Muhammad Shehada Profile picture
Dec 17, 2022 9 tweets 5 min read Read on X
Left: Hanna Basharat with his family in front of the villa he built in Talbiya in #Jerusalem in 1926.

The Zionist Haganah militia took the villa in 1948

In 1960s, Israel's Foreign Minister Golda Meir lived in the villa.
In 1969 she said "There was no such thing as Palestinians"
2\ Hanna tried to reclaim his house in Israeli courts, but to no avail!

In the villa, lived #Israel's labor minister Mordechai Namir, then Foreign Minister Golda Meir, then Knesset Speaker Kadish Luz, Supreme Court Judge Zvi Berenson, & Finance Ministry official Shlomo Arazi.
3\ In 1977, Hanna's grandson Prof. George Bisharat attempted to visit the Jerusalem villa were his father Dr. Maurice was born.

He rang the doorbell & explained the story to the old Israeli woman that answered.
She shrugged "Your family never lived here."
His pain was compounded
4\ George hesitated to argue, lest she denies him entry. He felt anguish by the need to grovel & beg this stranger to let him enter his family's house.

Her husband soon came. It was Israeli Supreme Court Justice, Zvi Berenson.

He briefly allowed him to only see the living room.
5\ In 1958, then #Israel's Foreign Minister, Golda Meir, met with Dag Hammarskjöld, the UN Secretary-General in this very Bisharat villa.

Her security personnel tore down an inscription on the front of the house in Arabic to obscure the signs of Palestinian ownership & identity.
6\ Recently, the Israeli government put a plaque at the house to mark its uniqueness & importance.

It names the original Palestinian owner Hanna Bisharat, but it makes no mention that he was a Palestinian or how the house was taken from him!
7\ In 2011, James Snyder, the Director of Israel Museum gave a gleeful talk about how he found this & made it his home.

Again, no mention of how it was taken away from its original Palestinian owners.

PS. Correction: the picture to the left is Hanna Bisharat's family. To the right is Shukri Al-Jamal's family, owner of the house across the street from Hanna's. Both homes were taken over by Israel. h/t @EveningSends (Hanna's great grandson).
“I shall continue to struggle till the end of my life. You ask me about my future plans. I have none… Our Villa Harun ar-Rashid in Jerusalem has been stolen…”
- a powerful quote from Hanna & picture of him, courtesy of his great grandson @EveningSends

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Muhammad Shehada

Muhammad Shehada Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @muhammadshehad2

Oct 11
When the genocide ends, I can write a giant book on mainstream media journalists who constantly wasted hours & hours of my & my colleagues time to do unrequited toil & collect indisputable evidence for them of Israeli crimes, only to NEVER publish a single word, ever!
2\ Journalist A last Dec: can you send me geolocation, footage from multiple angles, eyewitnesses, dates... of Israel shooting civilians raising white flags?

They never published a word

A few weeks ago same journalist: can you send me more recent incidents, the story is old now
Journalist B: can you send me the names of every single bakery Israel has bombed since the start of the war, their geolocation, date of bombing, footage, eyewitnesses...

Basically do the whole job for them unaccredited & they slap their name on it.

Story never published!
Read 6 tweets
Oct 8
This was Gaza 5 MONTHS before October 7🧵

Western govs & media will always pretend violence starts ONLY whenever Israelis are attacked. That's when history begins!

B/c we are *expected* to be murdered, crippled & dispossessed & keep quiet. That's "peace" to them, that's normal!
2\ This was Gaza 5 MONTHS before Oct 7:
Israel bombs a shelter for people with disabilities & special needs in Jabaliya on May 13, 2023

Did you see any reference to this in a single mainstream media outlet or in a single speech by a US or EU leader?
3\ This was Gaza 5 MONTHS before Oct 7:

Israel bombs Gaza's most famous dentist, Dr. Jamal Khaswan. His daughter reached al-Shifa hospital with her dad's corpse & didn't know he was killed

"Where's my dad?" She kept asking..

Why are these atrocities are unheard of in the West?
Read 6 tweets
Oct 7
54% of Palestinians still support October 7 a year later.

The 2 most vital questions are: what do they exactly support? & why? I spent months interviewing dozens of Palestinians on this🧵

1- Support for October 7 does NOT mean support for Hamas or atrocities against civilians

There are currently two October 7s in people's minds; one that Israel and pro-Israeli crowds see of pure evil, which focuses solely on the killing & kidnapping of civilians, omitting everything else.

The other Oct 7 that 54% of Palestinians voice support for, which is the attacks on military targets that broke Israel’s image of invincibility & the "prison break" moment of defeating Gaza's confinement.

90% of the Palestinian supporters of Oct 7 "believe Hamas men did not commit” alleged or documented atrocities from that day (per the source of that poll).

That is b/c Oct 7 is understood to have consisted of 2 waves (something acknowledged by the ICC Chief Prosecutor). The 1st wave was made of elite Hamas "Nukhba" militants & predominantly focused on Israeli military bases surrounding Gaza.

The 2nd wave formed spontaneously once the news broke out in Gaza & anyone with a gun rushed to the fence, including members of 6 other armed factions & non-Nukhba Hamas individuals as well as Gaza’s riff-raffs & hooligans & curious spectators. This wave had no central command, prior plans, coordination, or set goals, which prompted even Hamas’ own Yahia Sinwar to acknowledge that “things went out of control” (per WSJ).

