Tania Melnyczuk Profile picture
Sep 22, 2022 31 tweets 7 min read Read on X
PRACTICAL PROJECT FOR REFORM-MINDED BCBAs WHO WORK WITH AUTISTIC PEOPLE [THREAD]

#BehaviorAnalyst #BCBA #ABA
I'm a member of the #BanABA movement. We believe that Applied Behaviour Analysis should not be the basis of any nonconsensual therapy for autistic people. We want this type of therapy to be declared unlawful.
Some of us who are part of the #BanABA movement do also talk to ABA professionals who are interested in reforming ABA (even though we believe that ABA-based approaches like EIBI are fundamentally flawed, rather than just broken).
In a discussion group specifically focused on REFORM, some of us were told that we don't focus enough on that subject, and keep veering off to talk about ABOLISHING ABA.
At the same time, we don't see significant action towards reform being led by BCBAs or other ABA professionals who say they're keen on reform.
It would appear that perhaps BCBAs don't know where to begin, and that they are pottering around with tweaks to how they deal with individual clients.

These types of small actions are not reforming ABA. This is just improving your personal practice in a niche of a niche.
So I decided to go there. I decided to propose a practical project that reform-minded ABA professionals could undertake, since they believe that their field can be reformed.
In the light of what I perceived to be an unspoken 'OK, so tell us what reform you want then', I have a recommended reform project for BCBAs which I describe below.
This is the kind of action that we would expect from real reformers who are serious about changing the profession.
Thousands of autistic people (including myself) would still like to see the abolition of nonconsensual ABA-based interventions for autistic people.
However, if BCBAs were to undertake this reform project, there would be great and encouraging changes in the lives of many people. They can expect some support from autistic people even if we agree to disagree on many other things.
(To autistic people: Feel free to propose a different project if you think there is anything more important or impactful that BCBAs should be working on right now to bring about reform—more important than the project I describe below.)
Here are the high level tasks and guidelines for the project. Focus items/actions are numbered for ease of reference.
1 - Lobby for the banning of skin shock torture at the JRC. Have a campaign for this, e.g. "BCBAs Against Skin Shock (BASS)". #StopTheShock
2 - Write a personal position statement or manifesto, or a position statement on behalf of your organisation and publish or circulate it.
3 - If you're American, contact senators to vote against CESS. Hold Webinars to encourage other BCBAs to join the campaign.

neuroclastic.com/justice/ban-el…
4 - Expose the people involved in this—the torturers, the torture designers, the people lobbying to retain the torture.
4 continued - Name them, but don't dox them. Expose their affiliations, influences and conflicts of interest in ABAI, SABA, the Accreditation Board, and various academic institutions where they work.
4 continued - Question their academic works, especially their studies involving the use of extreme punishment.
4 continued - Write critiques, citing human rights standards, and also focus on effectiveness of punishment-based interventions, referencing existing papers from other disciplines (e.g. on the problems and relative accuracy of the results obtained via torture research).
5 - Question their other research in the light of their ethics. Write essays in journals, write Twitter threads, write public statements on Facebook or blogs.
5 continued - Cite formally published works, such as the work of Dr. K. Bottema-Beutel (@KristenBott). You could also read up about the Doogri method developed by Dr. H. Kupferstein (@HennyKtweets) for critiquing autism research, to see if it would help.
6 - Expose the tacit supporters of the torturers, such as prominent academics in ABA who feel that there cannot be a pronouncement on the effectiveness of extreme punishment until there has been more research.
6 continued - Expose the institutions that stand neutral at a time when people should choose a side. Do not use ad hominems or other forms of slander against the torturers and their supporters.
7 - Propose changes to regulations and ethics frameworks introduced to the ABA profession via its various affiliate and commercial bodies (ABAI, QABA, BACB, CARD, etc.).
7 continued - Propose explicit consequences for the perpetrators for officially or unofficially implementing extreme forms of punishment in their personal or institutional ABA practices.
8 - Write statements against seclusion and restraint. If you don't know much about what to say here, contact ICARS (@ICARSBanRandS) or the Alliance Against Seclusion and Restraint (@endseclusion). They'll gladly help you.
8 continued - If you need training in alternatives to seclusion and restraint, consider Studio III (@studioIII) and Foundations for Divergent Minds (@FDMorg) for ideas to inform your own approach.
@studioIII @FDMorg 9 - Lobby the BACB to strip all BCBAs, BCBA-Ds and other BACB-credentialed professionals at the Judge Rotenberg Center of their credentials.
10 - For 50 years, the ABA industry and its professional bodies have proven themselves incapable of self-governance to protect human rights. This is YOUR industry, BCBAs. If you want to reform it, it's up to YOU. We can support and encourage you, but we can't do this for you.
Who is going to stand up to lead this powerfully?

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tania Melnyczuk

Tania Melnyczuk Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ekverstania

Oct 25
Man, this is an interesting exchange. Many people are disadvantaged in this kind of situation: most of us don't have the full set of weapons and skills—body language, posture, tone, eye contact, reading the other guy's responses, quick thinking. This guy has… a lot.
The argument wasn't won entirely on logic and words. The squeaky guy was discombobulated and allowed himself to be overpowered. The use of the chair was masterful. This whole scene could be analysed by students in a drama class.
Squeaky was like, “OK, I am not getting a chance to come in with a considered response, so let me just allow this person to go off on a tirade and end up looking stupid”—except his tactic backfired, as the big guy ended up spouting a whole lot of good points—
Read 57 tweets
Apr 20
What these people are advocating is child abuse. I know the way they put it doesn't sound bad, but this is about a very controlled, clinically callous form of manipulation. I'll drop some more links below so you can understand the context.
What they're advocating is based on the principles of Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA). Here's what that's about:

autisticstrategies.net/nonspeaking-au…
Someone who refers to behaviour as 'attention-seeking' is highly likely to negatively judge people who need, deserve and ask for attention—like this:
Read 9 tweets
Feb 17
[THREAD]
Why is it so hard for people in the field of ABA to improve the field, even with the support of autistic activists? One of the reasons is this:
Powerful people in the industry will try to destroy you for listening to autistic people, for trying to do a job compassionately, and for calling out the abuse.
I'm going to ask Jennilee Sunshine, a BCBA, whether I might tell her story here verbatim. It's already public on Facebook.
Read 57 tweets
Nov 17, 2023
Vladimir Putin's standard modus operandi is to make agreements and then demonstrate his power by breaking them with impunity.
Any suggestion that Ukraine should negotiate a settlement with Russia is borne either out of ignorance of this long track record, or out of ill logic, naïvete and stupidity (like, "I know, but I'm sure it won't happen again") or straight-up support for Russia.
Ukraine must WIN this war. Its allies are wasting time, money and lives, and strategic opportunities by holding back the support that's needed for victory. Ukraine has more than proven itself to be deserving.
Read 17 tweets
Jul 13, 2023
[THREAD] Request to
#BCBA
#BehaviorTwitter #BehaviorAnalyst #BehaviorAnalysis

Content warning: ABA, child abuse

The following account was posted in an ABA survivor group. I have permission to share it to ask what this person can do to stop the abuse.

1/x
"I have step kids that are currently in the custody of their maternal grandparents. Dcf is involved and put the youngest in ABA (I have no say in her care as of now, and neither do her parents)."

2/x
"When I was over at their house most recently, I heard her crying and went to go see what was going on, her ABA therapists pulled me aside and told me we were now ignoring her when she cries until she calms herself down and uses a happy voice."

3/x
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(