Dear Dr @julieposetti I am watching your #ijf22talk with @ranaayyub & I thought it best to #livetweet my analsyis of your talk as I watch it on my phone after downloading it.
I want to see if attendee of Nov2010 JEAA Sydney conference, who livetweeted then, did justice today!
Great setting, I must say Dr @julieposetti - looks like everything has been planned to perfection in such intricate details- backdrop of #ijf22talk, the colors incl color of costumes,JP & Rana are wearing & their seating arrangement in perfect contrast to make a visual impact!
As a trained Chartered Accoutnant with exp of forensic auditing, I can’t help but notice & give suggestions -howsoever stupid or idiotic it might sound -so here is one to Dr @julieposetti -the color of speaker’s podium shud have matched that of walls for grater impact #ijf22talk
Moving on to the intro part.
Dr @julieposetti, I wish #ijf22talk organisers had released transcript of both, talk as well as @ranaayyub address to those present in the hall & globally. It would have saved me lot of time & effort. Nonetheless,let me share my analysis of ur part!
- @ranaayyub is there not because “you demanded” but coz India is ruled under a constitution with rule of law & free courts. Our legal system even gave full freedom to 2611 perpetrator, Kasab who killed on camera, chance to prove himself not guilty!
Wow,how liberally can u folks in west use word genocide or potential genocide,Dr @julieposetti.You come from Australia & represents the race that invaded land of aboriginals, reducing them to museum piece;that is what genocide does.
FYI, Ind is home to 2nd largest M population!
And Dr @julieposetti , @ranaayyub is NOT being victimised for her faith ; she is being made to face a law for fraud of $236000. U shud read abt Rajan Pillai- India’s biscuit baron & his fate under @INCIndia Govt, while facing case of similar violation.
And Dr @julieposetti , I request you to at least read unbiased and neutral journalists of this country to know about the work of @ranaayyub; being propped up by likes of Soros & Berggruen will give u award and international fame but not credibility. Wish u had researched more!
Somewhere in your intro part, you claimed to have researched 85 million tweets directed at her. Need I remind you of one @julieposetti who attended a Nov 10 conference and was handed a defamation notice by Chris Mitchell for her 3 tweets? crikey.com.au/2010/12/02/pos…
Dear Dr @julieposetti do u remember the outpouring of support for urself then?Ever wonder why @ranaayyub doesn’t have that support & u had 85 million tweets to mine. Barring westerners running foundations on charity & questionable money & their folks,she has no one backing her!
Dr @julieposetti , by the way, u introduced @ranaayyub as an editor of a magazine. Surely, someone with ur journalistic credentials shud have bothered to check abt magazine- owner & EiC was once accused of rape by a girl, his daughter’s age & employee indiatoday.in/india/story/ta…
Dr @julieposetti , yes @ranaayyub has published a book but neither was that independent nor factual. You and your team could have searched the worldwideweb to check millions of references that expose each n every lie; even courts have proved every claim of hers as incorrect. Yet!
Dr @julieposetti, good that u ended , before putting any further context as there was none left for you to glorify, shamelessly so, a person like @ranaayyub. By the time u ended 113 seconds long intro, u buried @julieposetti of 2010,113 ft. under heap of propaganda full of lies!
Let me now check her speech part and come back to Dr @julieposetti with my thoughts on her speech. As a heads up and given my views of Rana, I know it will be torturous and painful but I promise to do it with my objectivity and sanity, intact!
Phew; 12 mins 22 secs!
Default message b4 everything she uttered in her speech shud b this 4 second clip!
Dr @julieposetti ,this speech is full of so many lies that courts will find it difficult to ignore her anymore-tied herself in knots with long rope that court gave her!
Uff… what a opening!
All my life I only thought that lie has no legs but now I know that lie wear long heel shoes on no legs!
BTW, @julieposetti, u shud have correlated these two parts- joined by me - to know how everything Rana says stands on ‘real’ shaky grounds!
Forgot to carry winter clothes but carried high 👠- is it a girly thing or perhaps both Dr @julieposetti & @ranaayyub knowing it in advance for reasons mentioned below. Either way a lame attempt & I trust Dr Posetti to ignore it; but will know only when I reach #ijf22talk part!
Topic of @julieposetti’s #ijf22talk- when the state attacks: journalism under fire in worlds biggest democracy!
