Share this page!

Enter URL or ID to Unroll

You can paste full URL like: https://x.com/threadreaderapp/status/1644127596119195649
or just the ID like: 1644127596119195649

How to get URL link on X (Twitter) App

  1. On the Twitter thread, click on or icon on the bottom
  2. Click again on or Share Via icon
  3. Click on Copy Link to Tweet
  4. Paste it above and click "Unroll Thread"!
  5. More info at Twitter Help
Sarah Clarke Profile picture
@TrialByTruth
May 3, 2023 • 173 tweets • 55 min read • Read on X
It is a 'Labour smear campaign' but this is the Telegraph and this is 2023 UK BP demands guarantee that B...
The backstory to some of this
Referenced 'smear' in parliament
This was the original reporting
Some apparent steamrollering to institute the Middlesbrough Development Corporation that will oversee related investment with Gove's direct intervention Image
But also media FOI applications blocked for Johnson BP meetings opendemocracy.net/en/dark-money-…
Pretty much everything about the Development Corporation was marked as confidential
There is also this - from The Times
Plus this from Yorkshire Post reporter @JayMitchinson when MP Simon Clarke and Houchen went off the deep end about some questions about shellfish continuing to wash up on beaches
For clarity this relates to this area becoming an Investment Zone - it is an adjacent, but linked issue to freeport questions
Sky picking up the Yorkshire post report
The day that story resulted in some notable reactions from Simon Clarke MP and Houchen
Local @NEBylines on reactions northeastbylines.co.uk/houchens-dead-…
We will see what the reaction is. I almost don't want to look. Do you feel this is a smear seeking to prevent valued local investment, or more a demand for transparency about costs and benefit?
This is more on the deregulation and other legislation associated with the creation of freeports and investment zones. A careful thread
Including this OBR assessment. No need to go to any extremes about fears, but it really would be good (for once), to have a robust investigation of all trade offs
To close some direct sources for you. This is a 14th March debate on the Middlesbrough Development Corporation hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2023-0…
I shared a 2022 video from Andy McDonald before. This is a more recent one on deal due diligence
Extracts from that debate. First @AndyMcDonaldMP then it is @ACunninghamMP with a very good question. Transparency is all we want #LocalElections2023 The council decided not to ...Indeed, the Secretary of St...Alex Cunningham › (Stockton...
I went to check reactions. Deathly silence. Likely due to the elections tomorrow. Quoted on the airport @BenHouchen Please vote for...@SimonClarkeMP A HUGE 24 ho...
It would be good to go back to square one for one thing. Local child poverty. Never mentioned #LocalElections2023
There has been huge aversion to scrutiny and a reportedly huge PR budget
More reporting here on similar
As footer, I am not an activist trying to smear anyone, I am, ironically, a governance and risk specialist, hence digging into details of organisations and individuals to check my bias

The lack of transparency and attacks on media cause the threads. Feel free to counter
More now surfacing thanks to local elections, when Preston, the Middlesbrough Mayor, lost his seat and Turner, the local Police and Crime Commissioner, is also standing as councillor in the final seat awaiting recount

Both key members of the MDC
Houchen confirming the change in the MDC as a result, perhaps more to come depending on the Tuesday recount for that last seat and some questions about our PCCs conduct associated with it Image
This kind of reported conduct
Incidentally @leighsus had now been hired by @yorkshirepost to focus on this, so worth a follow
Please do browse replies to all the quoted tweets. It is not a political cabal trying to ruin the promise of local investment. It is a huge number of concerned locals
Something else for folk to look out for, from replies to this thread
I hope it will force some transparency
Facts should all be carefully checked and correlation is not causation, but that is why we need independent media and well resourced oversight bodies
'It was all about national issues' says Preston, ex-Mayor, on GB News. I decided not to link to it, but you can find it here easily enough Image
A prepared response now from Mayor Houchen - Alt Text split between this and the next tweet Andy McDonald is a coward w...
Alt Text continued from above Andy McDonald stood up in P...
It came with this tweet quoting the one where he first shared the statement @BenHouchen Recently there ...
From Andy McDonald MP
From yesterday's Treasury questions
BP and Equinor reportedly satisfied
The Prime Minister did not comment
One does hope, given this involves millions in public money and sale of local assets, that there is more due diligence than just to leave commercial partners and local bodies to it

Devolution is very attractive, but so is effective governance
Mr Clarke has now had his say @SimonClarkeMP 10th May 202...
Some other local colour while we wait for more. Thought the roundabout was an analogy, but no northeastbylines.co.uk/mayor-houchen-…
Thread continues here if you didn't hit 'show replies'. Just tucking stuff away in the Twitter back pocket
Incidentally, Mr Houchen did say that public coffers were going to be empty and wished Labour luck with that

