We reject Mr Maugham’s assertions about us which are unfounded and bizarre. #LGBAlliance is entirely funded by individual donations; we are a group of LGB people. His assertions remind us of the wild conspiracy theories people used to invent decades ago about gay people./1of2
Then we were all spies and linked to a Communist global threat. Now apparently we’re linked to the far right. We’re neither. We’re a bunch of ordinary LGB people standing up for our rights./2of2
To those who are urging us to sue: We believe that in making these defamatory remarks Mr Maugham is deliberately trying to provoke us into deploying our limited financial and time resources to rebut his claims.
We consider this would be a waste of our funding, which is sourced in an entirely legitimate way from individual donations. We are content to let Mr Maugham continue to make a spectacle of himself throwing around false and unfounded allegations in hyperbolic terms.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Welcome to #lgballiance, the home of people who know that lesbians are women who love other women, and gay men are men who love other men. On the basis of #SexNotGender. We are here to defend the rights of LGB people. This is a personal struggle for us.
It is personal because of the constant messages we receive asking for our help. Lesbians who write in confusion, having been excluded from LGBTQ+ spaces for being “transphobic”. Gay men who write in sadness that their men-only events are being attacked as “transphobic”.
Messages from teachers, psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers, politicians, NHS staff, civil servants, and from all walks of life saying they don’t dare to express their opinion about gender identity for fear of losing their job for supposedly being “transphobic”.
Here are some additional facts about the medicalisation of "gender non-conforming" children. Puberty blockers can be prescribed once a child reaches Tanner Stage 2. This is the first stage of puberty; usually age 9-11 in girls and age 11 in boys. 1/7 bbc.co.uk/news/health-55…
The youngest child GIDS has treated with hormone blockers to date was 8 years & 9 months old. Puberty provides a window of development which, if missed, cannot be regained at a later stage. The NHS website asserts: “Little is known about long-term side effects of hormone or 2/7
puberty blockers in children with gender dysphoria". Although Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) advises this is a physically reversible treatment if stopped, it isn't known what psychological effects may be. It’s also not known whether hormone blockers affect the 3/7
LGB Alliance believes the motion that has been tabled at Holyrood to mark Transgender Day of Remembrance tomorrow is full of misrepresentations. @TwisterFilm has pointed out some of the errors and exaggerations in the motion. #FactsMatter /1of12
URGENT. Please email your MSP today. The Scottish Parliament will be asked tomorrow to mark Transgender Day of Remembrance. But the motion shouldn't be passed because it's full of wild exaggerations and downright mistakes. You can read it here👇 bb.parliament.scot/Motions/Detail…/2of12
While it is true that 350 trans people have been killed worldwide in the last year not one of those was murdered in Scotland. In the UK there are currently more convicted killers who identify as trans than there have been trans people killed ....in the last decade./3of12
We look on with grave concern at the attempts to shut down liberal values such a free expression. It's a concern to us that the reputation of an important news outlet such as The Guardian has been diminished.
That it has become controversial to defend our rights in law that are predicated on the reality of biological sex only strengthens our resolve.
We believe that current ideas of gender identity are pseudoscientific and present a risk to people who are same-sex attracted.
2
We believe that there is a need to have a legitimate, respectful, and open discussion about our concerns.
This means that we all have to listen to each other and to expose ourselves to ideas and views that we don't agree with, and that may even make us feel uncomfortable.
Ten years after the passing of the UK Equality Act, it’s time to take stock. Key issues include emphasising the protected characteristics of sex and sexual orientation and the rules on sex-protected spaces. There’s a pressing need for clear guidance./1of4
In particular we need to examine how the Equality Act works in today’s world, in which the broad category of “gender reassignment” instead of the small group of 5,000 people in the UK (in 2004) is now being applied to 100 times as many people: half a million./2of4
This “trans umbrella” covers at least 17 different kinds of people (according to Stonewall), who have little if anything in common. @MForstater reviews what’s happened over the years. We need #ClarityOnSexAndGender./3of4
We oppose the “affirmative” approach to gender dysphoria. Our detractors suggest, offensively and quite ludicrously, that this reflects an uncaring attitude to those concerned. This important article suggests the opposite./1of6 quillette.com/2020/11/01/jac…
“Advocates of ‘affirmative care’ naturally downplay the risks arising from inappropriate transitions. (Turban himself has described them as largely ‘cosmetic.’ Yet we are seeing increasing numbers of patients who feel deeply traumatized by inappropriate transitions.”/2of6
“They suffer from irreversible physical changes, including alterations to their genitals and sexual function, sterility, painful vaginal atrophy, chest/breast alteration and scarring, deepening of the voice”,/3of6