There is a lot of talk about how two or more crises are over-lapping right now - #Covid19 along with #BLM protests, the drive to defund police, political unrest in the U.S. etc. But there isn't enough discussion about overlap with growing wealth inequality. #cdnpoli#onpoli 1/11
It's well-established that racialized communities, immigrants, and poorer Canadians are bearing the brunt of #Covid19. Minimum-wage workers are "essential" while highly paid professionals (inc. myself) work from home. The contradiction is obvious. #cdnpoli#onpoli 2/11
We've become used to the idea that money makes everything easier. Why shouldn't it? Well-off families pay for private tutoring with similarly privileged children, while everyone else send their kids back to unprepared public schools. Ever thus, right? #cdnpoli#onpoli 3/11
The truth is that this problem has been very real, and accelerating, for a long time before #Covid19. For a good basic explanation, here's a video from the Broadbent Institute. Yes, it's an NDP think tank. Just watch the video. #cdnpoli#onpoli 4/11
That summary from 2014 captures the problem in 2012. It's gotten worse since. The way to think of wealth inequality is to compare the problem with global warming. It's a runaway train accelerating for a long time now. It's NOT how things have "always been." #cdnpoli#onpoli 5/11
Wealth inequality has also always been a life or death topic. Poorer people access worse healthcare (yes, even in Canada), work at more dangerous jobs, and have weaker supports at all stages of life. Sadly, we've gotten used to this and accept it as given. #cdnpoli#onpoli 6/11
It isn't new that wealth inequality compels poorer Canadians to risk their health, and the health of their children, in ways that more privileged people avoid. It's just suddenly in-your-face and newsworthy. Which is, at least, an opportunity to confront it. #cdnpoli#onpoli 7/11
Like many things, our problem in Canada is less bad than the American version. But it's still a cancer eating at the foundation of our society. "We're all in this together" rings pretty hollow to people who have little stake in "this" to begin with. #cdnpoli#onpoli 8/11
I have no grand conclusion here, or solution to propose. Wish I did. The reasons for growing concentration of wealth in the hands of the already wealthy are complex and difficult to address. Fixing it will be a generational problem to confront. #cdnpoli#onpoli 9/11
But like global warming, to start, we need to face the painful truth. This isn't normal. It's not how things have always been. It's not only intolerable now, but getting worse every year with no end in sight. And we need to do something about it together. #cdnpoli#onpoli 10/11
The pandemic may end with a vaccine. Science may even address global warming. But wealth inequality can only be fixed by confronting our values. We've accepted this for too long. If this pandemic helps wake us up, that's a silver lining worth reaching for. #cdnpoli#onpoli 11/11
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Let's be clear what "conscience rights" really means. It's the idea that no professional should be required to do something they disagree with, even if needed to give effect to someone else's rights or as part of doing their own job properly. #cdnpoli 1/6 globalnews.ca/news/9180654/c…
"Conscience rights" can apply to lots of situations. Some teachers don't believe in evolution. Should they be required to teach it? Some nurses and doctors don't believe in ending a pregnancy or even contraception. Should they be required to provide this information? #cdnpoli 2/6
At the most extreme, some police officers don't agree with gun control, or apprehending a child from a parent, or enforcing the mental health act. Should they be required to enforce even laws they disagree with? Frankly, yes, yes, yes, and yes some more. #cdnpoli 3/6
I don't write enough about real poverty. I do write about it, but not enough. Politics revolves around issues that get politicians elected - right now that's the middle-class squeeze, inflation, cost of daycare - not what it's like to go hungry or be homeless. #onpoli 1/15
People get wrapped up in their own problems and concerns. That may not be admirable, but it's normal. When you're worried about the price of gas or the interest rate on your mortgage, real poverty may not seem to be an active concern for you. But it is. #onpoli 2/15
We all live in the same society together. We can't wash our hands of each other's problems and pretend they don't exist. There are politicians selling that line to people who want to believe it but it's a lie. If the house next door is burning down, it IS my problem. #onpoli 3/15
Apparently I hate Canada and I want to destroy it. I hear that a lot. So do many politicians, wide groups of bureaucrats and public employees, anyone in media, and sometimes the entire membership of registered political parties. Let's talk about what that means. #cdnpoli 1/8
A very few unhinged people think that I and many, many others are agents of foreign powers. As in, I've been somehow recruited to undermine Canada, where I live and was born. I don't know how to reason with that but it's a small part of the problem, so let's move on. #cdnpoli 2/8
Most people, when they say someone hates Canada, mean that person has a vision of Canada they disagree with. As in, you believe I hate the Canada that exists in your own mind because the Canada that exists in mine is different. And that makes sense, to a point. #cdnpoli 3/8
The Liberal Party, as it exists, is not welcoming to or accepting of the center-right. There, I said it. Call them red tories, mainstream conservatives or any other name you like. We've done a piss-poor job of keeping these people in the fold and a reckoning is due. #cdnpoli 1/14
Language matters, and I'd like to unpack what we mean when we describe people as "not tolerable." I'd also like to unpack what the right and alt-right mean when they describe Trudeau and others as "woke." Because these are the words that divide us. #cdnpoli 2/14
There are some truly intolerable ideas and beliefs out there - things we can never accept or accommodate. But that needs to be reserved for genuine evil and not just political difference. We've lost that thread. Everyone we disagree with, lately, is "intolerable." #cdnpoli 3/14
I'm trying to understand what's happening with politics in Canada, especially on the right. I read a lot of comments, though I obviously don't have time to pick fights with all of them. Still, I have to say, I'm discouraged. We're seeing the worst in people, lately. #cdnpoli 1/9
I'm seeing freedom defined as never having to do what you're told - even if that's just to not make life worse for other people. Forget about legal and illegal for a moment. We're just talking about human decency here. Apparently we're only free when that's optional. #cdnpoli 2/9
I'm seeing equality defined as a society where government does nothing to help people at all, and just lets them sink or swim on their own. That's what's "fair" apparently. As opposed to taxation for any purpose, which is apparently communism. #cdnpoli 3/9
I pissed off ring-wing twitter quite a lot by pointing out that "gatekeeper" is a nonsense term as Poilievre uses it. I got told, time and again, that everyone knows who "they" are, and was offered a wide variety of definitions that don't agree with one another. #cdnpoli 1/7
I don't deny the word "gatekeeper" has power and can be effective. If you're angry about anything, you can find someone to blame for it, rightly or wrongly. Everyone hearing the term knows who their "gatekeeper" is. It means whatever you need it to mean. #cdnpoli 2/7
The trick to Poilievre's rhetoric - and it's intentional, believe me - is that people really do think he has specific "gatekeepers" in mind. People really do believe Poilievre has a list and a plan, and if they only give him power he'll get rid of them all. #cdnpoli 3/7