A striking example of "behind the scenes" of great research: Esther Duflo noted that a crucial enabler of her Nobel-prize-winning work was a masterful synthesis of human resource economics in a handbook chapter.
I... think I tracked down the (141-page!!!) handbook chapter?
And it is indeed wonderful!
What a synthesis indeed of a conclusion!
Clearly identifying progress, and also crucial open problems, deeply grounded in a detailed analysis of the literature.
I wish I had such a synthesis for my fields of research also; and that everyone would have access to something like this!
#Idea - NLP to do initial clustering/classification of altmetric-aggregated discussion of preprints, to facilitate finding high-signal discussions and critiques of preprints (honestly would want this for any paper!).
Preprint servers already hook into @altmetric to expose mentions of a paper in news/blogs + social media (tweets).
But it links to an undifferentiated list of sources (not titles, citation contexts) - good for signaling "attention", missed opportunity to get real context.
If preprint servers have access to commercial API from @altmetric, classifying (and then clustering, enabling searching by) these mentions is eminently doable (e.g., can frame as a straightforward citation context classification problem, like with @scite and @SemanticScholar)
Started as a "short thread", turned into a longer thing. Hope you find it helpful!
There's been some good discussion on effective search as a core primitive for tools for thought, and the limitations of existing tools, such as @RoamResearch wrt search.
A delicious power of a #PKM (or Idea Development Environment): being able to effortlessly create joint attention with a collaborator over idea fragments (look at this graph, this design, this quote).
A picture (or concrete thing to look at) is worth 1000k words.
Also works for creating joint attention to converse with your past self.
Similarly, beautiful thread by [[Michael Nielsen]] on [[[[QUE]] - How can we measure everyday progress in open-ended creative work?]] and [[[[CLM]] - Paths to creative breakthroughs are frequently oblique]]