Josh Gerstein Profile picture
Jul 21 14 tweets 3 min read
COURT RESUMING at Bannon trial: This morning we learned Bannon won't testify and defense doesn't plan to put on any case. Judge now hearing defense presentation about why they needed Jan. 6 panel chairman Bennie Thompson or other members as witnesses
Judge Nichols again reminds that he threw out Bannon's main potential defenses because he thought they are precluded. Nichols: 'I was bound by D.C. Circuit precedent that I’m not even sure is right.'
Schoen now trying to explain why Bannon needed Thompson and perhaps other #J6 committee members and the 1 panel staffer witness (Chief Counsel Kristen Amerling) wasn't sufficient
Judge is pointing out whatever Thompson thought, Bannon didn't know so it couldn't have affected his thoughts on the subpoena. Nichols: 'The letter is the letter. What does Mr. Thompson's testimony tell us about Mr. Bannon's mens rea?'
Schoen is arguing that Bannon should be able to question Thompson about motivations for subpoenaing Bannon and even on overall structure of committee. Seems doubtful judge will decide to second guess committee or that jury should've been able to do so
Legal question now is whether denying access to House members incl. Thompson & Pelosi so undermined Bannon's defense as to deny him fair trial and Confrontation Clause rights
Prosecutor Vaughn up now, says most of what defense is asking for is 'irrelevant.' 'The through line of everything Mr. Schoen said that they wanted is relay just trying to get at the personal motives of members.'
Her rebuttal to Schoen is very brief. Only 5 minutes. Vaughn: 'Mr. Schoen talked for a long time.' We're done with arguments. He will rule later. We're moving on to jury instructions. We just learned 1 juror was excused for health reasons.
Now discussing logistics and whether closings can happen today. Corcoran wants to do in morning. Vaughn looks forlorn
Schoen reads statement explaining why Bannon isn't testifying. 'He has very much wanted to do so since the day he was indicted...' But says rulings precluding defenses undercut reason to do so. Defendant Bannon speaks briefly agreeing he decided not to. Bannon: 'Yes, your honor.'
Vaughn proposes cautioning jury not to watch House J6 hearing tonight, but judge isn't going to explcitly do that. Jury going to be brought in and then sent home to hear closings in morning.
Jury being led in at 2:31 PM. 1st time they've been in court today.
Defense just rested w/o calling witnesses, as advertised earlier politi.co/3OktjcV
Judge warning jury again not to talk to others about case. Not watch TV media etc about case 'and related matters.'... 'I want to thank you very much for your patience today.....Sometimes those discussions are helpful in ways that will improve the case as it goes to you tomorrow'

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Josh Gerstein

Josh Gerstein Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @joshgerstein

Jul 22
Gaston: This case is not complicated but it is important. This is a simple case about a man, that man, Steve Bannon, who didn’t show up....When it really comes down to it, he did not want to recognize Congress’ authority or play by the government’s rules.'
Nichols in jury instructions and just told jurors that neither executive privilege nor any other legal claim is a valid defense to the charged crime--a key issue in the case. Now prosecution beginning closing arguments.
Gaston scoffs at defense claims he may have been confused about the deadline or what he had to do. Showing subpoena on TV, she says: 'This document is not hard to understand.' Of his failure: 'Was that a mistake? No, that was intentional.'
Read 15 tweets
Jul 22
HAPPENING NOW: Jury instructions & closing arguments about to get underway at Steve Bannon contempt of Congress trial. Looks like AUSA Molly Gaston will deliver the govt closing (at least 1st part). Earlier: politi.co/3OktjcV
Bannon's lawyers just filed notice about House #jan6 committee's mentions of Bannon last night, including audio from @MotherJones of Bannon predicting before 202 election that Trump would contest it even if he lost. Defense has said this could infect jury and wants some inquiry
That filing: bit.ly/3zqn4A3 Judge Nichols taking bench now
Read 5 tweets
Jul 21
HAPPENING NOW: Bannon trial getting underway at US Dist Court in DC. Preliminaries as we await jury. Govt rested yesterday. Unclear whether defense plans to present any case. Discussing now timing of various motions and closing. politi.co/3PDbTJu
Judge now discussing whether it was proper for defense to say in front of jury that defense planned to move judge to dismiss case. Common motion but not commonly raised in front of the jury.
Def. atty Corcoran: 'We don't think that passing comment in front of the jury was prejudicial' to either party. But judge says it may have been prejudicial to Bannon b/c assuming Nichols turns down the motion then jury may think he's validated government case
Read 9 tweets
Jul 20
NEW: Judge vows Bannon trial won't become 'political circus' after defense argued to jury that all evidence in case may be tainted by politics. No discussion in court of Bannon railing outside against #J6 committee & trial decisions. w/@kyledcheney politi.co/3PDbTJu
@kyledcheney Prosecution has finished questioning House #J6 counsel Kristin Amerling and cross-examination by Bannon's lawyers just began. Def atty Evan Corcoran begins by asking her to confirm this case doesn't involve any claim that Bannon took part in events of 1/6/21.
Corcoran just asked if committee used typewriters or computers to prepare subpoenas. Guess the answer? Then we had this riveting exchange: Q: Did you type in that date? A: I don’t recall, sir.
Read 6 tweets
Jul 20
HAPPENING NOW: Bannon trial back underway. Prosecution, apart from jury, is asking judge to stop Bannon's lawyers from arguing that the case is motivated by politics.
We covered that here: politi.co/3v1zvzv AUSA Vaughn says defense evading pretrial order not to raise political bias claims other than about specific witnesses: 'I think there is a clear record now that the defendant plans to skirt this court’s order.'
Def atty Corcoran: 'That’s not our intention.' So far, no discussion of Bannon's tirade outside court yesterday afternoon towards House #J6 committee and against alleged unfairness of trial, imploring panel members to show up and testify.
Read 6 tweets
Jul 19
NEW: Bannon contempt-of-Congress case bogs down over evidence, prompting judge to consider delaying opening arguments. Jury pool stews as lawyers & judge wrangle. w/@kyledcheney politi.co/3v1zvzv
@kyledcheney We're back in session now. Defense says that, given rulings admitting the House J6-Costello letters at least in part, Bannon says whole letters would come in.
This means that jurors would see the thrust of Bannon's executive privilege arguments but would be instructed by Nichols not to consider the substance of those.
Read 20 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(