The history of how GET & CBT have been promoted, prescribed & researched is alarming. Sadly, these mistakes are now affecting people with #LongCovid.
1/
In response, the authors point out that 3 clinicians resigned from the NICE guideline committee before publication. This is true but misleading. NICE’s minutes state: “The whole guideline was agreed by the committee … before there were resignations.” nice.org.uk/guidance/ng206…
2/
Apr 5, 2021 • 7 tweets • 6 min read
Wow! @GeorgeMonbiot is cited as a cause of #LongCovid (along with support groups & doctors) by Prof Sharpe in a presentation to Swiss Re, a reinsurance company associated with denying payments to people with ME/CFS: swissre.com/dam/jcr:788aa2…
This could be a big own goal.
1/
More on Swiss Re and its connections to Prof Sharpe’s colleague and fellow PACE trial PI Prof Peter White here: virology.ws/2017/08/07/tri… (blog by @davidtuller1).
Looking forward to your next column on Long Covid and ME/CFS, @GeorgeMonbiot.
2/
Jan 28, 2021 • 11 tweets • 6 min read
Dr Clare Gerada talking about #LongCovid on BBC Breakfast this morning: “There is nothing that isn’t made better through exercise. OK. Nothing. No matter what age, what condition, exercise will always improve it.” 1/
Staggering claim from former RCGP chair. Deeply offensive & harmful to millions of people with illnesses that are not made better by exercise. Draft NICE draft guideline for ME/CFS specifically warns against graded exercise. Please correct & apologise @BBCBreakfast@TVNaga01. 2/
Nov 16, 2020 • 4 tweets • 2 min read
My letter to the BMJ highlighting the harms of graded exercise therapy and PACE-type CBT for people with ME/CFS, and calling on those who have failed patients by promoting ineffective and harmful treatments to acknowledge their mistakes and apologise: bmj.com/content/371/bm…
There is also an excellent letter by Andrew Devereux-Cook which makes some very good points, including how chronic underinvestment in ME/CFS research may now be impacting on people with #LongCovid. He also highlights the important work of @DecodeMEstudy: bmj.com/content/371/bm…
Speakers include: Dr Clare Gerada, Prof Lynne Turner-Stokes and Professor Trudie Chalder. All prominent advocates of graded exercise therapy (GET) and CBT for ME/CFS.
2) The new NICE draft Guideline on ME/CFS states that patients should not be given GET or CBT as a treatment: nice.org.uk/guidance/GID-N…
#LongHaulers may question whether those who have promoted these treatments for ME should be advising on #LongCovid.