Hee speech began with 1st concern - @MEAIndia ‘s abstention in the vote against Russia- ok now she wants India to vote as per her whims and fancies or of sponsors!
Glad that @ranaayyub miraculously recovered from polio & I req @WHO to make her a poster girl of their polio prog in Af-Pak so that Muslim parents don’t delay administration of pulse polio vaccines to their kids. I sincerely it was wasn’t that reason in her own case!
And I request Shri @mansukhmandviya Ji to appoint a committee in health ministry to study miraculous recovery of @ranaayyub from polio so that kids affected by this disease globally benefit from her experience. Pl @julieposetti convince her of this!
1. Did her father file any FIR to corroborate this? 2. Do read how this riot was NOT anti M riot but in retaliation after Hindu workers were stabbed & killed in M majority areas like Dongri & Hindus,incl a disabled girl was burnt alive.
BTW perfectly crafted story: a 9 years old Muslim survivor of polio being saved by a Sikh man, along with her sister, from rape by a Hindu mob on the rampage- painful reality is that her lies will keep on getting bigger n bigger with such conferences!
Here comes another lie and this time it is about our home minister Shri @AmitShah Ji ‘s false arrest in encounter of a terrorist Soharabuddin Sheikh! indiatoday.in/india/story/mo…
@julieposetti , I again implore you to READ, READ and READ to know how u all r aiding a compulsive liar!
Dear @HMOIndia , in no way should you allow a journalist to malign India and the institution of Home Minister of the country, in the way @ranaayyub did here. Courts must be asked to stop her from such baseless & false misrepresentations at int’l forum
Only thing that changed after ur self claimed undercover operation is that ur identity is NO LONGER FAKE and you now wear ur real identity everywhere u go, but this 12 min speech is enough to prove yet again- millionth time- that @ranaayyub remains a propagandist! #ijf22talk
Imagine she is lying abt not finding a publisher during days when UPA Govt was trying its level best to implicate then twice elected CM @narendramodi by hoisting fake cases on him, when his HM @AmitShah and ministers other ministers were sent behind bars in fake cases. #ijf22talk
That even Sonia Gandhi and Chidamabaram -who wud have launched a new publishing house to publish her book had it been true - didn’t support her,goes on to prove propaganda it must have been.
So much that one feel like respecting them for this!
Delhi High Court owe an answer to Indian public, Indian state and the office of the @PMOIndia for allowing this maligning of India by a known propagandist, found so, even by Supreme Court.
And Dr @julieposetti coming back to her book, here is Shoma Chaudhary, a known anti establishment journalist clearly contradicting Rana’s stand but seems facts don’t matter anymore in this!
Besides @julieposetti u need to check what India’s top court felt about this book,. This is from SC order and I’m deliberating quoting a publication that is opposed to current Govt to share this news as a proof of SC ruling caravanmagazine.in/law/appeal-sup…
Dr @julieposetti this part of proves she needs some serious mental health help instead of a platform like that of #IJF2022. She took only two names in her speech - PM @narendramodi & HM @AmitShah & it is clear she is calling elected leaders of India fascist,dictator & demagogues
Onus of allowing this mockery of India & Indian democracy-by using such derogatory language for its elected PM & HM- lies squarely on the judge who allowed her to travel despite knowing that her objection to PM/HM stands NOT on legal ground but her hate
This needs to be played and replayed before that judge of Delhi HC who allowed her- note the framing of this part, meant to link PM Modi with the alleged incident of that Hindu priest - even that incident was used fraudulently by her- @julieposetti read > republicworld.com/india-news/law…
What @ranaayyub hide from her audience and @julieposetti was that this same had a bounty of 28 lakhs issued on his head by Muslim and this was more of a retaliatory warning, although reprehensible!
Ms @julieposetti persecution is what aboriginals faced in Australia @ d hands of ur ancestors, wat Kashmiri Hindus had to face @ d hands of Muslim majority in Kashmir in 1990 and truthfully depicted by #TheKashmirFile not one that increases ur no to 220M
This woman needs some urgent mental assistance- is all I cud tell myself after listening to this part.
Basically here she is cunningly preparing a ground for the narrative that India need to be put under sanctions to avoid a potential genocide…. She is no longer treading that dangerous line but she is openly calling for waging a war on India
Delusional or mental or both!
Dear @julieposetti again I implore u to check this tweet of the police officer of the area, she is alluding to in this part- check this thread and I will let u decide if what she is trying to project is indeed true?
