Sparty Profile picture
Jan 10, 2023 16 tweets 8 min read Read on X
Principles of russian (war) economy.
a thread about russionomics.🧵

Recently there is rising discussion about #russia's ability to sustain the #Ukraine war. The great #Perun on YT comes to mind. Yet many observers overlook the specific russian economic model, russionomics. 1/n
1/ Material goods.
- A material good is something you or your mates can steal.
- It needs a means of production or storage to steal from.
- If a good is in short supply steal the rest.
- The function of the army is to provide lots of material goods to steal easily.
2/n
2/ Intangible assets
- An intangible asset can be stolen remotely.
- Nobody cares if it is stolen until some burly gopniks ring at your door
- Favours are immaterial goods obtainable by means of a bribe
- Justice, public sector and army operate as system of favours and bribes
3/n
3/ Immobile assets
- Immobile assets can be bought but are commonly obtained via bribe.
- Get immobile assets as they are harder to steal.
- The size of your immobile asset shows how much you steal and creates status.
- Yachts are mobile immobile assets.
- Never outdo Prez.
4/n
4/ Surplus value
- When you steal it it has value
- When you can bribe with it, it has value
- Selling is an attempt to steal as much money from the customer (gopnik) as possible.
- Stealing from the army creates private value.
- Sale of stolen goods maximizes surplus value
5/n
5/ Public Sector
- State steals from everyone inc other countries & people
- Everyone steals from the state
- You may also use bribes to steal from the state
- The more you steal the more important you become
- Your superior assigns you fiefdom to extort
- Prez gets 50% share
6/n
6/ Armed forces
- Army is a public sector entity with loads of material goods and heaps of mates to bribe
- The army hence educates in stealing and bribery
- Generals steal everything
- Senior ranks steal from conscripts/stocks
- Conscripts may bribe to get stolen stuff back
7/n
7/ Defense industry
- Provides army with stuff to steal
- Ideally produces fake goods or deliveries to ease stealing for senior officers and maximise surplus value
- Procurement▶️Bribing▶️Stealing
- Industries are fiefdoms to extort
- Converts material assets into immobile
8/n
8/ Storage
- Storage are things intended to be stolen
- Deliveries to and inventory of storage may be faked to ease stealing by officials
- Army has many warehouses to steal from
- Storage employees may be bribed
- Stealing minimizes storage costs increasing efficiency
9/n
9/ Currency
- Money is either Dollar or Euro
- Ruble means the state steals from you
- In cities you can buy things that other people stole, the state often forces you to use rubles for that.
- Money helps paying bribes, only poor people bribe in rubles.
- Store Money in EU
10/n
10/ Hydrocarbons
- Gas and oil have strategic importance and are lifeblood of russian economic cycle
- Hence the technology used is >90% from the evil west
- Only rich people can steal oil/gas to convert it into yachts and London flats.
- Bribe the Prez to steal oil/gas
11/n
11/ Inflation
- There is no inflation
- Inflation is a way the state steals from you
- It only affects poor people without money, convert your Rubles
- the ruble exchange rate is stable, poor people subsidize the rate for the rich
- Ferrari 3% - LADA 300% price increase p.a.
12/n
12/ State Budget
- State Budget is the money the state has stolen
- Includes charitable donations from oligarchs, aka taxes
- Avoid taxes using bribes
- Budget finances oligarchs & siloviki without natural commodity fiefdom
- pays pesky gopnik pensions
- pays OMON/SOBR
13/n
13/ Human resources
- A person is a commodity the army can steal/mobilize
- Production lacks, so the state steals from neighbour countries
- You may bribe yourself out of being stolen by army
- Jobs are provided via bribes
- If you steal enough you may live in the evil west
14/n
14/ Services
- A service is obtained by bribe aka fee
- serving state is "compensated" in rubles
- public servants are really payed via bribes, preferably in Money ($/€)
- You may also avoid state services via bribe
- Services degrade radially from Moscow
- All serve Putin
15/n
15/ Legal system
- Justice is a public service, use bribes
- Russia is humane, no death penalty
- Instead use accidents, mobilization and GULAG
- The police arrests criminals
- Criminals are convicted
- Arrest leads to conviction
- You may pay for de-arrest using bribes
16/n

