When ever I try to draw people's attention to the social evils that #homeschooling may intentionally or unemotionally promote, I get the word the word 'parental choice' thrown at me!
It seems that the parents have the right to choose how to educate their children and therefore you should not discourage a parent who exercises that right to choose #homeschooling, they tell me!
Up until 60s and 70s, in USA, it was illegal to keep children at home, in all 50 states. The Governments insisted that parents must send their children to schools, instead of keeping them at home.
In 1925, the Society of Sisters went to court against Oregon’s Compulsory Education Act 1922. The Act insisted that parents send their children to public schools instead of homeschooling them or sending them to religious schools.
In 1972, Yoder from the Old Order Amish, a group of traditionalist Anabaptist Christian church, went to court asking for permission to send children to school only after Grade 8.
Both the parties argued the case based on 'the parent's right to choose'
Remember, both cases were sponsored by the Church!
What is the interest of the Church, the most anti-choice organization in the world, about the parents' right to choose? (Remember, the church does not encourage people to choose - for example the right to choose abortion!)
I think a similar theme is playing out in India. The Right to Education Act clearly states that children under 18 must be sent to schools. Yet, we have Venture Capitalists pumping in money on CSR funded initiatives that advocate #homeschooling.
I think it is important for us to evaluate their political inclinations and social leanings, apart from their pro-parent choice and pro-open-source cover before we buy their homeschool-charity story! #Thread↓↑
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
When I say that #homeschooling will eventually embed caste-system, am I not seeing the 100000s of kids who get bullied in schools in the name of disabilities and abilities and either need traditional schools to be inclusive or need homeschooling?
As someone who had faced bullying in school (both from teachers & peers!), I can assure you I see them first when I disagree with our current enthusiasm around making homeschooling mainstream and pitching it as a better option than schools.
Research has already established that the best approaches to schooling are the ones that encourage healthy parent-school partnerships around the life of a child trying to learn.
Some people want to promote #homeschooling that will eventually embed caste system back in India because they feel Indian schools unfairly promote class-system and class-discrimination based on parental income.
1. They clearly seems to have not attended their Social Science 101 lessons.
The struggle against caste, class, racial, color discrimination is a perpetual struggle. What they do not know is our common schools are at the forefront of these struggles, against odds!
2. When India introduced RTE and allowed 25% 'poor' children to attend a private school near them for free, it was the upper-middle class parents who were up in arms against it, not schools. Imagine, you are pushing the same parents to do #homeschooling!
Whenever I come across an attempt to promote #homeschooling in India, I feel compelled to discourage it as a responsible citizen and a conventional educator. Since this video is no different, here is another 'homeschool-bashing' #thread. #Thread↓
#Note @SamrajSanjana & @aramanujaa are great tweeple to follow. I am merely voicing my disagreement with the idea of #homeschooling in India here, and it has nothing against them, personally. They are amazing people, from what I know about them so far. #Thread↓↑
#Clarification
My 'resistance' to #homeschooling in India is not the mere fear of a 'traditional' teacher about a new and revolutionary education movement. Like many of you, I loved the idea of the possibility of #homeschooling in India when I first heard about it. #Thread↓↑