Dr Ingrid M Profile picture
Dec 3 43 tweets 17 min read
good morning☀️happy December! Today on #Insiders are murdoch politics editor Samantha Maiden, ABC newsreader Dan Bourchier and ABC politics editor Andrew Probyn. The interview is with Indigenous Australians minister Linda Burney.
the government finishes the year on a high, says Speers. Significant reforms passed and Morrison censured. But the Nationals announcement on not supporting a Yes vote on the Voice referendum is “not everything went the governments way” #Insiders
the media are hyping the Nationals announcement as a No campaign. What the Nationals SAID was they will not support the proposal for a constitutionally enshrined First Nations Voice to Parliament. #Insiders
the montage Sou track is “You’re the Voice” in language. Is it Gamilaraay by Mitch Tambo? I am not sure. Lots of clips of journalists saying IS IT WRECKED and coalition politicians whining and lying about “detail” #Insiders
#MakingNews is the ACT DPP decision to not re-prosecute Bruce Lehrmann for sexual assault. The accused alleged future legal options are of course given time on the public broadcaster. #Insiders
claims that Littleproud is walking back the narrative created by media - that the Nationals will campaign for a No vote - which journalists said. Someone has a leaked WhatsApp message limiting the Nats position to not supporting the Voice proposal by referendum. #Insiders
interview. Minister Burney opens by spelling out the working groups - Profs Langton and Calma and the work they did commissioned by Wyatt; Prof Davis and Aunty Pat Anderson on the dialogues working group. #Insiders
everyone forgets that the parliament will control its design, says Minister Burney. It is not about what politicians want, it is about the Australian people voting yes to the principle of First Nations people having a say on legislation. #Insiders
it is very straightforward, says Minister Burney. It is about improving outcomes and telling the truth. And truth telling in the nations birth certificate (constitution). And that this country is home to 65,000 years of cultural heritage [paraphrased] #Insiders
there will be no veto right. Advice from the Voice will be tabled in the parliament. It will be made available to the executive.
Q: Will every bill include a statement that the Voice was or not consulted?
A: that remains open to the co-design process [paraphrased] #Insiders
self-determination will guide everything they do, says Minister Burney. She sets out some areas where government needs to act - housing, overcrowding, incarceration. Where will the Voice make a difference? #Insiders
minister Burney points to First Nations-specific DV policy and cultural heritage legislation. She says she will not get ahead of the process and commits that everyone will be well informed on the question/s and what it means. It is about us as a nation, she says. #Insiders
recognition in the constitution is still a part of the referendum proposal for a Voice to Parliament. Asked about personal attacks, the minister says this Voice is about representing First Nations people to the Parliament in an extraordinary moment of truth telling. #insiders
and it is about bringing the nation together. She is confident of a Yes vote, and has confidence in the Australian people says Minister Burney. And she is proud of the Socceroos ⚽️ ☺️#Insiders
panel. No more detail yet opens Speers. Bourchier reviews what Burney says and the wiring group, and Speers again emphasises that the other side is “clamouring for more detail” #Insiders
the key line is stressing that this is about the Australian people, not politicians, says Maiden, to counter that narrative about elites [paraphrased, and she is right] #Insiders
why did the Nats announce this week? Echoing Noel Pearson, Probyn says it is because of [Senator] Jacinta [Nampijimpa] Price. They approve the “practical” example of DV and Probyn says he can not see how Dutton says No. Speers cites polling. #Insiders
the report from the working group, the principles, the model. Bourchier says polling has to be higher to allow for it falling back during the campaign (citing Prof Twomey). Speers says the model includes weighted remote representation and repeats Nats talking points. #Insiders
back to “where does Dutton land”. Probyn repeats that he can not see Dutton opposing because the Liberals have to win back seats from independents (“teal seats”). It could get ugly tho, says Maiden, pointing to the Gucci nonsense and Pearson on IPA puppetry. #Insiders
clip of Morrison lying about lying. Bless, says Maiden😂😂clip of Morrison lying to Ben Fordham. It’s easy to forget you were sworn in as Treasurer, says Maiden. It sounded like a valedictory speech, like he was preparing for the exit lounge, she says. #Insiders
he gave a speech about the pandemic, says Maiden (she calls it rousing lol) and did not engage with the substantive criticism in the Bell report. They note his false claim that journos did not ask the right question #Insiders
what was the queue to shake his hand about? Maiden says it is a terrible look to line up and kiss the hand and Tammy Wynette and stand by your man and Dutton did not line up to hug him and kiss him (!!) and he probably took a dim view (of the ring-kissing queue) -Maiden #insiders
profits of coal companies? Look at Queensland, says Probyn, the royalties are 40% not 15%? I missed the detail here sorry. Speers repeats the major media narrative about household budgets (power prices) being the responsibility of the federal government #Insiders
pretty good finish for the government? asks Speers. They claim to have passed more legislation than any gov since 2013 says Maiden. So the best since the Abbott gov, she twinkles. It’s a low bar to implement election promises - Maiden #insiders
the territory rights to legislate on voluntary assisted dying is covered by Bourchier. There is no time for nuance here - the risk of little old ladies being seen as disposable by kids who are keen on the inheritance, for example. #Insiders