Dr @julieposetti, that 12 mins speech is full of lies,propaganda & falsehoods & ur talk about hee cannot be any objective. However what u have, via this talk, has done is that u made her into a Chris Mitchell of 12 years ago. Like him, her lies & falsehood will be defeated!
Lastly, @julieposetti, sorry to call it rudely, but u failed Julie Posetti of 2010 that took on Chris Mitchell of ABC. Or perhaps that was your job mandate. Either way, ur #ijf22talk was full of lies and false propaganda as u allowed ur guest to spread it unchecked!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD🧵: Madhu Kishwar vs Madhu Kishwar
When your 50-year-long compromised career is your biggest indictment!
Will you believe me, if I tell you that Kishwar was a Leftist Naxal when Naxalism peaked; became a Feminist when feminism peaked, was Anti-Ram Mandir when Hindutva was weak only to become pro-Hindutva warrior as BJP began ascending. Later she became pro @narendramodi when he was sure of winning in the run up to 2014.
And now, she Anti-Modi as she didn't get any favours, she was expecting on her own!
BTW, she had a small fling with UPA as well, writing "Dear Yasin Malik... With good wishes" after following Manmohan Singh's separatist engagement line post UPA's 2009 bigger mandate.
Hers is a story of wearing multiple identities in five decades: a smooth operator, bad liar and a worse propagandist- Lady Natwa
Let me first begin by sharing how I had warned about the intellectually fraudulent side of Madhu Kishwar way back in 2013 (check image 2).
Now that she has crossed all limits, the reality of this fraud @madhukishwar, who is hurling fake, baseless and motivated allegations against PM, @narendramodi must come out before everyone.
She has called PM Modi a "Satanic ruler," a "CIA plant," and a man with "personality disorders."
Let me remind everyone that in 2014, this same fraud wrote a 400-page book comparing the same PM Modi to Mahatma Gandhi, toured the country defending him, and fought for him so aggressively on television that the man she was attacking sued her for Rs 1 crore defamation. Now she is using allegations of that very man and as rejected by the SC to attack PM....
.....twelve years later.
Same person.
Same source.
Same allegations.
Nothing changed
........except her equation with power.
And the liar is basing her attacks on the SC-rejected allegations of the same Pradeep Sharma who sued her for defamation when she was defending Modi against him in 2013.....Again, same story repeats, same source, opposite sides, and 13 years apart.
What I am going to share is based on the court records, police FIRs, peer-reviewed academic papers, ED press releases, and her own published work.
It is important to set the record straight and for everyone to see.
Here comes a 🧵on the sordid saga of Madhu Kishwar with proofs at every stage!
KISHWAR's मौकापरस्ती PATTERN
Every major ideological shift in Kishwar's five-decade career has tracked where power, momentum, or institutional support was located at that time.
Not once has she been ahead of the curve. Consider this
>> She started as a Naxal sympathiser when Naxalbari was sweeping campuses.
>> She adorned the hat of a CPI(M)/SFI activist when the Left was the power centre.
>> She became a feminist leader through Manushi when the women's movement was cresting.
>> She was anti-Ram Janmabhoomi when Hindutva wasn't in power.
>> She turned pro-Hindutva when BJP started growing.
>> She followed UPA's separatist line after UPA won bigger in 2009.
>> She became Modi's biggest defender when his PM win was certain.
>> And now she turned into a most viciously lying attacker when the Rajya Sabha seat she expected never came.
Never ahead of the curve. Always riding it. And the moment the wave stopped carrying her, she found a new one.
KISHWAR'S NAXAL ORIGIN??
The woman who calls everyone "Urban Naxal" came from that exact world.
Two independent sources confirm her Naxal and CPI(M) origin.
Grokipedia documents her "participation in the Naxalbari movement and affiliation with the Communist Party of India (Marxist)."
Professor Shamsul Islam (Delhi University, The Quint 2020) independently confirmed that "Kishwar started her career with the Naxalbari movement and then went over to the CPM."
Two sources. Same conclusion. This is not anyone's allegation. This is documented record.
She was Miranda House Student Union President. SFI fielded her as DUSU candidate in 1972 (per Sunday Guardian). Later, she moved to JNU where Left was dominant in politics.
Her entire formative political education was in the CPI(M)/SFI ecosystem.
And today she has the audacity to call others "Urban Naxal." Madam, aap toh khud wahi se aayee hain!
