Thread by @EFF

Earlier this month, Mexico passed a catastrophic new #copyright law, virtually overnight, without adequate consultation or debate. They did it as part of Donald Trump's #USMCA treaty.

1/15

eff.org/deeplinks/2020…

The law is incompatible with the Mexican Constitution, a remarkable document that has some of the most stringent protections for free expression in the world.

2/15

eff.org/deeplinks/2020…

The law mandates copyright filters for online services. These are the automated algorithms that block you from posting anything that someone has identified as their copyrighted work.

3/15

Filters are blatantly unconstitutional. They represent "prior restraint" on speech - removal of content without a hearing or a court order. They are really poor substitutes for a judge.

4/15

Filters can't tell if the copyright claim they're honoring is real or fraudulent. They can't tell if they're matching your own piano performance of a classical composition or one that Sony Music has registered.

5/15

wikimediafoundation.org/news/2018/08/2…

They can't tell if they're removing your walk in the park because an unscrupulous company has claimed copyright on the birds singing in the background:

6/15

support.google.com/youtube/forum/…

They can't tell if you're documenting a war-crime:

7/15

reuters.com/article/us-glo…

They can't tell if you're livestreaming a scientific symposium where music is played on the lunch break:

8/15

They can't tell if you're recording a protest where people are playing music:

9/15

lumendatabase.org/blog_entries/b…

They can't tell if you're a giant media company presenting your own TV show at Comic-Con!

10/15

deadline.com/2020/07/star-t…

Filters can't tell if you're making a permitted use of a copyrighted work - criticism, parody, etc. They can't tell if you're quoting something in the public domain, like the works of Juana Inés de la Cruz.

11/15

Filters can’t tell if you’re an artist being blackmailed by a copyfraudster who demands cash or they’ll have your work removed:

12/15

torrentfreak.com/youtube-strike…

When filters get it wrong, you have to get in line to get your free expression out of copyright jail. That takes a long time. How long? How about TWENTY EIGHT MONTHS:

13/15

jwz.org/blog/2020/05/f…

Mexicans have the right to participate in their culture. The Internet is where our politics, civics, education and family life take place. Filters remove our speech at the speed of a computer, and the companies put it back at the speed of glaciers.

14/15

Mexico's National Commission for Human Rights has the power to overturn this unconstitutional, terrible law. It must act to do so!

15/15