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sparty

Sparty Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @spartyflyboy

Jul 8
Stealing Presidency - SCOTUS could install Trump🧵

As America debates if Biden is fit & can win over Trump there's a much more significant risk to American democracy:
In a professional rerun of a failed haphazardly organized '20 scheme SCOTUS could overturn the '24 election.
1/ Image
The History
The election of 2020 saw a number of haphazardly organised and ultimately failing schemes to overturn the election of Joe Biden. The common motif of these efforts was the lie that the election was "rigged" and ultimately that an accurate result can't be delivered.
2/
One of the '20 schemes to overturn the election had active involvement by wife of Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, Ginni. She pressured lawmakers in Arizona and Wisconsin to ignore the vote and select Trump electors to "fight back against fraud".
3/
azmirror.com/2022/06/21/how…
Read 20 tweets
May 23
Coup Proofing in Russia?🧵
Replacing Shoigu with Belousov was widely interpreted as move to strengthen the mil/ind complex performance. That analysis ignored the main motivator informing Kremlin conduct: System survival.
What we see now is a decapitation of the MoD and Army.
1/
Under new Management?
Think of Russia as a mafia run company to facilitate embezzlement and money laundering. Turning around such structures is a herculean task even without the stress of a war, and an extraction focused economy under sanctions.
Belousov also is a Gosplan guy.
2/ Image
The type of management Belousov can implement in reasonable time is centralization and squeezing companies. But Rostec is already centralized and preemptively puts up resistance. It's run by Chemezov as a cash cow for the mafia Don himself.
So why make Belousov Minister now?
3/ Image
Read 16 tweets
May 21
@nicolange_ Einordnung schwierig, viel passiert außerhalb des "Normals", aber ein Versuch.
Patrushevs Macht kam nicht aus seiner Position heraus sondern aus der Person selbst. Er war Gatekeeper zu Putin, extensive Vernetzung im Geheimdienststaat. Kardinal. Die Macht _kann_ er behalten.
1/
@nicolange_ Shoigu wird unterschätzt. Er war nicht "unfähig". Ihm wurde Kontrolle des kinetischen Apparates entzogen UND es werden seine Patronagesysteme im Militär demontiert. Ihm bleiben dennoch wichtige Netzwerke und Kontake nach China, riecht n bissl nach Coup-Proofing.
2/
@nicolange_ Es scheint zur Zeit, dass Shoigus Kontrolle über Siloviki eingegrenzt wird, seine Macht aus der neuen Position heraus alleine ist gering, aber seine Expertise wird erhalten und seine verbleibenden Netzwerke dürften Kreml loyal und kontrollierbar bleiben.
3/
Read 4 tweets
Mar 25
STOP BASHING POLAND!🧵

Want allies? Then don't alienate them!
Recent events led to a wave of Poland-bashing from many pro-Ukrainian accounts. This increasingly goes beyond reasonable criticism, taking the form of sweeping statements, even hostility.
1/
We have an alliance supporting Ukraine. Unfortunately nothing is ever perfect, each country has their own political problems and struggles - including Ukraine. Some are firm allies, some prone to waiver.
But this is the only alliance we have and Russia is trying to destroy it.
2/
How does Russia try to destroy the pro Ukraine alliance?
By sowing dissent, amplifying doubts and issues up to the level of hostility. Works in our domestic politics and towards other allies. No shock or surprise there.
So, to be frank, why do many help Russia play this game?
3/
Read 15 tweets
Mar 15
Wir müssen Macron beim Wort nehmen🧵
Gegen Russlands eskalierendes aggressives Verhalten hat es bisher vor Allem an Abschreckung gefehlt. Macrons Rede bietet die Chance wieder glaubwürdige Abschreckung herzustellen.
Durch Zweifel & Zerreden kann diese Chance verspielt werden.
1/ Image
Macrons Vortrag stellt einen Wendepunkt dar. Eine zentrale europäische Macht verknüpft offen die Frage eigener und europäischer Sicherheit mit dem Sieg der Ukraine über Russland.
Russland wird klar als Gegner bezeichnet der Frankreich hybride angreift und dort Leben gefährdet.
2/
Der Sieg der Ukraine ist laut Macron essentiell für europäische Sicherheit. Es gibt per se keine roten Linien mehr, was nötig ist um Russland einzugrenzen und der Ukraine zum Sieg zu verhelfen wird gemacht.
In diesem Sinn soll auf jede weitere Aktion Russlands reagiert werden.
3/
Read 13 tweets
Mar 8
AI & Drones? Why not use Nerds! 🧵
What seems like a "game" might become a new approach to employment of unmanned systems in the battlespace.
Instead of only using AI ,with all it's problems, future militaries might harness the power of distributed computing power:
The nerd.
1/
It isn't totally fair to compare AI with nerds (aka human intelligence). AI offers the capability to deploy deeply autonomous systems capable to operate with minimal (or without) EM signal emissions. Nerds can't do that.
So let's rethink augmented AI.
2/
digitalreality.ieee.org/images/files/p…
The rising military relevance of distributed human intelligence became obvious in Russia's war on Ukraine. While open source intelligence (OSINT) in general still comes with quality & reliability issues, projects like Oryx have demonstrated utility & strength of the approach.
3/ Image
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(