A senior fire engineer at the UK's largest building inspector suspected Kingspan was 'concealing' failed fire tests before the Grenfell fire. It continued to accept the product for high rise buildings
The inquiry saw emails from NHBC fire engineer John Lewis where he described the use of combustible materials as "an accident waiting to happen" and a certificate claiming the product met the standard of 'limited combustibility' as "garbage"
He also said he had been told of a test on a system where Kingspan's insulation had burnt so fiercely flames had gone over the top of a 9m test rig. He said the company which had helped arrange the test had been threatened with legal action by Kingspan if they spoke about it
Mr Lewis said he "had strong suspicions that Kingspan were concealing failed test reports" and had "concerns" about the use of the product. But he added that refusing to accept it in untested systems would have caused a "storm" in the building industry
The inquiry continues with more from Mr Lewis tomorrow.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
A new email from the Grenfell Tower Inquiry shows government officials tapping up industry figures to act as 'independent experts' who would follow a 'pre-prepared script' to help rebut a critical news story in The Times. Two days after the fire.
Here's the email. To spell it out: this is the UK government attempting to feed its defensive line to figures the media would treat as 'independent experts' in the immediate aftermath of a shocking public tragedy in which the state is deeply implicated.
This happened on the same day that Gavin Barwell (then chief of staff at No 10) was chased down the street by reporters asking why he hadn't reviewed building guidance before the fire. They were under intense scrutiny.
First the private rented sector bits. I think the most interesting announcement is that all PRS homes will have to meet the decent homes standard. According to the most recent data, that's where the highest number of non-decent homes are
The estimate is around 20%, which is some 880,000 homes. Given the unregulated nature of the PRS, it's a safe bet that the true number is higher.
The big question (unanswered) is how the govt plans to enforce this. Cash strapped councils will struggle, to say the least
At around this time Kingspan K15 (a combustible plastic insulation) was the market leading brand for high rise buildings. But people in the industry were starting to ask questions about its fire safety. Was the one test which supported its use really adequate?
As a result, an organisation called the National House Building Council (NHBC) told Kingspan it needed to see more testing proving its suitability. The NHBC is a private firm which signs off new builds as compliant with regulations and also provides warranties for them
What is Gove proposing? For those who haven't seen the news over the weekend, he is saying the current £5.1bn of cladding funding will be extended by £4bn, to cover remediation costs in buildings between 11m and 18.5m.
But it will not come from new govt funding. Instead Gove wants to get the construction industry into a room, threaten them with tough legislation and make them pay up apparently voluntarily. There are some problems with this and a major cavaet we will get to in the 'ugly' section
The government is understood to be considering preventing Rydon Homes accessing the Help to Buy programme, due to Rydon's involvement in the Grenfell Tower refurbishment. A couple of thoughts below:
If enacted this would be the first major govt level sanction for any organisation involved in the Grenfell Tower fire. They have talked tough in the past, but have never matched it with action.
However, you would have to ask: why now? Bereaved and survivors group Grenfell United have been pushing for this exact move since 2019. Below is a letter they sent to Robert Jenrick in August 2020:
A pretty extraordinary morning just gone where we saw video footage from a January 2016 conference where a cladding fabricator warned of the wide-use of ACM (the cladding used on Grenfell) and the chair described it as a potential "ticking time bomb"
Audience member was Nick Jenkins, then of Euroclad. He warned that the material was in wide use in the UK and as a result "You could have an exact repeat of the Dubai fire in any number of buildings that we supply product to in London"
Steve Evans of the NHBC (largest building control body in the UK) was on the panel and agreed with Jenkins that an "anomaly" in official guidance this type of cladding "would meet the regulations". He told the inquiry today this was not his view and it was "badly worded"