I thought I'd have a look at the FB targeted ads that have recently been published. We know that VL told porkies, but I wanted to see how much of their campaign was untruthful.
It seems that it was pretty much all of it. #VoteLeaveLied
Here's a sample of the worst offenders 1/17
We know that they targeted groups with their own special trigger messages & we know that they lied about the EU budget contribution (gross of Β£225m/wk, net Β£203m/wk), but Β£350m wasn't just on the bus ... it was pretty much everywhere in their ads 2/17
It started in their data capture con they used to get your information (Trump had Kogan & CA, VL used their Β£50m competition)
Β£50m/day = Β£350m/wk 3/17
Once they'd sorted out their target audiences, they started the targeted lying.
Concerned about industry of manufacturing? Have one of these
(are we spending that fake Β£350m/wk on the NHS, or industry?) 4/17
Are you concerned about animal welfare?
Have one of these 5/17
Concerned about immigration? Well, have I got some lies for YOU!!
(in case you've not already realised this - BREAKING NEWS: Turkey is not joining the EU anytime soon) 7/17
And it looks like Albania & Macedonia aren't getting on as well as they'd hoped with their accession dw.com/en/opinion-mac⦠8/17
What about the deal with Turkey & their visas?
Well that was only Schengen, & that's not going too well, so this was a lie too 9/17
My mistake. If you've got kids, you were probably told we'd be spending that fake Β£350m/wk on schools
Btw - EU migrants to the UK pay more in than they cost (including their share of "fixed" costs, like defence - how their contributions are spent is up to govt) 10/17
No - as you were. We're going to spend it on the NHS.
BTW - 10% of doctors in the NHS are EU27 citizens, compared to 5% of the popn. The doctor you see is more likely to be an EU citizen than the patient sitting next to you. 11/17
Yes - we're definitely going to spend that fake Β£350m/wk on the NHS. It was Reason #46 for leaving 12/17
And, of course, if we left the EU, we wouldn't be forced to help bail out Greece, would we?
What? You mean we didn't help Greece, & were under no obligation to? bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politiβ¦
Seems that VL were lying again 13/17
Sovereignty though! There were a number of ads to convince people that the EU was both undemocratic & corrupt. You can research that yourself, but it's not true 14/17
If you're a Corbynista, here's one for you. Unlike the rest of these I've highlighted, it's not a direct lie, just very misleading.
Yes Corbyn is Eurosceptic (some would say he's a closet Leaver), but the quote was from 1993 15/17
Finally, it's hardly surprising that Yorkshire voted Leave, because they were targeted with these ads
BTW - VL didn't tell you that the EU solidarity fund paid for emergency relief, nor that other EU funds were being spent on flood defense, did they? 16/17
So there you have it. The fake Β£350m/wk is going to be simultaneously spent on industry, schools, hospitals, NHS staff, & flood defences (depending on who you are).
Yes, I know it's not Β£350m/wk, but you must have realised by now - #VoteLeaveLied
/end
β’ β’ β’
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I had an interesting conversation yesterday with a group of #Tory voters about the #NHS.
The consensus was that "we can't afford to keep pouring money into the NHS. It's inefficient, & needs a good manager to wade in & sort it out."
A 𧡠1/11
They went on to discuss nurses (mixed reviews between very caring, & spending their shift at the nurses' station huddled around a computer, rather than being on the ward), & the difficulty of getting a face-to-face meeting with a GP.
2/11
They also compared the NHS with healthcare in France, where apparently there is a similar shortage in GPs, but no problem in arranging an appointment.
The general view was that healthcare in France is superior to that in the UK.
3/11
I heard someone today assert that we needn't worry too much about the rising number of Covid hospital admissions, because they're only staying in for a day.
That's interesting, I thought, & reassuring if true.
So I looked into it.
1/7
2/7 I couldn't find any stats on length of stay, so the assertion appears to be based on anecdote.
But what I did find is not quite so reassuring.
The number of Covid patients in hospital are not climbing as steeply as infections, but they ARE climbing
3/7 So I thought I'd look further, & see how many of those Covid patients are severely ill. The only measure of this that I have is the number on ventilators.
After all, they don't put a patient on a ventilator for the lolz.
Mini thread
I was volunteering at a stall this afternoon.
I like working on People's Vote stalls. You get to hear all sorts of stories & perspectives, from both sides of the divide.
1/8
Today, I spoke to a leave voter that couldn't wait to get out. He was 70, a retired businessman in the cosmetics industry who traded world-wide, & didn't like the EU.
With EU regulations on cosmetics safety being amongst the toughest in the world, I can imagine why.
2/8
I asked him to look at what Patrick Minford said would happen to our manufacturing industry & agriculture (he'd not heard of Minford, nor his expectations).
His wife promised that she would make sure he did.
3/8
Like many, I signed a petition calling for a referendum on Mrs May's proposed Brexit, & today I received the response from the govt.
For those that didn't sign up to this particular petition, I reproduce it here, with my response
My MP, @JHowellUK probably hasn't seen it
1/14
The response came from the Department for Exiting the European Union.
It starts by insisting that the govt will "respect the result of the 2016 ref"
This is such a key point that they say it twice, using "clear" on both occasions to emphasise it.
2/14
But look at that 3rd paragraph.
Apparently the 2016 ref gave a very clear instruction to the govt.
If it was so clear, why is there so much discord amongst Leave voters? Not one of those I met outside Parliament on 29/01 were happy
3/14
#MondayMotivation
I recently published a thread looking at #LeaveLies. Not surprisingly, I got responses that "both sides lied". After a bit of to & fro, @Jamiepembs kindly sent me some links which demonstrated #RemainLies
The 1st link was, on the surface, a little disappointing. It appeared to just make the assertion that "Campaigners on both sides of the EU Referendum made false claims" with no evidence of either #RemainLies or #LeaveLies
If you look carefully in that page, you'll see a link to a comparison of the Vote Leave & Stronger In leaflets. The 1st thing I noted was that the Leave list was longer, but I'm here to look into #RemainLies. This is an image, but the individual links are included below 3/18