🧵We had an amazing time at #CJDDemocracySummit yesterday for the launch of the inspiring @C4JDHowardU. Here is a thread of some of the greatest insights from speakers and panel discussions. Congratulations to @nhannahjones and her amazing team. 1/
Counter to the emerging national media narrative that election liars were soundly defeated and barriers to the ballot box were overcome, @SIfill_ warned that the threat is not over. Until there is legislation preventing racial gerrymanders, they will not be stopped. 2/
We'll also point out the extremely obvious here that while it is true that @katiehobbs got roughly 1.28 million votes, lying extremist Kari Lake got roughly 1.26 million votes. Moving forward it will be absurd and dangerous for mainstream, corporate media to downplay threats. 3/
Political scientist, Steven Levitsky, warned that the anti-democracy MAGA movement would be with us for years to come. We agree. Journalists with morals must counteract the ubiquity of decontextualized, half-baked narratives like this from @azcentral 4/ azcentral.com/story/opinion/…
Levitsky also relayed, from his experience studying Latin America, that the American people must be ready for anything, including violence. He pointed out that normally leaders who attempt and fail at self-coups meet disgrace and isolation. DJT just announced his 2024 run. 5/
.@jasonintrator, noting that journalists are teachers, outlined 5 ways journalists could help the public reject propaganda. 1) Call attention to patterns (changing the topic to crime) 2) No false equivalencies (as when Fox compares 1/6 to BLM) 3) Pay attention to the world...
6/
3) cont... (propaganda here originates from, or has analogues in, other countries) 4) Attention economy (were momentarily distracted but believe he meant be wary of the oxygen and space you give to propaganda) 5) No such thing as neutral language 7/
Either @ruthbenghiat or @jasonintrator made the point that using words like "fascism" or "authoritarianism" means confronting those things. We wonder what US journalists can do in their newsrooms to push for more forceful language. Because journalists MUST confront fascism. 8/
.@jasonintrator made the point that local journalism is the cure to propaganda. It can build trust with readers that national media cannot. We couldn't agree more. If you can, and you have one, sign up for at home delivery of your local newspaper or otherwise donate. 9/
It occurred to us while @SIfill_ was speaking that if, instead of a woefully inadequate, commercialized system for informing the public, we had robustly funded public media, we'd all know a lot more as a society about the gutting of the #VotingRightsAct. 10/
We were grateful for the context provided by @SIfill_ that the reason for laws like the one in GA that prohibits giving water to people waiting in line to vote is that Black voters in GA often face hours long waits just to get access to the polls. 11/
.@AveryElections pointed out deadlines prevent journalists from providing election coverage with long, holistic views. There needs to be space for reporters to talk about things that are less exciting, that eschew sensationalism. Candidates must commit to norms on record. 12/
This panel made the point that when one side of an argument is a lie, maybe that doesn't need to be in your piece. We couldn't agree more! The journalists job is not to simply quote "both sides" and leave it there. It is to verify the truth of the matter. 13/
.@AntheaButler made sure to say it twice, "Democracy is under threat from theocracy," and implored journalists to understand the role of religion in dismantling American democracy. 14/
Ta-Nehisi Coates reflected that the tradition of Black journalism is a tradition of truth-telling, a tradition of moral clarity. He added that the journalists role is not to "chronicle the world as it falls over a cliff." #CJDDemocracySummit@C4JDHowardU 15/
Journalism historian @krforde made sure to remind journalists that "journalism is not a neutral cultural product." @Maria_Hinojosa said reporters must have the astuteness to not accept propaganda and profound stories get the most engagement. #CJDDemocracySummit@C4JDHowardU 16/
.@jayrosen_nyu said journalists covering elections must shift from the paradigm of examining "what are the odds?" to asking, and informing, "what are the stakes?" Help voters be informed participants. Ask voters what they want candidates to talk about to get their votes. 17/
.@WesleyLowery said journalists need to be unafraid to be direct and clear. Journalists' legitimacy "comes from the ideas we write down being true." He also made the great point that deadlines are a construct of capitalism. National newsrooms are about making money. 18/
.@cassandrajar discussed the pitfalls newsrooms can encounter when they simply regurgitate press releases. Politicians know reporters will run their press release. We often say that disinformation agents rely on corporate media to launder their rhetoric into the mainstream. 19/
#CJDDemocracySummit's last panel of the day generated the comment, "Democracy is an idea." Other panels questioned whether we'd ever had a democracy. Without robust journalism interwoven with the moral clarity that it serves the public, we'll never achieve democracy's promise.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🧵JOURNALISTS: Tomorrow and the next few weeks will be a MAGA created nightmare for democracy. You will see all of the same tactical lying and bogus lawsuits of 2020. You will see stochastic violence. DO NOT LEGITIMATE what amounts to a continuation of the Jan. 6 coup attempt. 1/
Please consult the @DemocracyNowUS Election Denier Playbook (we wish they'd used "Election Liar"). It is your duty as a journalist to be aware of these strategies and call them out as anti-democratic, deceitful and immoral. 2/
⬇️⬇️⬇️ projectdefenddemocracy.com/wp-content/upl…
The so-called Brooks Brother’s Riot of 2000, which successfully halted vote counting and resulted in George W. Bush’s victory, is an example of the momentous efficacy of such tactics. Do not refer to any such strategies as "legitimate protest". 3/ washingtonpost.com/history/2018/1…
🧵We wrote in @Salon, "The 2022 midterms are a referendum on how well America's newsrooms have conveyed the authoritarian threat to the voting public."
