Many people are coming up with the `let us write everything in Devanagari' trick. This is the first step to destruction of non-Hindi languages, as the native script is the link to the heritage. Poor KPs are facing the heat today as they cannot reinstitute their script at all.
Let us turn it round. Let us write Sanskrit also [those of us who wish to read and write Sanskrit, that is] in our local script. The reason why this should be done is the tendency of Hindi supremacists to destroy every other language, claiming that they are all Hindi dialects.
The reason why we should write Sanskrit in our own scripts, apart from comfort for ourselves, is normative inversion, which is a powerful trick against misappropriation. Every state has contributed to Sanskrit, and it is important to safeguard these contributions.
Finally, there is the false notion that `Devanagari is the natural script of Sanskrit'. Nothing could be farther than the truth. Sanskrit was written in Sharada script in Kashmir, Kannada script in Karnataka, Bangla script in Bengal, Telugu script in AP and Telangana, etc.
We should focus on reclaiming our heritage fully by focussing our energies on the local script and language. Sanskrit is the heritage of every state in India [and even Tibet, Java, Bali, Cambodia, etc], and those who wish to learn Sanskrit are best equipped in local scripts.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Shanmukh

Shanmukh Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @maidros78

8 Oct
Reading history of Tibetan Buddhism, almost all their teachers and concepts were from India. In fact, Bihar has been the biggest contributor to Tibetan Buddhism - the monasteries of Nalanda and Vikramashila gave most Buddhist teachers of central Tibet. Rest from Kashmir/NWFP.
BTW, it is another piece of nonsense that Indians did not travel abroad. They travelled a lot, especially the Buddhist and Hindu teachers. Already [reading history ~1200], I have come across more than a dozen Buddhist teachers from India going to Tibet and teaching there.
In fact, even Nepalese Buddhists routinely got teachers from India-from the same Vikramashila and Nalanda monasteries. In 1100, both were flourishing and producing Buddhist scholars by the ton. So much for `Buddhism died due to Hinduism in India' theories. cc @SVOjha @SAnsumali
Read 4 tweets
26 Sep
1) A few tweets on the Champaran issue, where people are claiming Gandhi achieved `great success'. In the following tweets, I will investigate the Champaran issue and people can judge just how much `great success' Gandhi had in this issue.
Champaran, being far up north of the Ganges, at foot of the Himalayas on Nepal border, was cut off from the rest of India. The Congress was practically unknown here. Even those who had heard the name of the Congress shrank from joining it or even mentioning it.
3) The issue there was a) increased rents. b) excesses committed by European indigo planters. c) agricultural price collapse in WW1.

Gandhi, even early in 1917, knew nothing about Champaran, not even its name or geographical position, let alone the economics of indigo planting.
Read 18 tweets
10 Sep
Since I haven't read the primary source for the Rashtrakuta bit, I won't comment on it, but @kshetragnya may want to take a look at it. However, let us correct the bit about Lalitaditya. Lalitaditya swore an oath on Parihasakeshava that the king of Gauda would be safe if he+
+came to negotiations. However, he broke his word and had the king of Gauda killed. This act is, BTW, criticised by Kalhana, who is also a Kashmiri. After this, the adherents of the king of Gauda considered the murti of Parihasakeshava violated, since Lalitaditya had sworn+
+a false oath on it. So, they sought to destroy what they considered a defiled murti. However, they destroyed another murti by mistake. This is not about the deity being the favourite of Lalitaditya, but being targeted because a false oath was sworn on it. But to come to+
Read 8 tweets
1 Sep
Tibet is India's core issue. However, our politicos, even our RW, seem to use it on and off, as a card to play and throw. It is not. There can be no security for India without Tibet. Dharmic Tibet is `us'. We need to always stand up for a sister dharmic civilisation.
Tibetan language is very close to our own, having been influenced by Sanskrit to a significant extent. Further, Tibetan writing is abugida, just like our alphabet. Finally, Tibetan has been the source of preserving much of our literature, both original and as translations.
The way our RW looks at everyone and everything commercially, even fellow dharmics, as some kind of trade goods sickens me. This core lack of commitment to fellow dharmics is what has destroyed India. Too much focus on economics and money is NOT good.
Read 7 tweets
28 Aug
Both Hindi and Urdu are victims of policies not connected to them. Urdu became the language of Islamist supremacism/separatism, and Hindu writers deserted it [many Hindus wrote in Urdu in the pre-1900 days]. This essentially sealed the fate of Urdu in India, and it lost traction.
Hindi became the language of linguistic supremacism and economic discrimination. The false idea was planted that Hindi was needed for Hindu unity and the government tried to destroy languages in south/east India. This turned away south and east Indians from the Hindi language.
In fact, if the government had not been so desperate to introduce Hindi, many south and east Indians would have learnt Hindi as they do other languages, in which they have to communicate. In the pre-1940 days, Hindi was learnt quite avidly in [the then] Madras Presidency.
Read 4 tweets
23 Aug
For those on my TL who are interested in Telugu ఛందస్సు, here is అప్పకవీయము of అప్ప కవి. archive.org/details/appaka… cc @VMuppi @MGangavalli @Half_Baaked
cc @NarasimhaRao10 Forgot to add you, in case you are interested.
cc @p_malavikapatil @HariHaraBhakta Sorry, forgot you two in the above.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!