Saying Conservatives would come up with some plans just before the election
A little debt burden context
It seems the site sale document is in the public domain. This is Private Eye responding to Houchen
A couple of small snippets from a related conversation with a local h/t @Anthdunn @skatothecore Screenshots of a direct mes...Anth Dunn to Ben Houchen - ...
Bring the latest Private Eye report that kicked all this off to the top again
Mr Clarke has now issued a long statement on Facebook 1/6 Simon Clarke MP 10th May 20...
2/6 It is no exaggeration to sa...
3/6 But the task is HUGE - this...
4/6 So Private Eye magazine hav...
5/6 He exposed crabs to pyridin...
6/6 This campaign is damaging i...
Do please reach out if you can simplify all of this for me. I am more than happy to trust in the benefit of this for the area in the medium / long-term, I just want a bit more clarity on what money goes to whom (aside from jobs)
For more context, I did work very hard to try and understand the law being passed for these new zones. Most listed in this thread
A somewhat shorter rebuttal to Clarke
The first mention quickly found of Teesside job creation estimates @Rob Kimbell - October 18th...
What are the current estimates? It is a rapidly moving picture, but it is not clear how figures are arrived at. Just one of the queries. Exchange here between the Private Eye and Houchen Richard brooks @brooks45 • ...
A useful thread on how this tests robustness of devolved arrangements. All want this to work for locals
This is a balanced assessment from the @yorkshirepost reporter
From the Tees Valley Combined Authority demanding Yorkshire Post delete an article recently
A past look at TVCA make up, establishment and terms for operation
A resonse to the PM's statement at #PMQs that this is just the business of the local entities involved
A response from Houchen on the author of the article published by Private Eye
*response
A reply to Houchen on his post about this on Facebook. This shocked me
A related historical Private Eye podcast. Why trust this? Not necessarily doing so. Just more context private-eye.co.uk/podcast/76
This goes back to the last seat that was counted where Steve Turner, Middlesbrough PCC, was also running as councillor
The news report to go with it
Some context for change in police numbers in Cleveland. It is the bar at the very bottom
Other local policing context, so I wonder how pleased officers were to be sent on these visits gazettelive.co.uk/news/teesside-…
Corroborates this in days preceding
His response to @SamCoatesSky
@SamCoatesSky As a little more context for the complaint about size of imprint denoting party on leaflets. This is from @clearpolitic5. These are all Conservative candidates Image
A campaign well worth supporting
Recent @yorkshirepost reporting on the site sale value that is the main bone of contention yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/politics/…
@yorkshirepost Mr Houchen views this as all the questions answered. Still unsure how a 2021 document valuing the site at £15m relates to the sale? @BenHouchen • IMPORTANT:SeA...
There do still appear to be questions
While I try to work out if I have the wrong end of sticks. This is on the Freeports that Thatcher tried
This is @TomLarkinSky who was working on the Sky report with a thread
A key part of this thread here
A related statement earlier
A reminder of why I'm skipping between Turner and freeport stories
The charm offensive
Something from the House of Lords
Now it has hit the Financial Times ft.com/content/c5c6a3…
Will this outlet and author be called raging communists and be accused of working with Labour?
That was Ben Houchen's response to Private Eye in case you missed it
Prior claim re National Audit Office @BenHouchen The National Au...
Something more recent from Private Eye. Alt Text across 2 tweets NEWS: PORT IN A STORM THE l...
I suspect little motivates most journalists more than being attacked The mayor also claimed that...
Pertinent @FT extract re transparency Aside from the project's fi...
One of the two key developers who own 90% of the site under discussion has bought a local hotel. Perhaps that will come in handy for media that visit? gazettelive.co.uk/news/teesside-…
Yorkshire Post on the investors
It would seem judicious to have the National Audit Office do a review if a project is beset by questions about transparency and due diligence. It is part of a flagship strategy, surely it makes sense to counter concerns vs ever more aggressively attack critics?
If there is central government intervention to establish the investment oversight bodies, counter to an initial local vote, should there not be central governance of later conduct? Alex Cunningham › (Stockton...Image
The direct link to the debate in Hansard hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2023-0…
From the author of the @FT piece
Some local scrutiny of reporters
Local politics remains fraught. The deputy Mayor lost her post along with Preston. Separately election as councillor argued to be grounds to stay on the board of the Development Corporation gazettelive.co.uk/news/teesside-… Clir Smiles, who represents...
Contrary to assurances from local Tory MPs Clarke and Mortimer Now, comments from a parlia...
Another small detail. An apparent change to a TVCA payment between the time of a Tees Valley Monitor screenshot and review by the author of the FT story
The first report by @leighsus in his new @yorkshirepost role yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/people/le…
