Questions journalists could and probably should ask Sri Preston Kulkarni about the #RSS scandal:
Do you know what the specific allegations are? Can you name them?
What is the RSS? If you don't know, why don't you know?
You have strong family ties to BJP politicians in India. What is your opinion of the BJP?
Considering your BJP family ties as well as your attendance at "Howdy Modi," what is your opinion of the BJP's Modi?
You're a 14-year veteran of the US Foreign Service. Your next posting was to be at the US Embassy in New Delhi. Changing paths from being a diplomat to being a congressman, what would be your foreign policy towards India?
There's a strong push in US Congress right now for the US State Department to list India as a "Country of Particular Concern" due to religious freedom and human rights issue under the BJP government. 14 senators just signed a letter supporting it. What's your opinion of that?
A policy advisor to the BJP government's Foreign Affairs Ministry, last year, tweeted in a way that appeared to be in support of your election. How do you respond to that?
This year, a BJP executive threatened to interfere in the presidential election after Bernie Sanders criticized the BJP government's human rights violations in Kashmir. With so many concerns about foreign interference, how do you respond to this threat from India's government?
Why did you attend @hssusa event after winning the 2018 nomination? Were you aware the HSS-USA is the US wing of @RSSorg? What is your procedure for vetting an organization before associating yourself with it?
When did you learn about the RSS? What is your opinion of the organization? The RSS has been named in reports by Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, the US State Department, & others as linked to anti-minority violence. What, if anything, should be done about that?
How do you feel about RSS leaders entering & touring the US? Were you aware that one of your longest, biggest donors, who has been involved in your campaign, is a top HSS executive? Were you aware he has hosted RSS's chief in his home, apparently on multiple occasions?
When did you first meet this man, HSS's Ramesh Bhutada? He is said to have brought "financial power" to boost your campaign in its first month and get it off the ground. How heavy has his involvement in your campaign been? What will his future involvement be?
Were you aware that Bhutada organized large teams in Houston to work to get Modi elected in India? Did you know that he even sent teams back to India which included several donors to your campaign? How do you feel about having many donors who worked to get BJP and Modi elected?
Bhutada & many of your donors are associated over a period of many years with @ofbjp_usa, the US wing of the BJP. OFBJP sent teams of thousands from US to India & were instrumental in Modi's election. It was just registered as a Foreign Agent in US. How do you feel about that?
Sri Preston Kulkarni is actually the nephew of the late Pramod Mahajan, a top RSS-BJP leader who organized the "Ram Rath Yatra" in 1990s that left hundreds of Muslims dead. His cousin is Pramod's daughter, current BJP MP @poonam_mahajan.
1) He's running for Congress. He wants political power. When do you ever give people seeking political power "a break"? Isn't the duty of journalists to hold the powerful accountable and ask deeply uncomfortable questions?
2) He's a seasoned diplomat whose next posting, until he resigned, was going to be in New Delhi. Combined with his family ties to high-level BJP politicians, there is no rational explanation for his supposed ignorance of the political significance of the RSS.
The annexation of #Kashmir was "an enormously popular move among many Indian Americans," says Hindu American Foundation in this critique of my work — no mention, of course, of how Kashmiris in the diaspora or in Kashmir felt about the issue.
Ro Khanna, Pramila Jayapal, Ram Villivalam, Jay Chaudhuri, Ash Kalra, Ameya Pawar — all Hindu Democrats — have disassociated w/Hindu nationalist outfits in US, opposed various policies of Modi's regime & stood for human rights in India. Because of that, for HAF, they don't count.
Instead, HAF leaps to defend a handful of politicians who participate in events by @ofbjp_usa — a registered foreign agent — as well as by @hssusa & @VHPANews. The thread linking all these organizations together is that they spring from the Nazi-inspired #RSS paramilitary.
@MuqtedarKhan is surprised that "some Indian Muslim leaders are more interested in [Sri Preston Kulkarni's] alleged links to Hindu nationalism" than in electing a Democrat — even an #RSS-backed one.
Perhaps it's because RSS massacres Muslims in India?
@MuqtedarKhan, I recommend you spend more time studying the #RSS, what it has done already to Indian Muslims and what it plans for them in future, as well as how Hindu nationalism is a kissing cousin of white nationalism and concern for one requires equal concern for the other.
“Kulkarni has been accused of being close to Hindu nationalists,” he writes. Okay? Close HOW? Your article lacks the slightest detail. Funding? Associations? What? Are the details of the “closeness” unimportant to a journalist?
Over the past few weeks, I’ve had representatives of two different Indian political parties reach out to me and request collaboration and/or guidance on issues related to RSS-BJP.
I’ve told both the same thing: I do NOT work with political parties, either in the US or abroad.
For one thing, I’m a US citizen. I don’t work with foreign political parties. At all. I’m not interested in advancing foreign partisan interests. I’m interested in promoting global human rights.
Besides, as a US citizen - aside from the legal implications under US law - what business do I have poking my nose in the sovereign elections and partisan conflicts of foreign countries inactivities intended to promote one political party over another?
#Modi himself reportedly played a role in the #OFBJP’s development. Historians Walter Andersen and Shridhar Damle explain that he was “dispatched by the BJP to the US in 1998 to review the activities” of the group.
#TulsiGabbard was a featured speaker alongside Jolly at the August 2014 #OFBJP banquet where he spoke.... Gabbard posed for a photo with @VijayJollyBJP while wearing a #BJP scarf and holding a biography of #Modi.
The #OFBJP’s registration as a foreign agent means that, going forward, any such interactions with US elected officials must be reported to the US government.
Sri Preston Kulkarni has been questioned about the #RSS. 1st by @MuqtedarKhan; 2nd by @GhaniShariq. Both responses boil down to: "I have no connection to RSS."
Yet no one has asked why he says his campaign "literally could not have happened" w/out support by RSS's #2 man in USA.
I have reached out to @SriPKulkarni repeatedly over weeks to request an interview. He has not responded.
My questions for Sri Preston Kulkarni include:
What did you mean when you said that your campaign “literally could not have happened” without @hssusa Vice-President Ramesh Bhutada's support?