I want to do a few tweets about common ventilation issues, but first I need to do an intro to the basic system - the RTU. It's essentially a home furnace with dampers. Here's what they look like:
1/14
This is a schematic of what it looks like inside. Here are the steps:
1. Air is returned from the space into the unit. 2. The exhaust damper - air leaves here. It's usually a backdraft damper. Air can only flow out and not in. It isn't motorized.
2/14
3. The mixed air dampers/economizer - these control the ventilation. When they are "open", it means the outdoor air damper is open and the return air damper is closed. This brings in 100% outdoor air. The return damper closing forces the air out through the exhaust damper.
3/14
When they are "closed" the outdoor air damper is closed and the return damper is open. 100% of the air is recirculated. No fresh air.
For safety, dampers always fail to the closed configuration.
4/14
4. After the dampers, the air is a mix of return and outdoor air, it passes through a replaceable bank of filters like in your home furnace. This catches dust and prevents it from clogging up the coils or being supplied to the space.
5/14
5. The air passes through a direct expansion (DX) cooling coil. It works similar to your furnace through compression and expansion of a refrigerant. When it's on, it cools down the air. 6. The air passes through a gas fired heating coil. When it's on, it heats up the air.
6/14
7. The fan is what pushes the air. 8. The air is supplied back to the space.
If it is computerized, there are usually 5 temperature sensors:
a. Space Temp (SPT)
b. Return Air Temp (RAT)
c. Outdoor Air Temp (OAT)
d. Mixed Air Temp (MAT)
e. Supply Air Temp (SAT)
7/14
How the temperatures work:
- If dampers are closed, MAT=RAT
- If dampers are open, MAT = OAT
- If heating and cooling are off, SAT=MAT
- cooling on, SAT < MAT
- heating on, SAT > MAT
SPT should be close to RAT, but due to stratification, RAT might be a bit higher.
8/14
Here's the general sequence of operations for the equipment:
Fan:
-always runs during occupied hours
-at night during the winter, the space temperature is allowed to get colder. If it gets too cold, the fan will turn on to heat the space (night setback).
9/14
-before occupancy, the fan will turn on early to heat up the space so when people arrive, it won't be cold. This is called optimal start or morning warmup.
-some places might have morning cooldown and night setback for cooling. Generally not common in Canada.
10/14
Cooling: when it's hot outside, if the space it too warm, turn on the cooling. Supply cold air to the zone until it's satisfied.
Heating: when it's cold outside, if the space it too cold, turn on the heating. Supply hot air to the zone until it's satisfied.
11/14
Dampers:
-when the fan is off or unoccupied (night setback or morning warmup), dampers are closed.
-during normal operation, dampers open to a position to provide the minimum amount of required air to the space.
12/14
-Free cooling/economizer mode: if it's cooler outside than inside and the space is too hot, the dampers open even more to cool down the space.
That's the basics. When all this is computerized, it's put on a building automation system (BAS). That's what I do for a living.
13/14
If you want to know the simple ways to improve the system, it's here.
- Not enough focus on ventilation and filtration.
- Delay in acknowledging COVID is airborne
- Lack of clear communication
- Ventilation reduces risk of transmission
- look for HEPA filters and places with CO2 levels < 800 ppm
- We need operation warp speed for clean indoor air. I credited @j_g_allen for this in the interview.
(I don't believe "people will die from other respiratory viruses" was my quote)
How did he get membership to ASHRAE? Between being a doctor, MPH with specialty in pulmonary medicine and associate prof, he got an engineering degree with 12 years HVAC experience? It's not listed anywhere. (I'm an associate member because I only have 11 years experience).
The new normal must be extreme airborne mitigation everywhere. Air quality experts need to be front and center. Imagine we had a new measles virus that caused brain damage and vaccines and natural immunity did not prevent infection.
1/3
HVAC mechanical engineers (who are responsible for ventilation) have a basic understanding of air quality, but know very little about airborne virus mitigation. The last virus people assumed was airborne was the measles and that hasn't been a societal threat since the '60s.
2/3
Most are unaware that electronic air cleaning doesn't work. Almost none have ever heard of upper room UVGI. We need indoor air quality standards. Air quality experts need to lead the way. Failing to emphasize that #COVIDisAirborne is preventing that.
3/3
I'm amazed that this concept exists. It's as if some doctors have pledged eternal loyalty to the vaccine and any additional measures are a form of adultery. It's absurd. Stop encroaching on engineering.
1/9
An engineer's perspective:
a. Especially with boost, vaccines are extremely effective against severe disease.
b. They are not effective long-term in preventing infection.
Because of this, many have said that only severe disease matters. It's not true. Here's why:
2/9
1. We've tried using a vaccine only approach. It's failed in every country that attempted it. 2. What about the immunocompromised, elderly and unvaccinated? 3. A vaccine only approach causes people to blame the pandemic on the unvaccinated. This can't continue.
3/9
A UV light is placed in the duct or by the coil of an air handling unit. It will kill virus particles being supplied to the zone.
I'm not in favor:
a. It can damage the filters
b. Better alternatives are: increasing outdoor air % and improving filtration.
2/20
c. Transmission through ducts is long range transmission. Shared room transmission is much higher risk. Better to focus on higher risk.
d. People in the industry have expressed skepticism to me of how
effective this actually is.
e. UV is more expensive than filtration.