the Lehrmann mistrial and decision not to re-prosecute. Maiden bothsides the traumatisation of [alleged] victim and accused. The *police* had concerns about the prospect of a conviction, says Maiden #Insiders
we get a re-cap of the inside drop article written up by Albrechtsen and published in the Oz from Maiden, who also summarises her report on the AFP giving Higgins’ private counselling notes to the defence bY aCciDeNt #Insiders
and *politicisation* of the trial/decision not to re-prosecute - as tho the politics can be extracted from a rape trial where the rape was allegedly by one political staffer against another in a ministerial suite. Not possible. #Insiders
#MattPriceMoment is dominated by demoted Nationals leaders. Google it mate gets a run. Joyce and McCormack get two each #Insiders
as does anus horribilus. The Shaq moment. Tehan lying about twitter. Albanese spelling magnanimous. Jason Clare and Jim Chalmers performing parenthood. #Insiders
#MattPriceMoment is Morrison bowling over a kid in a soccer campaign stop, which Speers calls this bit of over enthusiastic campaigning #Insiders
#TalkingPictures is with the mighty David Pope, a back to you David man. #Insiders
#FinalObs 1 is Bourchier on the federal court decision recognising Tiwi rights to consultation and that Santos failed to do so, recognising traditional owners, says Bourchier #Insiders
#FinalObs 2 is Maiden saying there are juicy nuggets in the latest book by Niki Savva #Insiders
#FinalObs 3 is Probyn but I missed most of it. Energy prices again, I think. #Insiders
the outtake is a mash up filled with grotesque reminders of federal politics dominated by men like Scott Morrison and Josh Frydenberg. Just the sound of their voices is😣 but the election night reminders are pleasant I guess. Garma gets a good run. #Insiders
oh my lawd that clip of Dutton saying they “can smile together” and attempting to smile again. The Liberals focus groups must still be telling him to smile more lol #Insiders
this has been the final 2022 edition of watching #Insiders so you don’t have to👋🏼👋🏼👋🏼
paying forward this week to #JusticeForDianneMiller and baby Edmonds. Donate directly here gofundme.com/f/dianes-partn… Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dr Ingrid M

Dr Ingrid M Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @iMusing

Nov 26
good morning☀️happy Sunday! Today on #Insiders are Guardian politics editor Katharine Murphy, murdoch politics editor James Campbell and former Costello staffer/murdoch columnist, current Costello-chaired 9fax (SMH/the Age) columnist/author of new book Niki Savva.
the interview is with employment and workplace relations minister Tony Burke. #Insiders
opening spiel: Andrews makes history, federal implications, tuff times for Liberal Party politicians. #Insiders
Read 53 tweets
Nov 26
hearing the murdoch and nine entertainment campaign against Daniel Andrews has failed to persuade Vic voters of their agenda.
political journalists and polling companies - who constantly get elections wrong because they exist to profit from promoting bullshit conflict narratives and Coalition agenda - will, as always, keep their jobs.
the rank whiff of meritocracy mythology is strong tonight.
Read 25 tweets
Nov 25
inquiry into multiple appointments of Scott Morrison, when Prime Minister, by current Governor General David Hurley to six ministerial offices of the crown. ministriesinquiry.gov.au/publications/r…
he did not appoint himself. Any purported self-appointment would have zero legal effect. The Governor General swore Morrison into six ministries of the crown, as only the vice regal representative of the crown has authority to do.
there is no need to keep broadcasting what Scott Morrison said to the press 5 months ago or how Josh Frydenberg feels as told to Niki Savva last August. The public interest is not synonymous - nor aligned - with the personal interests of Liberal Party operatives.
Read 12 tweets
Nov 19
good morning on the bird app🐦☀️today on #Insiders are ex-murdoch now 9fax (The Age) politics corro Annika Smethurst, ABC everyman Stan Grant, and murdoch (Oz) serial temper-loser Greg Sheridan.
The interview is with opposition foreign affairs spokesman Simon Birmingham.
opening spiel: “diplomatic deep freeze” is over. What next? Why is Xi re-engaging? asks Speers (A: change of federal government from Coalition to Labor). #Insiders
Australia held its ground, says Speers. Xi has agreed to “the thaw” he says. And these outcomes a mystery to very senior press gallery journalist David Speers, or so he would have us believe. #Insiders
Read 45 tweets
Nov 12
good morning☀️happy Sunday! Another Oz fest on #Insiders today with 9fax (AFR) columnist Jennifer Hewett, murdoch (Oz) columnist Peter van Onselen and murdoch (Oz) political reporter Sarah Ison. The interview is with Home Affairs minister Claire O’Neil.
opening spiel: data dump, Russian hackers, has the federal government DONE ENOUGH to ensure our data is safe? #Insiders
editorialising on the “urgent need” to strengthen defences against hackers. Albanese attending conferences and meetings overseas, a weirdly critical narrative ABC has been pushing this week. The IR bill and cross bench vote. #Insiders
Read 47 tweets
Nov 12
RR unlawful mass expansion of fabricated debts was timed, by Scott Morrison, to kick in on 1 July 2016. He announced his multibillion dollar extortion program (“savings”) on 28 June. The Coalition limped back into office on 2 July with a net loss of 14 seats.
in the lead up to the July 2 election, Treasurer Morrison and Prime Minister Turnbull publicly contradicted each other on the timing of that years federal budget, which was moved for the specific purpose of launching the Coalition election campaign.
the treasurer calculated, correctly, that major media outlets - notably the unforgivably craven press gallery - would broadcast his unverified claims about what was always unlawful extortion of the poorest members of society, for the Coalition campaign.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(