[Thread] Bad news for fair elections in Illinois. GOP could now win a state Supreme Court majority in 2022 & use it to impose unfair redistricting maps under guise of "nonpartisanship." GOP could then win legislative majorities even if Dems win more votes by roughly 10% overall!
Illinois' Supreme Court has a 4-3 Dem majority, but federal courts have never held that "one person, one vote" applies to judicial redistricting, & the districts are badly malapportioned after 5 decades. Dem-leaning District 2 has 2x as many people as GOP-leaning Districts 4 & 5
Now that a Dem incumbent lost retention election in District 3, it'll have a partisan 2022 election in a seat that Trump won in 2016. GOP could flip it to gain control of court if Dems don't win partisan election for District 2, where a GOP incumbent will face voters for 1st time
Without extreme malapportionment in Illinois' Supreme Court districts, District 3 could've backed Clinton by several points in 2016 & Biden this year, which would make it much easier for Dems to win the pivotal 2022 election for this seat. Dems can & should redraw the districts
IL is a rare state where white-flight racial segregation creates a big geography penalty against Dems without their gerrymanders, which merely negate it. Dems could win popular vote by 10% yet fail to win majority of districts under this hypothetical nonpartisan congressional map
If GOP flips Illinois' Supreme Court, they could strike down Dems' congressional/legislative maps to impose "nonpartisan" maps like this that are functionally no different than GOP gerrymanders in terms of popular vote/seat disparities. This would be a disaster for fair elections
Of course it isn't ideal that Illinois has Dem gerrymanders, but the alternative of "nonpartisan" maps that let GOP win power with a 10% popular vote loss is worse.
IL needs reforms like proportional representation that don't penalize the party supported by Black/Latino voters
Illinois' current Dem gerrymanders only negate the geography penalty against them, & GOP Gov. Bruce Rauner won 58% of state House districts when he won by 4% in 2014. Mean-median test shows no Dem edge. This point seems unbelievable to GOP but it's true docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
We are caught in the two-party doom loop where Dems can either escalate or continue to abide by norms after initial GOP violations, but either response will just see the GOP keep escalating because they’re either retaliating or getting away with violations. We have to break free
Ending the two-party system's zero-sum game would likely help tremendously with this, & we could do it by adopting proportional representation along with ending winner-take-all elections & gerrymandering. Protecting voting rights is another key element
See @leedrutman's book on how we're stuck in the two-party doom loop & how institutional reforms could help us break free. But the million dollar question of course is how to overcome the collective action problem of getting there, & I have no easy answers global.oup.com/academic/produ…
And of course 4 million American citizens, who would count as 8 million people in this Senate representation exercise (since every person gets 2 senators), have no Senate representation whatsoever despite both D.C. in 2016 & Puerto Rico last Tuesday having voted for statehood
No exaggeration to say that Dems winning the Jan. 5 Georgia Senate runoffs is the single most important unknown shaping the next decade of U.S. politics. GOP will dominate 2020s redistricting, run SCOTUS, & block all Biden judges. A Dem Senate could curb all of those outcomes
Fundraising isn't the only thing that will help Dems win Georgia's Jan. 5 Senate runoffs. Voters who haven't yet registered may do so here, including those who are currently 17-years-old but turn 18 by Jan. 5
GOP is poised to dominate redistricting, but a Dem Senate could fight back by passing a law to ban congressional gerrymandering nationally. That would likely also require killing the filibuster & reforming SCOTUS. Possible but hard dailykos.com/stories/2020/1…
NEW: The 2020 elections were a disaster for a decade of redistricting, further securing GOP minority rule.
GOP is tentatively on track to draw 4-5 times as many congressional districts as Dems, while SCOTUS threatens to remove checks on GOP legislatures dailykos.com/story/2020/11/…
After 2010, the GOP drew 5 times as many congressional districts as Dems, a majority vs. Dems' 10%.
2020 is poised to be similar with the GOP drawing 4-5 out of 10 districts nationally. GOP gerrymandering WITHIN states may also become even more extreme than 2010 thanks to SCOTUS
If Dems don't pull off upsets in the expected Jan. 5 runoffs for both GA Senate seats, GOP will control Senate, blocking House Dems from banning congressional gerrymandering nationally with #HR1 & taking the threat of SCOTUS expansion off the table.
Puerto Rico appears to have voted 52-48 for statehood with a large majority of votes already counted.
Unlike in past referenda, there does not appear to have been any significant boycott like 2017 or undervote compared to the governor's race like in 2012 nytimes.com/live/2020/11/0…
D.C. voted heavily for statehood in 2016. If Dems somehow pull off upsets to win both expected Georgia Senate runoffs in Jan. 5, admitting D.C. & Puerto Rico as states is key for protecting our democracy & majority rule.
The Senate has a huge bias against Dems & people of color.
One crucial casualty on Tuesday was any realistic hope of passing the National Popular Vote Compact by 2024. It could've been close to passage had Dems done well in 2020, but no more with the GOP set to dominate redistricting & 2022 unlikely to be a pro-Dem midterm under Biden
Dems seem to have gotten very lucky that Trump didn't again win Electoral College despite Biden winning the popular vote by what could end up being 3% or more nationally.
The risk of an Electoral College misfire isn't going away, & it won't always favor GOP as TX etc. trend blue
I'm proud to have opposed the Electoral College & since I was a teenager, even in this 2014 essay after it had favored Dems in 3 straight elections. The Electoral College is an affront to democracy & a ticking time bomb in the event of a contested election newrepublic.com/article/120635…