Back to embattled PCC Turner gazettelive.co.uk/news/teesside-…
Related point of order in parliament
As an aside, a 2020 Open Democracy article. Extra fighting funds for some Red Wall candidates including Clarke opendemocracy.net/en/dark-money-… In Middlesbrough South and ...
Journalists investigating have now appealed directly to the national audit office for more scrutiny
As has Shadow Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, Lisa Nandy
As will, believe it or not, Houchen
I suspect the NAO have rarely been this popular. Will wait to see what transpires
All in the spirit we now expect Leigh Jones @leighsus Writi...
Mr Clarke has not reacted here, but this is on the recent @FT story Simon Clarke MP I @SimonCla...
From the thread by @JenWilliams_FT Jennifer Williams @JenWilli...
@JenWilliams_FT It appears Mr Clarke will be on GB News with Mr Wootton to respond
For those who are interested Simon Clarke MP I @SimonCla...
The story so far here if easier threadreaderapp.com/thread/1653714…
Tomorrow's @yorkshirepost frontpage
The PR budget mentioned previously
Broader Commons scrutiny for all the freeports and investment zones
We owe quite the debt to @NEBylines @PrivateEyeNews @TeesVMonitor @JayMitchinson @SamCoatesSky @leighsus @TomLarkinSky @JenWilliams_FT and a raft of locals who kept attention on this. Independent media is a key pillar of democracy
@NEBylines @PrivateEyeNews @TeesVMonitor @JayMitchinson @SamCoatesSky @leighsus @TomLarkinSky @JenWilliams_FT ICYMI The 44 page digest of local Bylines articles on freeports mentioned in the HoL h/t @BylinesCymru bylines.cymru/wp-content/upl…
A response from government
May I humbly suggest that lack of prior scrutiny may explain the lack of evidence. In addition it is best to robustly refute claims of corruption vs denying, when this is the acknowledged history of events
It mirrors the PM's line and does not inspire confidence in extent of laissez faire for these freeports
About the same at #PMQs
The exchange in question. Some of the context above may help #PMQs
Time to revisit the top of the thread
There is an audit stumbling block. The government
This was quoted there. There is no block, but needs to be signed off
Discussions reportedly underway
@leighsus noting the PM, a reply to them, Davison, and Clarke at PMQs are all aligned on the 'leave it to the local entities' position
Some pre-reading above for #NewsNight
Coffey is also accountable for any environmental issues in Teesside
Counterpoints / Misinformation?
Coffey on 2021 and more recently reported impact on Teesside sealife
In other news, Private Eye again
Renewed calls for an inquiry now from Lisa Nandy
Some perspective on the gaps in governance from @JenWilliams_FT
Some history on prior enterprises northeastbylines.co.uk/how-tees-valle…
Noting which local journalists were interviewed by #NewsNight. Just the Northern Echo
A state aid and public funding legal specialist with 3 key questions
A clip from #NewsNight
Financial risk is just one element of this. Another is how people seek redress for any issue. If NAO is not given leave to review in detail, then all transparency depends on those with most to gain and most to lose, including the local PCC
Now a reaction from Houchen Ben Houchen @BenHouchen The...
This is what he is referring to
May I suggest that a politicised push to align with the party in the run up to an election, is not quite the same thing as locals finding they have no defined recourse to an independent oversight body re potentially material environmental risks and contract due diligence?
Another useful point. It was not do nothing, or do this. Questions are about the path to current state and likely outcomes
As a slight departure. I had reason to look back at some Vote Leave site content recently. This is from the internet archive. It is very reminiscent of the TVCA ticker of money that would have been spent.
I do not claim to be impartial in this thread. I am not happy with this government for many reasons. But I am doing my utmost to keep this factual. The lack of clarity is what motivates me most. No-one can manage risk without transparency and effective accountability
Meanwhile one local paper is reporting a bin fire. The irony is not lost on me
Some perspective on original plans
Waiting for the furore to die down?
Apparently not. Ministers refused
Response to adjacent calls for for assessment of Brexit impact
Benn with complementary points: If transparency is denied after issues arise, how can we a) deem change to have a mandate and b) have means to strategically plan?
Stray *for there
How is this now being left to the local entities if the block is Gove?
Can the government have this both ways? Leave it to locals, but Gove intervening to establish the MDC and now Gove and Davison intervening again re locally requested STDC / TVCA audit
Are local people being told that no matter the outcome in terms of sale of public assets, impact, and disbursement of monies, there is no means to get clarity?
On Gove and the Middlesbrough Development Corporation
Something @JenWilliams_FT also covered at the time it happened
Might I suggest this whole saga is not doing much for public trust in both the government and the prospect of other such freeports and investment zones
Quite a lot does remain unclear
As others have pointed out, Ben Houchen is free to sue Private Eye, Yorkshire Post and the FT for defamation should he wish to
Express article shared by Houchen Ben Houchen Retweeted Calgi...
The other local MP enters the fray about the #NewsNight report

