This is your daily pension announcement. The Pension War Room™️reveals the 💣bombshell💣 from the @aimcoinvests Annual Report. The pension plans, presumably LAPP, SFPP, and PSPP, are suing AIMCO for $1.33 billion dollars. WOW. This is for compensation for the VOLTS losses. #AbLeg
Let me explain. Notes to these financial statements are super important where AIMCO is required to reveal **significant** financial details. One can surmise that the pension plans are alleging that @aimcoinvests was grossly negligent in executing the VOLTS strategy. #AbLeg
If you sign an investment management agreement with @aimcoinvests you agree that if you sue the you don't do it in Queen's Bench but rather you go to arbitration. So that is where we are at: as I type this in some law office in Edmonton this hearing is happening right now.
What is precedent setting is the amount: $1.3 billion with a B dollars (all numbers in the Note are in thousands). That is twice @aimcoinvests annual budget. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
What is worse is that AIMCO is wholly owned by the Government of Alberta. Travis being the responsible Minister of TBF at the time.
So if AIMCO loses this hearing, either in whole or in part, the GOA will have to write a cheque from taxpayers to cover the gross negligence.
That is nasty. It is also one of the reasons you don't have investment managers that are solely owned by governments. The GOA picks up all liabilities from AIMCO as their owner. #ABLeg
This hearing is held in secret. The decision is likely secret with binding nondisclosure agreements on all parties. This is wrong, the worst of GOA secrecy.
However, whatever the decision is will come out in financial statements eventually... #AbLeg
Travis, as you will remember, was the Minister at all material times. He did **checks notes** NOTHING. He allowed the AIMCO Board to conduct an inquiry into itself.
I can't wait for @SPhillipsAB to let er rip in question period on this very topic.
I have been asked to give my assessment of likelihood of success of this arbitration hearing.
I have no inside information. But, my opinion is that AIMCO responsible in a significant way. Like hundreds of millions dollars at least.
As you can imagine, I will be discussing this issue all week.
Not being represented in any way on the @aimcoinvests Board we must seek accountability through Twitter. #AbLeg
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is your daily pension announcement. The Pension War Room™️celebrates irony day today as an official Alberta holiday. No richer gift of irony than Jason and Travis WRONGLY asserting that the GOA guarantees your pension then having to pay to cover AIMCO misdeeds. #ABLeg
So right now in a top secret arbitration hearing LAPP, SFPP, and PSPP are asking for compensation for the billions in loss at @aimcoinvests as a result of the VOLTS fiasco. To be precise, asking for a combined $1.33 billion dollars plus costs. Since AIMCO is owned by the GOA....
The GOA would be responsible for paying any award. Making the pension plans "whole" if you will. Remember, despite what Travis said, your pension is in no way guaranteed by the GOA but rather is guaranteed by the assets of the plan. Assets matter! #ABLeg
This is your daily pension announcement! The Pension War Room™️is scandalized that the former @aimcoinvests CEO Kevin's severance pay adds up to over $10 million dollars! How much do you have to hate him to pay him a cool $10 million to go away? #AbLeg
Kevin made between $2.5-$3.0 million per year at @aimcoinvests so severance of that amount might be expected since he only had a few months left on his contract. But $10 million? C'mon that is just egregious. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
Of course @aimcoinvests is "quasi-independent" preferring to be independent on some things like executive compensation and preferring to be a government organ on other things like client relations. #AbLeg#handsoff
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️again notes that @aimcoinvests does not publish a schedule of investments in their Annual Report. So you need to rely on Twitter when something goes wrong. Read it and weep. #AbLeg theglobeandmail.com/business/artic…
I would also like to take this opportunity to remind you of the words of Athana Mentzelopolous Deputy Minister of Treasury Board and Finance when justifying forcing the pension plans to stick with @aimcoinvests#AbLeg (June 23, 2020)
“Bill 22 was developed to forestall the possibility that each of the pension funds could ... develop unique pension management ... capacity resulting in overlap, duplication, growing cost, elimination of existing economies of scale and potentially outsourcing outside of Alberta".
This is your daily pension announcement: As the decomposers set in on the last of Jason Kenney's government The Pension War Room™️rejoices that more Annual Reports are out! LAPP for instance. #AbLeg lapp.ca/page/annual-re…
LAPP is now 124% funded! After the good year @aimcoinvests this spells contribution rate reduction! For once in its 13 year history @aimcoinvests exceeded the return target of LAPP. Hopefully it doesn't take another 13 years for it to happen again. #AbLeg
LAPP paid @aimcoinvests $542 million to manage the investments. Almost double what they paid the year before.
This isn't necessarily a problem, as I have explained many times, the narrow cost only argument of Travis and Athans is disingenuous and wrong. #AbLeg
The Pension Hawk™️is once again circling the carrion that is Treasury Board and Finance to bring you today's announcement.
The @aimcoinvests Board used to be a pest house for PCAA connected appointees. Ah, the good 'ol boys. #AbLeg
Did they have Alberta's best interest at heart? Maybe. Were they the best for a multi-billion dollar pension fund? Nope.
Board member selection for AIMCO has certainly evolved. You wouldn't know it because Travis has not publicly talked about anything to do with it. #AbLeg
It is bad to have a board that is deeply connected to the politics of AB investing the retirement savings of workers. This process needs to be non-political.
When Rachel became Premier the Board Chair of @aimcoinvests (Mac) offered to resign. #AbLeg For example.
This is your daily pension announcement. The Pension War Room™️continues to act in place of a hog manure pump. AIMCO total return was 14.7% last year and ATRF returned 15.6%.
Yet these numbers tell us very little about performance.#handsoffmypension
Short time periods are unreliable, as well we need to separate out the skills of the portfolio manager from the movement of the general market. We would do this by looking at the 10-year value add above the benchmark return (think index fund). #AbLeg
The 10 year value add at ATRF is 0.8%.
The 10 year value add for AIMCO's balanced fund (mainly pensions) is 0.5%.
Most pension funds have a value add target of around 0.7% to 0.85% depending on risk. This is the information that should have been in the "business case". #AbLeg