Here's a simple statement of historical fact which every American should know:
US immigration policy has always favored white northern European immigrants, but visa quotas were *explicitly* determined by eugenics & "race science" from 1921-1965.
That's it. That's the fact.
You can't know this fact to be true and honestly deny that an immigration system which only stopped relying on eugenics 15 yrs before I was born is fundamentally and irredeemably founded in white supremacy.
You just can't.
And no, since I know you're about to ask: it's not much better since the birth of the modern US immigration system in 1965.
The racial preferences and open displays of white supremacy are not only still baked in, but one of the few things both parties can still agree on.
Liberal champion Ted Kennedy fought to pass the 1965 INA knowing full that it would absolutely without question create untold #s of undocumented Mexicans within a few yrs.
He then later amended it in a desperate effort to keep white northern Europeans immigrating.
Trump has to go, but let's not convince ourselves that somehow all we need to do to scrub white supremacy from our immigration system is to elect Democrats. They've never--ever--been good on immigration, we'll never get anywhere better until we confront and own this history.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I was reminded again today that most state judges simply don't comprehend the trauma that even a chance of imm. enforcement causes non-citizens.
If you don't already understand why my client lives in fear of being detained & exiled by ICE I'm just not sure how to explain it tbh
My client didn't appear bc he knew that he had a deportation order & that ICE would be waiting.
While I sincerely appreciate the court agreeing w/our request not to impose bail after removing the default, I can't agree that this decision was merely "putting his head in the sand"
Thanks to the Trump administration's twisted anti-federalism, states which share information w/ICE and allow them into courthouses are voluntarily giving up on prosecuting a substantial number of non-citizens. Yet they continue to defend all of this in the name of "public safety"
Former DHS Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen has scored plenty of paid speeches and consulting gigs since her tenure, and is now enjoying a comfy sinecure on the National Infrastructure Advisory Council
Former Nielsen lieutenant Miles Taylor shepherded the policy through & actively worked to help her lie about it.
He's never taken any responsibility for this, and was defending the intentional orphaning of asylum-seeking kids #onhere as recently as this week.
friends, pls let me be the first to tell you: 2020 is no longer the worst year of our lives
It is possible that whenever this is all over that no one person will ever have had more direct influence on U.S. immigration policy in our history to date, all of it awful.
#StephenMiller is, I assume, the only White House official ever to work directly with Marvel to get that archvillain dialogue just right
The 1 person on Earth most responsible for the spread of #COVID19, the deaths of 207K+ Americans, & the immiseration of millions more is experiencing the painful reality of this virus &--for once--the consequences of his choices.
This is good. This is right.
It's ok to say it.
Months hampering relief efforts, botching testing/tracing, politicizing help to blue states, mocking science, using DOJ to challenge lockdowns/mask orders, watching asylum seekers die in ICE custody, ridiculing mask-wearers--and he doesn't deserve this? In what moral universe?
"...because the virus had hit blue states hardest, a national plan was unnecessary and would not make sense politically."
This referendum is the point at which the world pretty much agrees that Turkey became a fully authoritarian regime. The EU condemned Erdogan. Trump went out of his way to personally congratulate him.
I mean, ofc I know why. I'm not actually asking why. I'm asking what we can learn from it, what it means for us as we feel the gentle slope toward American fascism get ever slipperier beneath us.
Knowing what happened next in Turkey might be instructive.
The referendum--barely noticed by Americans, AFAIK--was a classic authoritarian move, narrowly (51%!) approved by largely rural, religious Turkish voters suspicious of urban elites. Erdogan played hard to the most extreme right, all too familiar stuff
The very best view of the available evidence in the ICE sterilization story is that one rogue doctor w/a history of Medicare fraud routinely chose the most expensive option w/o obtaining informed consent from women in ICE custody.
This is what we used to call a "scandal"
2/ I know ppl have had the best intentions but IMO it's not helpful to go straight to talking about a Trump/Miller scheme or some kind of organized plot worthy of genocide charges in The Hague. At base, this was one greedy doc who knew no one would care. Don't prove him right!
3/ This is not a Trump thing. This could have, and indeed did, happen under Obama, GW Bush, or Clinton--all of whom presided over mass immigration detention--and there's nothing stopping it in a Biden administration. It is very important to me that you understand this.