MP for Redcar and Cleveland @JacobYoungMP Spot on from...
With enthusiastic backing Ben Houchen @BenHouchen The...
To Houchen's point about Andy Burnham. I have always been an equal opportunity supporter of robust transparency for the actions of devolved local government
The portion of the thread about the Redcar and Cleveland elections
Checking in on Simon Clarke MP Simon Clarke MP I @SimonCla...Simon Clarke MP @SimonClark...
Again perhaps worth reiterating that calls from Andy McDonald were to investigate the evidence in Private Eye and Financial Times reports. Clarke is also free to sue either

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
　

Keep Current with Sarah Clarke

Sarah Clarke Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @TrialByTruth

Sarah Clarke Profile picture
Sep 2, 2023
The RAAC thing has completely broken my head. The timing has to be a decision, unless it was forced by a leak. This government that did everything not to shut schools doing this? What is going on? I suspect more will come out
Perhaps close enough to the election to guarantee the cost is a problem for the next administration. @bylinetimes reporting in June, to go with what you know about Gove cancelling the school building programme in 2010. It's a 'Why now?' not 'Why? question bylinetimes.com/2023/06/28/hun…
Gareth Davies, head of the NAO said: "At present, 700,000 pupils are learning in schools requiring major rebuilding or refurbishment. DfE has, since 2021, assessed the risk of school building failure or collapse as critical and very likely, but it has not been able to reduce this risk. More widely, it has an ambitious strategy for decarbonising the education estate but no plan for how it will achieve this or how much it is likely to cost." Conservative MP Philip Dunne, chair of the Commons' Environmental Audit Committee, said the NAO's report is "raising alarm bells on the co...
@BylineTimes On Gove's 2010 decision theguardian.com/education/2012…
Read 55 tweets
Sarah Clarke Profile picture
Aug 13, 2023
Why is our human rights act and ECHR inconvenient for government? Not just about people on small boats. What could a government do to you and your family if there is no backstop to appeal elsewhere and laws can be changed and passed with little consideration of human rights?
That is the frustration driving this move. The NHS data reuse and AI ambitions are central here, as are the plans for deregulation. If done carelessly and workers rights and consumer rights are run roughshod over, the equation is 'Will we get caught and can we be sanctioned?'
That is evidenced here from when an EU delegation came to review plans for Data Protection divergence with the Data Reform Bill (DPDI No.2 Bill as it is now) One, a human rights barrister who didn't want to be named, said: "I'm worried for my safety, I've not been before; other lawyers have told me they are worried too." Stephanie Harrison QC specialises in challenging the detention of vulnerable migrants, including people with mental health problems and trafficking and torture survivors. She said the "deliberate" decision of the home secretary and the government to "turn on" lawyers was a tactic used by authoritarian states.
Read 14 tweets
Sarah Clarke Profile picture
Aug 11, 2023
We are being turned into a foreign owned industrial estate, with a wealth management outfit in London tacked onto it
What gives me that impression?
Source for that - @jburnmurdoch ft.com/content/e5c741…
Read 24 tweets
Sarah Clarke Profile picture
Aug 10, 2023
Matt heaping on the easy to agree with nostalgia, with a nascent movement entirely dependent on social media and targeting people to foster grievance at some poorly defined blob of 'new elite' people
Free Speech Union, as the main partner organisation, is run by an Oxford graduate who has spent most of his life as contrarian loud hailer. All about the terrors of wokeness, diversity, and lack of race science in public policy. What exactly is fought for against and for here?
Anyway, make your own mind up, as folk keep saying bylinetimes.com/2021/02/16/fre…
Read 20 tweets
Sarah Clarke Profile picture
Aug 10, 2023
A nominally new sovereignty fight to congeal around for the election. Won't happen, for good reasons, but that simply adds grist to the mill for arguing 'EU' interference (it's Council of Europe, not part of the EU body we left)
If this government can pull off getting people to vote against their own Human Rights, then we would see rights in domestic law erode for all in the next parliament. What would weaker human rights do? Sure you can treat migrants how the heck you like, but same for everyone
Onwards and don't swerve to spare the proles? This is not exactly a quiet ambition. When Cameron had Beechcroft look into no fault firing, main flies in the ointment were equalities law, human rights act, EU worker protections, and ECHR appeal mechanisms. Not about your freedom
Read 26 tweets
Sarah Clarke Profile picture
Aug 9, 2023
This is like letting NHS backlogs grow and staff leave so we hate that enough to tolerate NHS private rescue packages. These people are that utilitarian about lives. Suck it and see, fatally
Do you really see different?
Calling Jenrick far right? Is that unhelpful hyperbole? Turning Point UK, Meloni, and others agree. Saying what they see now https://t.co/xSsbzt6amL
Image
Read 34 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

Send Email!

:(