Also, the wave of attacks on Israeli Kibbutzism on October 7 are clouded to many Palestinians by doubt over how much of the atrocity narratives is accurate. This is in light of debuked disinformation Israel’s government deliberately tried to spread as well as Israeli reports of “numerous” incidents of friendly fire & activating the “hannibal protocol” which authorizes the IDF to thwart suspected kidnapping attempts by killing everyone at the scene. Add to this Israel’s strict military censorship over what is allowed to be published.Image
2- Why do 54% of Palestinians still support Oct 7 a year later?

80% of those Palestinians do so b/c it “has put the Palestinian issue at the center of attention & eliminated years of neglect” (per the poll's source). This sentiment stems from a context of Gazans suffering slow death for 2 decades under Israel's siege while the world looked the other way.

In their support for Oct 7, many Palestinians cite the desperate necessity to disrupt an excruciating 17-year-long siege on Gaza that had already rendered the enclave “uninhabitable” by 2020 & pushed many futureless yet highly educated youth to the brink of suicide.

They also bring up a profound sense of isolation & abandonment that preceded this war where Palestinians’ plight was relegated to the sidelines of international discourse; seen as a mere hurdle on the path to Israeli-Arab normalization, which deepened the fear that Palestinians' suffering would persist indefinitely.

Compounding this was an increased sense of existential threat under Israel’s most far-right government in history, due to rising attacks by Israeli settlers & the IDF across the West Bank, with 2022 and 2023 marking the deadliest years for Palestinians since records began in 2005, and Israel’s largest land theft for settlements in decades.
3- Was October 7 the best course of action to disrupt Gaza's unliveable status quo?

Many supportive answers are not articulated in voicing support for Hamas itself or violence but rather in highlighting how virtually every other alternative path failed to yield tangible results.

The most prominent disillusionment Palestinians bring up is that with over 30 years of negotiations that never birthed a Palestinian state. Israel’s Knesset recently affirmed that conviction with 2 resolutions that uncompromisingly reject the two-state solution under any circumstances.

Nonviolent protests were also crushed by Israel. The 2018-2019 Great March of Return saw tens of thousands of unarmed Gazans protest weekly against the blockade. Israeli snipers shot & maimed over 30,000 protesters & bragged about how many Palestinian kneecaps they blew up, with one scoring 42 knees in one day.

Palestinians also tried to knock on the doors of the UN and international courts, actions that Israel routinely attacks as "diplomatic terrorism". Whatever historic resolutions Palestinians got remained mere ink on paper; never to be implemented.

Even Palestinians who try converting to Judaism are automatically rejected out of hand by Israel. One prominent convert who changed his name to David Ben Avraham, studied the Torah in depth and befriending numerous Israeli Rabbis was shot dead at point blankby an IDF soldier last March for daring to call himself “Jewish.”

So slow death under Israel’s Apartheid, compounded by deadlocked peaceful avenues, leaves Palestinians with the conviction there is nothing they could do to be treated as human beings.

This despair then lends credence to armed resistance as a tool to shake up the status quo, exact revenge, or for counter-intimidation.
Read 4 tweets
Aug 30
🚨Israel is arming criminal gangs in Gaza with US-made assault rifles to sow chaos & societal collapse:

Those kids in Deir Al-Balah were armed with M16s that can ONLY enter Gaza through Israel.

They're openly firing their M16s without any fear of Israeli troops 800 meters away!
2\ The US M16 rifles those kids are parading around look very new.

Hamas doesn't smuggle those into Gaza, they use soviet AK-47s rifles.

Similar M16 rifles were reportedly seen with gangs that loot aid trucks & rob homes & civilians.

There's been also 2 major bank robberies.
3\ Israel has been in touch with many criminal gangs & families in Gaza to recruit them to destabilize the enclave and/or in some cases to act substitute for the Hamas government & run neighbourhoods as warlords.

Some families refused or were threatened by Hamas to back off
Read 5 tweets
Aug 26
Deliberately downplaying Israeli atrocities:

A 1,743-word story about IDF soldiers RAPING a Gazan civilian does NOT mention the word "rape" a single time

In passing, the article uses vague language like "violate from behind"

They also omitted important parts of his testimony! Image
2\ Ibrahim Salem testified earlier that Israeli soldiers raped him & other Gazan civilians kidnapped to the Sde Teiman torture camp, including children.

Most of his testimony here was left out in the CNN article above.

The article deliberately downplays Israel's rape of Salem!
3\ Now compare the vague language & deliberate avoidance of the word "rape" in a story about Israel raping Palestinians with how CNN covered the allegations of sexual violence on Oct 7

Many of those allegations have been debunked since, but they're still featured in that article!Image
Read 4 tweets
Jul 31
Assassinating Haniya is an empty victory image that reeks of desperation & malevolence.

He was a politician not a militant leader. Israeli media themselves admit his killing will have minimal effect on Hamas' operations.

But it'll dramatically impact internal power dynamics🧵 Image
2\ Haniya lived in the open & NOT in hiding like Sinwar. So reaching his head is NOT an achievement.

Why kill him now?
1- Ruin the ceasefire/prisoner swap negotiations
2- Kill chances of Palestinian unity after Beijing's summit
3- Push Hamas to become more hardline
3\ Haniya was a pragmatist & had a moderating influence on Sinwar & Hamas' military wing.

Khaled Meshal, Haniya likely temporary successor, is a moderate within the movement, but doesn't have as much authority over the militants & Sinwar. He's not a Gazan & not as well-connected to everyone on the ground as Haniya was.
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(