On the anniversary of the #WarsawGhettoUprising I would like to share, in a thread, the final letter written by Szmul Mordechaj Zygielbojm, a Jewish Pole exiled in London and serving as an advisor to the Polish Gvmnt-in-exile, before he died by suicide to protest inaction.
1/X
The letter, addressed to Polish president Władysław Raczkiewicz and PM Władysław Sikorski, dated May 11 1943, is one of the most searing and painful letters I have ever seen. He’s just learned that his wife Manya & 16-year-old son Tuvia had been killed during the uprising.
2/X
After all of his frantic efforts to get the Allies to do more were in all in vain, and as the uprising was being mercilessly crushed, he decided to sacrifice his own life in the hopes that it will stir them to action. I will share it in it’s entirety below:
3/X
“Mr. President,
Mr. Prime Minister,
I am taking the liberty of addressing to you, Sirs, these my last words, and through you to the Polish Government and the people of Poland, and to the governments and people of the Allies, and to the conscience of the whole world:”
4/X
“The latest news that has reached us from Poland makes it clear beyond any doubt that the Germans are now murdering the last remnants of the Jews in Poland with unbridled cruelty. Behind the walls of the ghetto the last act of this tragedy is now being played out.”
5/X
“The responsibility for the crime of the murder of the whole Jewish nationality in Poland rests first of all on those who are carrying it out, but indirectly it falls also upon the whole of humanity, on the peoples of the Allied nations and on their governments,…”
6/X
“… who up to this day have not taken any real steps to halt this crime. By looking on passively upon this murder of defenseless millions – tortured children, women and men – they have become partners to the responsibility.”
7/X
“I am obliged to state that although the Polish Govmnt contributed largely to the arousing of public opinion in the world, it still did not do enough.”
8/X
“It did not do anything that was not routine, that might have been appropriate to the dimensions of the tragedy taking place in Poland.”
9/X
“Of close to 3.5 million Polish Jews & about 700,000 Jews who have been deported to Poland from other countries, there were, according to the official figures of the Bund transmitted by the Representative of the Government, only 300,000 still alive in April of this year.”
10/X
“I cannot continue to live and to be silent while the remnants of Polish Jewry, whose representative I am, are being murdered. My comrades in the Warsaw ghetto fell with arms in their hands in the last heroic battle.”
11/X
“I was not permitted to fall like them, together with them, but I belong with them, to their mass grave. By my death, I wish to give expression to my most profound protest against the inaction in which the world watches and permits the destruction of the Jewish people.”
12/X
“I know that there is no great value to the life of a man, especially today. But since I did not succeed in achieving it in my lifetime, perhaps I shall be able by my death to contribute to the arousing from lethargy…”
13/X
“… of those who could and must act in order that even now, perhaps at the last moment, the handful of Polish Jews who are still alive can be saved from certain destruction. My life belongs to the Jewish people of Poland, and therefore I hand it over to them now.”
14/X
“I yearn that the remnant that has remained of the millions of Polish Jews may live to see liberation together with the Polish masses, and that it shall be permitted to breathe freely in Poland…”
15/X
“…and in a world of freedom and socialistic justice, in compensation for the inhuman suffering and torture inflicted on them. And I believe that such a Poland will arise and such a world will come about.”
16/X
“I am certain that the President and the Prime Minister will send out these words of mine to all those to whom they are addressed, and that the Polish Government will…”
17/X
“…embark immediately on diplomatic action and explanation of the situation, in order to save the living remnant of the Polish Jews from destruction.”
18/X
“I take leave of you with greetings, from everybody, and from everything that was dear to me and that I loved.
I have been saying this to journalists who assign to lobbying groups such as @pearlsNY and @KnowUs_ the same credibility as they give #YeshivaGate whistleblowers:
@pearlsNY was formed after a legal complaint was filed by whistleblowers who allege educational neglect at certain yeshivas. A few years ago @MollyBoigon found that leadership of @AgudahNews actually helps run it 2/X forward.com/news/436106/se…
It’s important to understand that at it’s core, what the whistleblowing does is threaten a hugely profitable enterprise which was hitherto allowed to operate almost totally unregulated — on the public’s dime.
@pearlsNY themselves acknowledge their raison d’être is financial 3/X
This phenomenal Op-Ed by @nmoster in @JewishCurrents newsletter is a *must-read* article. Important for any New Yorker, but especially conscientious progressives who care deeply about social issues.
“@JuliaCarmel__’s bill, if passed, could potentially undo all of that and allow yeshivas to form their own accreditation agencies that would in turn rubber-stamp yeshivas that continue to flout the rules.” jewishcurrents.org/progressives-h…
“It seems reasonable to conclude that her decision to sponsor this legislation out of the blue […] @JuliaCarmel__ appears to be throwing Hasidic kids under the bus to ensure her political survival.”
Herein you will see what happens when a member of the tribe knows the facts but because he’s a naive Baal teshuva doesn’t know that he is meant to lie about them.
Let’s begin with a stark admission by the Good Doctor:
“As a baal teshuva & a practicing physician, I am certain that the chasidic education is in no way “substantially equivalent” to the public school education I received.”
But no! He continues with this WHOPPING confession:
“It is time to be honest, both with ourselves & with the government. No more pretending that a Torah curriculum miraculously confers competency in English, mathematics or science. This is pure fiction.” crownheights.info/op-ed/773243/o…
There’s nothing cheaper in NY politics than Jewish blood and Chasidic peoples’ wellbeing. @BrooklynDA should resign in shame. thecity.nyc/2022/5/9/23064…
But when activists or advocates accuse @BrooklynDA of being corrupt or in the pocket of influential Chasidish powerbrokers we get gaslit by @OrenYaniv (who covered the story for @NYDailyNews so he knows there’s over 10 victims) or made fun of online by him:thecity.nyc/2022/5/9/23064…
“It is indefensible and cruel that a self-styled Torah institution not only failed to keep vulnerable young women safe from monster Weberman, but now at long last still use any means whatsoever to keep them from being made whole, even if only financially,”thecity.nyc/2022/5/9/23064…