1./ Who regulates our broadcasters, @Ofcom or @stonewalluk? It's an obvious question after the car-crash yesterday at the @CommonsDCMS hearing when Ofcom's head said she agreed with this tendentious nonsense from @MrJohnNicolson 👇
2./ Pink News who are to free speech what Bennie Hill was to subtle humour celebrated, arguing @Ofcom had set out rules preventing anyone being interviewed whom Pink News decides is an "anti-trans activist"; ie anyone who's not a wide-eyed enthusiast for the latest trans demand.
3./ What is "extremely inappropriate" is a regulator deciding who should speak on issues such as women's sport, puberty blockers or single sex spaces and being guided by the opinion of a lobby group called @stonewalluk who take positions counter to the public on all these issues.
4./ @Broadcastnow tried to make sense of something many TV colleagues have told me they consider an outrage. They suggested @Ofcom was going to "enter talks with Stonewall". But that's not what Ofcom said. They said they were ALREADY talking to them. Of course they were.👇
5./ Ofcom are just one of many institutions from schools and police forces to NHS boards and even the House of Commons who sign up for Stonewall re-education, competing to please the panjandrums of Britain's most successful protection racket. 👇parliament.uk/mps-lords-and-…
6./ They know if they keep on the right side of Stonewall they can slowly climb up a ladder towards a gold medal as a Diversity Champion. None have seemed to clock this means they've delegated policy to a lobby group with a narrow niche agenda. stonewall.org.uk/diversity-cham…
7./ Stonewall's presence inside institutions like Ofcom, its brainwashing of HR depts, & its recommended LGBTQ staff groups who seem to function like its eyes and ears mean employees become become inured to its ideology until it becomes a reflex.stonewall.org.uk/setting-up-an-…
8./ But all is not lost. Not long after Nicolson's slanderous tirade about @ALLIANCELGB the Tory MP @DamianGreen begged to differ.. pointing out that if Ofcom enforced Nicolson's approach a feminist like @jk_rowling would be banned from TV debates.👇
9./ It's painful for old lefties like me to admit it's Conservatives who now talk the most sense on issues of free speech but it's not our fault (or Mr Green's) that much of the Left has gone mad. Suffice to say @dawes_melanie rushed to assure him JK was not persona non grata. 👇
10./ But can that position hold? @dawes_melanie claimed she just wanted to stop offence being caused. Err...but even the redoubtable and wonderful JK is accused of causing offence by, for example @Mermaids_Gender. Here they are saying she was "condescending and inaccurate".
11./ Rich coming from them. They also wrote an open letter saying JK's blog was "difficult for many trans people and their families to read". @MunroeBergdorf opined "She is not a supporter of our community. This is not her fight". Will Ofcom be consulting Munroe on who can speak?
12./ What does this prove? Nicolson (with his tin ear) has unwittingly shone a light on the influence of a lobby group on regulators. And @dawes_melanie has had a crash course on the inadvisability of dictating to journalists who they can speak to. Over to you Dame Melanie.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1./ On Jolyon Maugham and his underhand tactics. Here's Jolyon complaining that an expert cited by the prosecution in the Tavistock trial is a.... veterinary scientist who did work on sheep. To self-styled genius Jolyon this appears to be an outrage. It isn't. And here's why.
2./ How would YOU test puberty blockers? Now that they're in widespread use Jolyon's side argue it would be unethical to run a trial where a control group of gender dysphoric kids are NOT given PBs. So why not run an animal trial? That's exactly what Professor Neil Evans did.
3./ His team at Glasgow University worked with researchers from Norway's leading Gender Identity clinic. Jolyon didn't mention them. But anyway how CAN animals help us work out the impact of puberty blockers? Simple: all mammals go through adolescence. Yep even sheep.
1./ Who knew the BBC now needs defending from a regulator that admits to working hand in glove with a controversial lobby group which famously enforces its own narrow, biased agenda on some of the big issues of the day. Yes @stonewalluk
2./ Stonewall is wrong on single sex spaces, its advice on Self ID has been rejected by the UK govt, its policy on puberty blockers was rejected by the High Court. Sporting bodies reject its attitude to women’s sports. It conspires against the rights of gay people.
3./ And yet secretly it is working with @Ofcom day to day to help them decide who gets to debate these issues and many more. This is a disgrace. Forget defund the BBC. It’s Ofcom that needs wholesale reform. 👇👇
1./ Just how dumb are some LGBTQ+ activists? I ask since there's yet another petition against @ALLIANCELGB. Surprise, surprise the usual sheeple gay glitteratti have signed it. Even Cashman has taken a break from promoting his tedious book to pontificate.
2./ This one demands the 'UK Media' should never interview anyone from LGB Alliance unless there's a warning (and maybe a skull and crossbones flag in the corner). At least we've given them a break from remedial classes in those skills they never mastered, like tying shoelaces.👇
3./ We shouldn't mock. These are people so dumb they really do believe Sam Smith is brave for growing moobs. And luminously boundary breaking for wearing some eyeshadow. Wow, "they're" so very totally non-binary.👇
1./ On #HumanRights day we should remember Patrick Zaky #PatrickZaky the Egyptian rights campaigner who was arrested and tortured when he went back for a holiday to Egypt from Italy in Feb 2020. He's still in prison. huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/egyptian…
2./ Patrick was studying for a masters in "LGBT and gender studies" in Bologna. While there he bravely spoke out about Egypt's failure to prosecute the men who tortured and brutally murdered an Italian doctoral student called Guilio Regeni in 2016 theguardian.com/world/2020/feb…
3./ Today -appropriately- the Italian authorities charged 4 members of Egypt's national security agency with Guilio's murder. Guilio was researching labour unions. An estimated 2,723 people have been 'forcibly disappeared' in Egypt since 2015. theguardian.com/world/2020/dec…
1./ Puberty blockers. Yesterday's High Court judgement says "children must fully understand their impact". But can kids really do that when they're being exposed to an onslaught of online promotion which presents Blockers as an almost magical "cure"? theguardian.com/world/2020/dec…
2./ More than 50% of those treated with PB at the Tavistock were under 16. Brave, young Kiera Bell's evidence said that from 14 she was exposed to videos encouraging her to medically change her body. Let's explore just some of that online propaganda👇judiciary.uk/wp-content/upl…
3./ In this video from @mygenderation a 14 year old celebrates P Blockers saying "everything feels so much better now" and "you can carry on as yourself" but "don't have to go through all the things that biological females have to". Oh and there's some fun skateboarding👇
1./ Online conspiracy theories are the bane of our era. Yet this weekend a significant section of the membership of @theSNP abandoned themselves with gusto to a truly insane fantasy. Hold on to your tin foil hat as I try to make some sense of it. It started with this👇
2./ On Friday night someone alerted me to this strange tweet. John and I haven't spoken since we went for a fabulously boozy dinner at a mutual friend's in Camden 3 years ago. 4 of us (including the wonderful Juliano) argued intemperately into the wee hours. John CAN be fun.
3./ Everytime I call out some idiocy of his I restrain myself, and try to remember his lovely mum who was a treasure. And my own mum's advice: judge people by their partners. By that measure he cannot be all bad. But John really has made a plonker of himself this time