Last night was an utter catastrophe for stopping GOP gerrymandering next year. GOP is poised to draw 4-5 times as many congressional districts as Dems, likely closer to the latter number. That's similar to the GOP's 5:1 advantage after 2010. AZ, MI, PA legislatures still uncalled
With GOP's radical 6-3 Supreme Court majority, the court could strike down ballot initiatives, state supreme court rulings, & possibly even governor vetoes that block GOP gerrymanders at its most extreme.
This would cement GOP minority rule across the country. 2022 may be awful
GOP in lawsuits ongoing in many states over voting rules argue that only the literal state legislature may set federal election laws, blocking ballot initiatives & state supreme courts. Independent commissions in AZ, CA, & MI may be struck down & worse dailykos.com/story/2020/10/…
2020s redistricting could be even worse than after 2010 depending on SCOTUS. If its 6-3 majority remains, GOP in Texas & more could gerrymander based on the much whiter adult citizen population instead of more diverse total population as has long been norm, turbocharging GOP maps
THIS. What little remains of American democracy is hanging on by a thread.
If Dems don't win the Senate by flipping both GA seats, Biden will likely be a failed president who can't appoint any judges, leading to GOP 2022 midterm backlash that entrenches GOP minority rule
I hate to be dismal, but we must realize that democracy just suffered a catastrophe. GOP minority rule legislatures are further entrenching minority rule with the support of SCOTUS.
We may eventually have no option left but Chile-style mass protests. I hope it won't come to that
AZ, MI, PA have independent commissions or Dem govs, so legislative control doesn't directly matter, but SCOTUS could overturn any restrictions on legislatures' control over maps
We're tracking results of elections that decide control over redistricting in key states here. GOP has gained control over NH, gutted MO's legislative redistricting reform, & VA passed reform to block Dem gerrymanders. Dems have yet to flip a lege chamber docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d…
THIS. If you want something to be cheerful about today, Senate is not yet decided & Trump may lose.
Georgia will have at least 1 runoff if not 2, & Dems around the country can organize for a Jan. 5 runoff that could decide fate of Senate. Warnock & Ossoff
Michigan has gone basically a full decade under GOP minority rule after 2010's GOP wave. Thanks to the GOP dominating Dems across the country, this is a story that will happen again & again in many states in the coming decade.
GOP minority rule has often become self-entrenching
NEW: The 2020 elections were a disaster for a decade of redistricting, further securing GOP minority rule.
GOP is tentatively on track to draw 4-5 times as many congressional districts as Dems, while SCOTUS threatens to remove checks on GOP legislatures dailykos.com/story/2020/11/…
I looked at each individual one of the key states where partisan control was at stake & explained how 2020s redistricting could turn out following Tuesday & anticipating future Supreme Court rulings, which I'll explore in depth in a second follow up piece.
After 2010, the GOP drew 5 times as many congressional districts as Dems, a majority vs. Dems' 10%.
2020 is poised to be similar with the GOP drawing 4-5 out of 10 districts nationally. GOP gerrymandering WITHIN states may also become even more extreme than 2010 thanks to SCOTUS
Puerto Rico appears to have voted 52-48 for statehood with a large majority of votes already counted.
Unlike in past referenda, there does not appear to have been any significant boycott like 2017 or undervote compared to the governor's race like in 2012 nytimes.com/live/2020/11/0…
D.C. voted heavily for statehood in 2016. If Dems somehow pull off upsets to win both expected Georgia Senate runoffs in Jan. 5, admitting D.C. & Puerto Rico as states is key for protecting our democracy & majority rule.
The Senate has a huge bias against Dems & people of color.
One crucial casualty on Tuesday was any realistic hope of passing the National Popular Vote Compact by 2024. It could've been close to passage had Dems done well in 2020, but no more with the GOP set to dominate redistricting & 2022 unlikely to be a pro-Dem midterm under Biden
Dems seem to have gotten very lucky that Trump didn't again win Electoral College despite Biden winning the popular vote by what could end up being 3% or more nationally.
The risk of an Electoral College misfire isn't going away, & it won't always favor GOP as TX etc. trend blue
I'm proud to have opposed the Electoral College & since I was a teenager, even in this 2014 essay after it had favored Dems in 3 straight elections. The Electoral College is an affront to democracy & a ticking time bomb in the event of a contested election newrepublic.com/article/120635…
1. We're going to call it a night soon, but here's a thread on where things stand:
Biden may still win the Electoral College, but Dems are on track to not take the Senate despite getting more votes nationally just like the last several cycles.
GOP minority rule is our reality
2. Redistricting seems nothing short of a bloodbath for Dems. Dems aren't poised to make inroads against the GOP's current large advantage, & with the GOP's 6-3 SCOTUS majority likely soon to overrule Dem state supreme courts, it may be 2010 all over again
3. Joe Biden could be elected president, but without the Senate, there's a massive risk that he becomes a failed president unable to appoint any judges or enact any progressive policies. This is because of what would likely be a minority rule GOP Senate.
Intentional sabotage by the Trump administration. Election mail is just a tiny fraction of the Postal Service’s day-to-day mail volume & it alone wouldn’t be cause for delays
Trump is sabotaging mail delivery service in an attempt to invalidate largely Dem ballots. We've seemingly avoided the worst Election Day problems, but it isn't over yet
I don't put much emphasis on predicting elections like I did years ago given the importance of voting rights & institutional reform, but here are my guesses for 2020.
Barring SCOTUS interference, Biden wins & Dems get a narrow Senate majority & expand their House majority to 250
270 to win cut off the titles, so the first map is Electoral College, second is Senate, third is governors, fourth is House
I haven't been following individual races as closely as I'd like, but I would bet that Dems flip the following state legislative chambers:
AZ both
MI House
MN Senate
TX House
And Dems winning more support but GOP wins gerrymandered majorities in
GA
NC
PA
WI