7 years ago, on January 18, 2016, I wrote:
“Bitterly cold day as I cross No Man's Land. Off to pay my respects at the Martyrs' Well in Ajnala where the bodies of native sepoys (who rebelled at the Mianmir Cantt in Lahore in 1857 & who were summarily executed at Ajnala) were 1/n
disposed on a rainy day all those years ago.”
It was to be a memorable trip as some elderly Sikh gentlemen present at the site received very warmly a person who suddenly stepped out of the fog - and across the fog - spoke to them in Punjabi and respectfully asked to be guided 2/n
on the place & its history. Initially they were a bit taken aback. Yes I too revere them as you do I told them. Their valor & common cause unites us far above & beyond what divides us today.
The images of the place still haunt me. As was expected I barely managed to catch my 3/n
train to Delhi as typical Punjabi hospitality was loathe to let me leave so soon.
Next year Penguin Random House India was to publish my novel Snuffing Out the Moon. The events from 1857 were to figure prominently in it. This visit had helped me imbue them with greater 4/n
texture & feeling.
The narrative on Ajnala started with the lines:
“There was a well at Ajnala. A dark, deep and dry well. Lying desolately in the shade of a large peepal tree, it had been long abandoned and lay silently gaping like an enormous parched black mouth. 5/n
The monsoon rains were particularly heavy in Punjab in the summer of 1857; they flooded the fields and open grounds that stretches around the small rural town of Ajnala for miles. Through these rains struggled many as they fled from the Mian Mir Cantonment in Lahore that was 6/n
well over thirty miles away from Ajnala as the crow flies.”
On a car, on foot and a taxi I too had come from the direction of Mian Mir’s tomb. Almost 160 years later. Pursuing the faint trail of the memory of many still nameless men who had perished here. And to mourn them 7/n
عمران خان کے اخلاقی کردار کی گراوٹ کے بارے میں بچپن سے سنتے چلے آ رہے ہیں۔ کم از کم مجھے ان #audioleaks پر کوئی حیرت نہیں۔ پر کئی سوال پیدا ہوتے ہیں اور میرے نزدیک ان کے جواب یہ ہیں۔
س۔ کیا عمران خان کی ذاتی زندگی اس طرح سے منظر عام پہ لائی جانی چاہیے؟
ج۔ نہیں۔ کسی کی بھی
۱/۷
پریویسی اس طرح پامال نہیں ہونی چاہیے۔ اب یہ دیکھنا پڑے گا کہ ریکارڈ کس نے کیا اور کیا وہ غیر قانونی تھا۔ اگر حساس ادارے یہ کر رہے ہیں تو یہ سرکاری وسائل اور اختیار کا غلط استعمال ہے۔ اور سیاست دانوں کو کنٹرول کرنے کا طریقہ۔ سیاست دانوں کی ۲/۷
ذاتی زندگی اور ان کی پبلک لائف میں امتیاز ضروری ہے۔ ہاں یہ ضرور ہے کہ عمران خان خود دوسروں پہ خوب ذاتی حملے کرتے ہیں اور ان کی کردار کشی میں مہارت رکھتے ہیں۔ یہ بھی کہ وہ مذہب کا بھی سیاست میں خوب استعمال کرتے ہیں۔ اور ایک زاہد و پارسا کا لبادہ اوڑھتے ہیں۔
س۔ کیا ان لیکس کا ۳/۷
#ImranKhan’s political lack of acumen (he has cunning) has meant that he has managed to fall from positions of great strength. 1st VONC. Having been shuttled into power with vast popular support & Deep State support, he managed to fall out with allies, under perform & take 1/11
all kinds of unnecessary steps to entrench himself. Destabilised/made insecure too many & pulled himself down. Post VONC because of PDM divide/indecisions, his big jalsas, by-election victories & constant politicking he managed to resurrect himself. All he needed to do was 2/11
to wait out some months. Floods, inflation, fuel/electricity prices, lacklustre governance, Bajwa on way out, burden of his own govt’s legacy on economy etc means that PDM lame duck in coming elections. PTI also rules 2 provinces. But again his COAS appointment obsession. 3/11
At prospect of IK’s compromising videos following reactions from followers: (1) They are fake. Shows there isn’t any capacity or intent to objectively gauge or to ask for legit forensics. It’s blind faith. This despite the fact that the man has a long & known past of sexual 1/11
escapades & promiscuity. Also it would matter if any clips were recent or from distant past. Because if recent & authentic then quite apart from Arts 62/63 piety clauses & his entire persona & political use of Islam there is also the Q of how such activity can compromise 2/11
leader of a nuclear nation. Already a few lame preemptive PTI videos on how fake audios/videos done. Surely any devout supporter should ask for authentic international verification to fully clear this thing/expose fakers. But No (2) Nothing can make us doubt IK. Again this 3/11
Reminders for IK Red Liners. 1) we opposed illegal detention/torture against citizens in the past. You laughed & said they deserve it. 2) We always said don’t brand people as thieves, traitors & heretics. You continued to presume guilt & abused them 3) We said military has 1/10
always meddled in politics/has commercial agendas. You called us unpatriotic for this. 4) We said judiciary direly needs reforms. You called it contempt of court. 5) We said an elected PM ousted by deep state. You said he should be thrown in a dungeon for life. 6) We said 2/10
false cases filed/NAB hounding opposition with political agenda. You called these excuses of criminals. 7) We said free speech needs protection. You said anti-state speech/criticism of institutions should be banned/punished. 8) We shall jalsas/protests a political right 3/10
What the #SupremeCourt Order fatally doesn’t appear 2 account for is the following: (1) Political parties run as fiefdoms/personality cults in Pakistan. What if the party head does egregious things or becomes an erratic & dangerous egomaniac or otherwise 1/5 #COAS#HamzaShahbaz
undermines democratic principles/norms or commits other outrages? (2) What if he then becomes entrenched because of the initial calculus of seats? Is a member then bound to not dissent on essentially national & larger than party considerations? An additional question is that 2/5
what’s the point of any voting at all? Everything is predetermined by electoral outcomes as to numbers in assembly. Members should then just sign over to party their votes to be used as it wishes. VONC becomes ineffectual except if coalition partners break off. While clamping 3/5
An ego-centric cricket player finally found prominence in politics when he was adopted/catapulted by Deep State. He made an ass of himself in office & was ousted by a valid VONC. His ego couldn't take it & he declared everyone except himself a traitor, claimed that a foreign 1/n
conspiracy ousted him, announced threat to his life, said nation ought to be nuked instead of his opponents coming to power, & exhorted Deep State to readopt him or else. Along the way he started posturing as if divinely anointed, routinely slandered his opponents, & incited 2/n
violence against them. His stance on desecration of holy places by his zealots was dubious. He blatantly violated Constitution. He regularly instigated his comrades to flout the law. He incited violence against his detractors. He threatened to bring country to a standstill 3/n