We called on media to urgently uplift truth & democracy with election coverage. With a week to go... 1/ salon.com/2022/10/23/med…
Things aren't going great. We outline 3 main requirements for pro-democracy election coverage: 1) make threats to democracy clear 2) protect Americans against disinformation 3) treat elections as if they are more important than the sports page
This @AP article fails all 3. 2/
To make threats to democracy clear journalists need to stop saying stuff like candidates "embrace...Trump's lies about the...election." Candidates are lying all on their own. Say so. Timidity from newsrooms is creating a nationwide permission structure to "deny" elections. 3/
🧵Let's examine the immorality of covering elections like a sport. @nytimes The Daily spent 25 minutes on "The Personal and Political Saga of Herschel Walker". The issues were not covered. The threat of MAGA fascism wasn't mentioned. Republicans were treated normally. 1/
"So after the 2020 presidential election and the 2021 Senate runoffs, Republicans had to do some soul searching, some recalibrating." Maya King mentions DJT's #BigLie but leaves out that the majority of Republicans in Congress also participated in the attempted coup.
2/
Then she and @mikiebarb have this exchange after we learn Walker put a gun to his ex's temple-
Barbaro: Wow. That’s pretty extraordinary.
King: It is, and it’s something that might otherwise disqualify a candidate with far less star power...than Herschel Walker.
🧵As national news media perilously spreads anti-democracy candidate lies, here are examples of what pro-democracy, pro-truth election coverage can look like. Check out our guidelines and share them with a political reporter you know...immediately. 1/
⬇️⬇️ mediaanddemocracyproject.org/prodemocracyco…
It's imperative that pro-democracy newsrooms use forceful language to inoculate American voters against strategic election disinformation. Here's a great example from the @pbpost. Coverage must connect the #BigLie to the GOP effort to undermine faith in elections. 2/ #FixMediaNow
Pro-democracy newsrooms must uplift election workers, voters, and the election process. Here's a great example from @npr's @hansilowang. Poll workers are under MAGA attack. Celebrating them in feature articles makes them less ripe for GOP demonization. 3/ npr.org/2022/09/07/112…
🧵Our national news media, describing lying GOP candidates as mere "skeptics," has taken sides in the battle for democracy. Fascists who lie about our electoral system aren't viable candidates for office. Media must stop softening their immorality. We need pro-truth frames. 1/
Fascism expert @ruthbenghiat explains: "The GOP's aim is to debase the whole idea of elections, so the fundamental democratic idea of relying on elections to choose leaders is compromised." The midterms are a referendum on how well America's newsrooms have conveyed the threat. 2/
Euphemisms like "election denier" convey validity to a strategic disinformation campaign. 70% of GOP voters believe lies they've been fed. News media creates a nationwide permission structure to "deny" elections. A candidate who "disputes the 2020 results" is lying. 3/
1/ There's no objectivity in journalism. The choice of what to cover and what not to is subjective and everything follows from there. Word choice is subjective. Both-sides, horse race coverage, euphemism, directly quoting liars, all choices. Framing is its own form of propaganda.
2/ What follows are a series of headlines which normalize GOP malfeasance and downplay the threat to democracy. We've edited them to make clear the purposeful employment of euphemism, especially on threats to voting. Corporate media subjects us to these pro-GOP frames everyday.
3/ We'll ease into it with a press favorite, choosing to call GOP liars "firebrands." Jim Jordan lies about elections and ignored student rapes by a team doctor when he was a wrestling coach at Ohio State. America, he's just passionate. Just another "GOP firebrand."