And @NMenonRao, in her true parasitic self of a compromised Indian elite (most of them are like that actually) has exposed herself yet again……for the nth time…..
Before I start, let me tell you that Rao gets hefty pension at the cost of Indian taxpayers but always works for her real masters……ever since her famous Fujimori party escapade when rebels stormed Peruvian party thrown by then Peruvian President!
Man, this woman is a parasite to the core & sadly no vaccine exists to deal with parasites like hers!
Let me begin by requesting everyone to NOT make the mistake of reading @NMenonRao - @HinaRKhar exchange at face value.
If you do, you simply haven't understood how six decades of subcontinental geopolitics has always worked until @narendramodi happened in 2014 and the rules changed forever.
So what got exposed in reality- well this is something I would call "The Elite Asymmetry".
Often I have written about it because we Indians need to see the real games that are being played behind the scenes and how major section of the Indian elite has always sacrificed our interest at the altar of fellowships, think tank postings or western scholarships for their kids and themselves .
Rao-Khar exchange just proved it once again!
As against what @sushantsareen wrote, the exchange between Rao-Khar makes the fundamental difference between the Pakistani and Indian elite class crystal clear........
This phenomenon rarely gets discussed as it is carefully hidden under the cloak of appi jhappi punjabified nostalgia. Sadly, this is how our diplomacy played out on the world stage for longest of times and is the pain point of Rao as well.
Pakistan's elite, regardless of tone, stage, or audience, ALWAYS works in the direction of its state's strategic interest.
Compared to them, significant section of India's elite spends its energy working against its own government.
Chalo, samjhte hain kaise...
Congress and its supporters never tire of boasting about having a Cambridge PhD economist as PM while mocking PM @narendramodi's humble origins at the same time.
Well, since data doesn't lie so let us check 20 years of data on India's oil economy to find who ran India's ₹30 LAKH CRORE oil economy better : PM with Cambridge PhD degree or a PM with humble origins and who also sold chai once at the railway station...
Thread follows!
To set the context, let us look at what Cambridge educated PM inherited in 2004 from a Pracharak PM Vajpayee after his 6 years rule:
In line with Kelkar committee's recommendations, Vajpayee govt dismantled Administered Pricing Mechanism (APM) and made petrol pricing market linked.
Prices in Delhi when UPA took over:
☑️ Petrol: ₹33.71/L
☑️ Diesel: ₹21.74/L
☑️ LPG: ₹241/cylinder
Remember these numbers as they will tell you the reality of Cambridge educated PM the best!
How many of you that know that-
1) Despite APM being formally dismantled, Manmohan's government effectively brought back government controlled pricing through the back door? Yes you heard it right. 2) Instead of letting market pricing work (as ABV govt intended), UPA forced OMCs to sell below cost, thus creating massive "under-recoveries," and then compensated them by issuing oil bonds effectively kicking the bill to the future.
So by the time Manmohan Singh was kicked out by the voters in 2014, prices in Delhi rose to
If you ever happen to be near Astley Hall, Dehradun, pls find her and buy stuff from her to support her. She told me she sells variety of stuff until 11:30 night.
I felt I found her as I needed to meet one to help me extract out of the general disenchantment creeping within me
I had a brief chat with her after she approached me. I found something of my use in her box; more importantly I was interested in hearing her story. She is from Delhi, lives in a rented accommodation as both her sons died n now supports her by selling variety stuff to shop goers
Life is extremely uncharitable on some - but then it is the tenacity and the will that helps overcome problems one faces. To me, the highlight was the way she narrated her story with a smile on her face, with acceptance and recognition of her state, written over it.
Since last year, @AjiHaaan and I have been tracking role of Germany and how it is meddling in Indian affairs. Consider few points and everything is verifiable:
1. Harsh Mander spent close to a year in Germany on the pretext of some study. 2. German State TV has been running propaganda against India and esp Modi govt for long. Infact DW has produced anti Modi documentaries. 3. Germany tried to meddle into Indian affairs several times - be it during farm law agitation or via its utterances on Kashmir when their FM shared stage with Bhutto. 4. And lastly, Dhruv Rathi is in Germany and is spearheading a propaganda against Indian govt. Simply impossible to do all that circular jacking up of video views to push his narrative without some agency support.
Note how this comparison of video views theme/narrative to determine popularity of leaders and journalist began last year and is single most criteria today to push this compromised man. Surely he is working for German agency!