Nathan Ruser Profile picture
14 Dec, 14 tweets, 8 min read
It's interesting that 🙈-turned-propagandist Jerry here brings up Tongxin, Ningxia (by showing two sites more than 4km apart, both have been significantly damaged). In this thread I'll show through 16 different mosques in XJ how they've been systematically decimated.
First, I want to highlight one particularly nasty bit of disinformation in Jerry's original tweet. In the first picture (which he says is taken in 2019), he has blocked where the mosque's domes originally were with foliage. In reality they were demolished and removed in Oct 2019.
The minarets were removed between June and October 2020. Beyond the domes and the minarets, all the arabic script that was previously on the mosque in 2014 has been removed and replaced with Chinese writing.
Now let's look at 16 mosques more generally in Tongxin, a city that Jerry uses as an exemplar to prove 'religious freedom'. The first one here had its dome removed in 2019 and was entirely demolished between June 2020 and October 2020.
Here's four more, 3rd one hasn't had its domes removed yet, but it's following suit of every other one.
Another four, in the 3rd photo here, even the domes on a neighbouring apartment building were removed.
Final four, in this city for now.
I should note, that these aren't only damaged mosques. These are all the mosques. The only mosque I could find that wasn't damaged was the touristy "great mosque" (同心清真大寺) without a single smidge of Islamic architecture.
SORRY BIG YIKES I just realised out of habit I wrote "XJ" in the top post, the mosques in this thread are ALL in Tongxin, Ningxia. A town that Jerry claims is a good example of China's religious freedom.
It's not just the mosques, but any Islamic style architecture. This is a shopping precint in the town. It used to be adorned with Islamic domes, now they've all been removed.
.@Jerry_grey2002, you asked if anyone "want[ed] to challenge me on Chinese religious freedom".
Do you have any comments on all these 'rectified' and deislamified Mosques?
If not, I have a question. How many mosques need to be damaged before it affects religious freedom?
ALL these examples of destroyed and damaged mosques are from ONE town in Ningxia, the one town that Jerry highlighted to show 'religious freedom'.
All in all 94% of the mosques I found in that town had been damaged or destroyed. All in the last year.
I'm curious whether Jerry can read Chinese, he claims the two mosques he showed at the same, but theyre more than 4km apart and all it took to figure that out is looking at the picture and searching "汇百 宁夏". I wouldnt claim to be able to read Chinese but even I could do that.
One quick clarification I should make in regards to the Arabic lettering being removed, this shows where it was in comparison with the photograph from 2019, where it and the structure's domes have been removed (minarets were removed in 2020).

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Nathan Ruser

Nathan Ruser Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Nrg8000

14 Dec
Reporters from the BBC visited a detention facility in Xinjiang's Kuqa that opened in mid-2017. In May 2019, a 35,000m2 factory opened directly adjacent to the camp. Less than a week after it was completed, satellite imagery caught ~1,500 people being moved to the factory. ImageImage
The line stretches 200m between the camp and the factory, called Kuqa Pomegranite Seed Industry Co (库车石榴籽实业有限公司), and with a rough density analysis you can estimate the crowd at around 1,500 individuals. Moving DIRECTLY from a camp to a factory. ImageImage
During the week between when the factory was completed and when a mass transfer of detainees was captured by satellite imagery the detention facility itself was significantly desecuritised. Watchtowers were removed, internal fencing was lowered and concrete walls were removed. ImageImage
Read 15 tweets
13 Dec
We have shown, thrown exhausting satellite evidence, that roughly 66% of mosques in Xinjiang have been destroyed or damaged, mostly since 2017. Visitors to Xinjiang since then have estimated to me that about 75% of the ones that do remain are closed.
Some of the photos I've seen showing the inside of closed mosques show an unbelievable amount of decrepitation. Sacred would be the last word to describe how they're treated with what Chinese authorities have done to these mosques
The entire city of Hotan, according to recent visitors, has two mosques that remain operational to any degree. That's a city of over 300,000 people. Fewer mosques than the city of Canberra, with a similar population but only 0.6% Muslim vs >95% of Hotan being Islamic.
Read 4 tweets
10 Dec
This thread will quickly show, step-by-step how to use GIS to plan protest escape routes, using the example of the last hour's confrontation in Bangkok. With some of the legwork already done (can be done at a city scale), this took 10min to adjust and process.
Essentially, this boils down to using the notion of assigning a cost to transversing each pixel, and letting computers work out what the most efficient routes are. Here's an example of that concept being used for Lord of the Rings. esri.com/arcgis-blog/pr…
In Bangkok, and pretty much every other major city in the world, we can cut out the tricky modelling of how difficult each part of a map is to walk through by turning to @Strava's heatmap, which shows approximately that, easier paths are travelled more.
Read 24 tweets
9 Dec
This map shows the proximety and rough trajectory of Iceberg #A68A towards South Georgia Island. Red shows water that's shallow enough for the iceberg to likely beach itself. Its position on Dec 3rd and 9th is shown, so's a basic idea of its course (based on 3rd-9th movement).
Right now it's less than 14km from the closest area it could run aground.
AFAIK the effects of such a large iceberg beaching hasn't been recorded this far North, but in Antartica itself, they have abosultely decimated penguin colonies in the past, with species more adapted to the cold.
S Georgia has 1mil pairs of penguins, and ~30mil pairs of seabirds.
Read 4 tweets
22 Nov
New satellite imagery published by @ndtv, conclusively proves that a new village constructed by China and revealed in Chinese state media is indeed located within over 2 kilometres into Bhutan, according to their official maps and claims (27.307, 89.007).
ndtv.com/india-news/exc…
The high resolution imagery also shows how percarious of a village it is, being constructed on what is essentially a sandbank in the middle of a mountain river valley (where snowmelt and high cliffs make water flow unpredictable and flash floods common)...
In that annotated imagery above, the pink outline shows areas of fallen trees, very possibly where the river has flooded and knocked them over. You can even see tree trunks in blue. Now the other side of those floods would be the village.
Read 4 tweets
21 Nov
Outrage over the crackdown in Hong Kong 👎
Outrage over the crackdown in Xinjiang 👎
Outrage over totalitarianism in Vietnam 👎
Outrage over human rights abuses in Cambodia 👎
Outrage over a white woman cooking dumplings 👍🥳👍
To add some more nuance that didnt fit,
Of course it's valid to have perspectives on local culture issues, and I agree that this is sketchy, but it's been taken to the point where the shop owner has been evicted and lost their livelihood in the middle of a pandemic.
There's a big difference between posting food-takes on twitter/not shopping at a resturant you find problematic and actually ruining someone's life over the fact that they cooked dumplings. I don't eat at a similar resturant near my house because I actually agree with her.
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!