As Europe is yet again left with a fascist dictator dreaming of resurrecting an empire, let’s talk Victory Day in Russia and Ukraine.
To understand modern Russian identity and how the invasion of Ukraine perfectly fits into it, you have to take a close look at the #VictoryDay.
It might surprise a lot of people, but the Soviet Victory Day was not nearly as big as it is in modern Russia.
In fact, Victory Day in Russia is basically what independence day means for most other nations.
Victory Day provides a perfect bridge between the imperial, Soviet, and d modern-day Russia. It also feeds the unresolved imperialist ambitions of Russia.
Folks, it’s a death cult.
I can’t stress enough how undermining Russian version of Victory Day for the rest of former Soviet states and allies.
Ukraine’s relevance and human sacrifice in defeating the Nazis is one of the most widely ignored aspects of WWII discourse.
There is little joy for Ukraine in the WWII story. It’s a huge tragedy.
Of course, if you create a cult of war, sooner or later you’re gonna find a war to fight. Just call some people “Nazis” enough times and you’re good.
Kindly reminder that the Z-symbol and glorification of modern-day Russia basically means open support for the genocide of Ukrainians.
#NeverAgain now has dark undertones because a fascist war of extermination is here again, in Europe.
But it’s not too late to act.
Support for Ukraine is crucial right now.
If you want your donation to have a real impact, I urge you to donate to my dear friend @bo_pavlo who’s been volunteering 24/7 to supply Ukrainian defenders with drones.
Donate here: 100drones.com.ua
Feel free to download and post/send these cards wherever you want (but please tag or message me if you do): drive.google.com/drive/folders/…
More cards are available on the Ukraine Explainers website: uaexplainers.com
Thanks! End of 🧵
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
My grand theory of why American and W European cultural establishments love Russian anti-regime stories is because they all view storytelling as the main act of resistance.
They don’t like talking about solutions to hard problems. They’d rather keep talking about the problems 1/
in ever more subtle and meta ways. They favor “complex” stories with “nuance” that don’t tell the audience clear answers.
It’s all discourse for these people, and participating in this discourse without any practical impact is seen as the most righteous thing to do.
This is 2/
very different from how Ukrainians view storytelling in the middle of the war.
If a chid is murdered by a Russian missile, Ukrainians tell that story to do their small bid in preventing another child getting killed.
We deal with life/death scenarios everyday and learn to 3/
We are yet to see what kind of deal Trump strikes with Putin.
But it’s clear what kind of strategy the US is pursuing: Trump wants to reach some form of ceasefire, possibly get some juicy rare mineral deals out of Ukraine and be fully done with this part of the world.
1/9
No strategic deterrence of an increasingly hostile adversary.
No support for a democracy under attack.
Zero care for the security of America’s biggest trade partners in the region – partners it had pledged to defend for decades.
2/9
With America’s full or partial withdrawal from Ukraine, there’s only one path left that ensures my home survives the next decade: the revival of Europe.
Something’s changing on the maps
of Europe right now.
It’s subtle change that only a trained eye can see.
As a Ukrainian, I never had the privilege of not noticing what the map of Europe looked like in every book or movie. On too many of those maps, Ukraine wasn’t included. 1/
Ukraine’s absence always communicated a bitter sense of invisibility. Here I was, sitting in Kyiv, a capital of a dynamic democracy bordering four EU countries.
And yet, apparently, I was not in Europe. Together with my forty million compatriots, I was stuck in a non-place.
2/
Borders mean much more to the people who inhabit them, and Ukrainians are one of Europe’s key border folk.
We have always been, as Serhiy Plokhy put it, “the gates of Europe”: from the spread of Indo-Europeans to the Mongolian invasion and to modern Russian aggression.
3/
My hot take: Ukraine’s Maidan was a pretty standard pro-democratic revolution for Central/Eastern Europe.
Similar revolts led to democracy fully prevailing in other countries — and didn’t lead to wars and mass devastation.
Do you know why? One word: Russia.
1/
When pro-democracy movements swept Central/Eastern Europe in the 1980s/1990s, Soviet Union was in decline and then Russia was deep in internal crises.
So these nations could peacefully sort their politics out and transition into western democracies.
Ukraine wasn’t so lucky.
2/
Georgia and Ukraine had their democratic turning points exactly when Russia was fully back into its usual autocratic empire state — so our revolutions were met with direct military aggression from Russia in 2008 and 2014 respectively.
3/
I know some are getting tired of the Russians at War movie scandal at @TIFF_NET
I get it.
I don’t like canceling stuff — especially when there are more practical ways to help Ukraine (like helping its armed forces).
But this is an exception.
This is a teachable moment.
🧵
The backlash against the funding and promotion of Trofimova’s Russians at War movie by Canadian institutions is not caused by hurt feelings or anti-Ru censorship.
It’s caused by western institutions getting easily exploited by Russian propaganda campaigns — which has to stop.
2/
As of today, here’s how the situation looks:
Trofimova, who spent 7 years working for Kremlin’s top propaganda network, got hundreds of thousands of Canada’s public money to film a movie showing Russian soldiers in ordinary, empathetic light.
3/