Meet @AppSame, a Conservative SuperPAC with 338418 followers, most of whom don't seem to be interested in retweeting its tweets. Since it attacks the legitimacy of other people's followers, its own follower growth is surely beyond reproach, right?
Although @AppSame's last ~50K accounts look largely organic, the story is quite different early on, with lengthy streaks where it was followed by thousands or tens of thousands of accounts with zero likes or which follow more than 50 times as many accounts as they have followers.
200448 of @AppSame's 338418 followers (59.2%) followed it during these periods of inorganic growth. Helpfully, @AppSame was running a follower-tracking app back in its early days, confirming that it repeatedly gained tens of thousands of followers in a single day.
Unlike @AppSame's recent followers, which are mostly English-language #MAGA accounts, slightly over half (50.1%) of the followers @AppSame gained during spurts of inorganic growth have a primary language other than English, most frequently Russian or Spanish.
Footnote: we've seen many of @AppSame's bogus followers before. Here are threads documenting the networks they belong to:
Earlier tonight, a Twitter account named @Fauci sent out a tweet impersonating Dr. Anthony Fauci and was quickly suspended. We did some research on it before the ban, and decided to present our findings as a tutorial of sorts on detecting impostor accounts.
First off, the (subsequently suspended) @Fauci account sent what it claimed was its first tweet in December 2020, despite being created in 2009. It's also potentially odd that Fauci would retweet the Biden transition team while still working for the Trump administration.
Secondly, we looked at old tweets tagging @Fauci, and most of them don't appear to have much to do with virology or any other medical topic. Some are in Indonesian, which as far as we have been able to discern, the real Dr. Fauci does not speak.
We've done a few analyses lately of anomalies lurking in the followers of various large #MAGA accounts. Here's a thread linking all of them. First up: the account presently known as @Wizard_Predicts (although it's had at least a dozen other names thus far).
Next we have @ColumbiaBugle, recently retweeted by Trump. It began its existence with an infusion of empty accounts that seem to have been created exclusively to follow @ColumbiaBugle.
We found multiple anomalies in @SidneyPowell1's followers, one of which (a recent infusion of Japanese accounts) also turns up in the followers of fellow #Kraken tentacles @LLinWood and @RudyGiuliani.
The identical tweets were posted by a newly-created botnet, consisting of 10 accounts created over the span of 10 minutes on December 9th, 2020. All 10 accounts have female profile pics, and none has ever liked a tweet or followed another account.
As is often the case with spammy botnets, the profile pics are stolen, generally from stock photo sites. We found Google reverse image search effective for tracking them down (although we didn't try any other search site, as we didn't need to with this group).
We took a look at the other followers of some of the Arabic accounts followed by the now-suspended fake Sidney Powell account @SidneyPowell_, and found a portion of a bulk follow botnet following @aL7ijaaz. #TuesdayThoughts
To find the rest of the network (or at least most of it), we recursively explored the followers of large accounts followed by the bots we'd already found. Many of the accounts the botnet follows appear to have almost no real followers whatsoever.
We found a total of 522180 accounts that we believe are part of this fake engagement network. All were created in batches between July 2013 and March 2014, frequently exceeding thousands of accounts per day. They have repetitive naming schemes, and none has ever liked a tweet.
Unsurprisingly, they're part of a botnet, consisting of (at least) 19 accounts that use custom apps with names of the form "Twitter for HUAWEI<xxxx>", and occasionally "Twitter for Android6" (not the real Twitter Android phone app). Most were created in June or October 2020.
The bots in this network do two things: retweet and reply. In both cases, the accounts they interact with are accounts selling access to proxy servers and botting software.
Here's an interesting duo: @POLICEFORTRUMPI and @SidneyPowell_ (not the real Sidney Powell). Both were created in Apr 2016 but silent until Dec 2020, both are demanding RETWEETS and FOLLOWS, and both started out by following large Arabic-language accounts.
The RETWEETS and FOLLOWS verbiage on this pair of accounts is reminiscent of this recently-suspended network of fake #MAGA accounts, so they may be the same operation, but we don't have enough information to be 100% sure on that yet.
Yet another similar looking fake #MAGA account (@atensnut__, impersonating @atensnut) has emerged and is begging for RETWEETS and FOLLOWS. (Despite the claims of the impostor, the real @atensnut is still active and still has a full complement of followers.)