Muhammad Shehada Profile picture
May 11, 2023 • 7 tweets • 4 min read • Read on X
Quickđź§µDebunking #Israel's "Human Shields" lie used as a blanket excuse to justify killing ANY Palestinian civilians:

e.g. IDF officials admit they 100% knew children & women would die in their strikes. They went for it anyways & called them "collateral damage" & "human shields" Image
2\ Amnesty found ZERO evidence of Palestinian combatants forcefully taking civilians as human shields or preventing them from evacuating targeted areas

The #Israeli org Breaking the Silence interviewed 100s of IDF soldiers, but never encountered evidence of those "human shields" Image
3\ #Israel's own courts, however, found evidence of Israeli soldiers taking Palestinians as human shields at gun point

IDF calls it the "neighbor procedure"

Amnesty, HRW, BTselem... all found evidence of Israel taking Palestinian human shields since the occupation began in 1967 Image
4\ #Israel deems ALL Palestinians in Gaza "human shields" by virtue of just living in the same neighborhoods with possible Hamas or PIJ members (even non-combatants)!

Can Hamas equally claim that it has a right to target Israeli cities b/c IDF soldiers live among civilians? Image
5\ An #Israeli "evidence" for "human shields" is a 2014 Hamas leader praising Gazans who refused to evacuate their home so that Israel bombs it to the ground.

HRW said this doesn't amount to the crime of human shields but rather a form of "peaceful protest" & defending homes! Image
6\ Amnesty concluded that even guerrilla warfare tactics in a densely populated urban space such as "storing munitions in civilian buildings of launching attacks from the vicinity of civilian buildings" do NOT amount to the crime of "Human Shields" under International Law. Image
7\ "Human Shields" are still civilians who don't lose their protected status whatsoever. Targeting them is still a War Crime.

#Israel's "Human Shields" canard is vile, racist & dehumanizing. It implies that Palestinians don't value their lives & have no agency! It's a 100% lie! Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Muhammad Shehada

Muhammad Shehada Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @muhammadshehad2

Aug 25
Israeli propagandists got their marching orders: blame Egypt for Israel's famine in Gaza. So here are the factsđź§µ

1- Egypt doesn't control its borders with Gaza, Israel does b/c it occupies Rafah (as Ravid points out)

Israel is NOT allowing ANY food to come from Egypt into Gaza Image
2- Israel fully depopulated all of Rafah & most of Khan Younis.

If Egypt sends any trucks into Gaza, there are NO Palestinians on the other side to receive it, there's only IDF troops in those dark purple coloured areas (& Israel's proxy Abu Shabab gang that loots aid)! Image
3- From the start of the genocide, Israel explicitly told Egypt it would bomb any aid convoys that cross from the Rafah crossing into Gaza

Israel then bombed the Rafah crossing multiple times to emphasize that threat & shut the crossing down
aa.com.tr/en/middle-east…Image
Image
Read 6 tweets
Aug 22
🚨Debunking Israel's talking points about over 83% of causalities in Gaza being civilians🧵

Claim 1: "The 8,900 figure only includes Hamas militants targeted in intelligence-led precision strikes, not those killed in combat"

False! IDF standard procedure is to photograph bodies of Gazans killed in the field, e.g. in designated "extermination zones" or in combat, & collecting details such as ID cards or phones from the bodies.

Soldiers then send those pictures & confiscated belongings to the Israeli intelligence "to verify militant status." Less than 5% of those causalities are identified as Hamas after intel analysis.Image
Claim 2: "Hamas admitted in Feb 2024 losing 6,000 fighters, so 8900 by May 2025 is an undercount"

Hamas never made that statement! They immediately & officially denied its veracity & called out the outlet that attributed it to an unnamed anonymous Hamas source! Image
Claim 3: "8,900 killed militants is an underestimate"

No! It's an overestimate; this is the same database that listed Anas Al-Sharif, Ismael al-Ghoul, Hassan Islaih & others are "Hamas militants"

Israel's database also includes people who have long ceased to have any combatant role (e.g. veteran wounded in previous wars, people who quit Hamas or the Qassam, people who deserted their positions & fled... none of those would be regarded as militants under the laws of war).

Additionally, Israel's database designates someone as a militant in Gaza based on intel, probability, social media, intercepted calls, whatsapp groups, old & new Hamas documents... It's not a conclusive database of who is a militant, but an estimation of who Israel considers to be "highly likely" a militant.
Read 5 tweets
Aug 11
🚨This message is completely FAKE!

Just went through all of Anas al-Sharif's messages on Oct 7, 2023, no such messages exists.

Telegram doesn't even put the date on messages.

Israel is so desperate to justify murdering Gaza's top journalist, but all they have are doctored docs, fake screenshots & a picture he took *as a journalist* with Gaza's rulers.Image
Even if Anas wrote this fake message, even if he took selfies with every single Hamas leader on the face of earth, even if he was once a militant in 2017...

NONE of this would justify murdering him! Israel didn't provide any evidence Anas was actively taking part in hostilities or combat!
This was Anas’s message history on that day. Notice there’s nothing at 15:49, there’s no date on the message Image
Read 4 tweets
Aug 8
Folks are asking what does Netanyahu’s occupation plan mean, since Israel already occupies Gaza?

It means implementing the notorious “Generals Plan” to Gaza city, Deir al-Bala & Nusairat; the only last 3 areas Israel hasn’t fully wiped out & where most Gazans are sheltering🧵 Image
2\ The “Generals Plan” is ethnic cleansing (per Israel itself) done in 5 steps:
Fully encircle & besiege a city
Cut food & water & take hospitals & other vital services out
Bomb incessantly by air, land & sea
Invade gradually & force people out at gunpoint
Flatten everything Image
3\ Israel tested the "Generals Plan" in Northern Gaza in late 2024

There were around 150,000 Gazans there at the start

IDF surrounded them, cut off all food & water for over 100 days, gradually advanced from all directions, forced people out until only about 12,000 were left. Image
Read 11 tweets
Jul 31
The ultimate gift to Hamas is NOT a few countries' symbolic recognition of Palestine

The ultimate gift to Hamas is Netanyahu & Trump humiliating, weakening, sanctioning & bankrupting the Palestinian Authority no matter how far Abbas goes to appease Israel & the USđź§µ
2\ Hamas' key argument for armed resistance is that nonviolence, advocacy, civil disobedience, international courts, diplomacy, peace processes are all futile & if you try them you'd only get smacked & demonized by Israel & the US without achieving any tangible results
3\ Hamas' main case study to legitimize their path is to point out how Mahmoud Abbas recognized Israel, renounced violence, suppressed intifadas, & actively collaborates with the US & Israel against fellow Palestinians

Then they'd ask "what did Abbas get out of this? Nothing"
Read 10 tweets
Jul 16
We warned about this 8 months ago; Israel's 5 finger policy of dissecting Gaza into smaller concentration camps using "security corridors" (i.e. extermination zones):

Everything on both sides of each corridor is then gradually wiped out

Latest corridor👇 ecfr.eu/publication/de…Image
Image
2\ You can already see how Israel systematically demolished every single building on both sides of its latest "corridor" in Khan Younis

Those "corridors" are deadlier than the Berlin Wall; anyone trying to cross from one side to another is instantly executed
3\ Each time Israel creates a "security corridor" (i.e. extermination zone), they gradually expand its width until it becomes a giant strip of wasteland

Netzarim started as a narrow route, quickly expanded to 4 miles (6.5 km) in width
Every single building in there was wiped out Image
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(