Carl Zha Profile picture
25 Dec, 15 tweets, 5 min read
.@TheWarNerd asked me if famous Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai was really born in Suyab, Kyrgyzstan. I thought I had an easy answer. Then I quickly went down the rabbit hole of explaining near impossible tale of how China’s most famous poet born in the heart of Central Asia. A thread
Turns out Li Bai’s family background shrouded in mystery. We only have brief accounts frm Li Bai himself and his close family and friends. All suggest Li Bai family moved to Sichuan from Central Asia in 705 AD before he was 5 yr old and he descends frm Royal house of Xi Liang西凉
Primary source on Li Bai family background: his writing, his Uncle’s memoir and his Tomb inscription. But details scant on how his family ended up settling in Central Asia. Famous scholar Chen Yinke 陈寅恪 thinks Li is non-Chinese origin.

Kyrgyzstan stamp commemorating Li Bai
In 草堂集序 the intro to Li Bai’s work, Li’s Clan Uncle 李陽冰 wrote: 李白字太白,隴西成紀人。涼武昭王暠九世孫,蟬聯珪組,世為顯著,中葉非罪,謫居條支,易姓與名。然自窮蟬至舜,五世為庶,累世不大曜,亦可歎焉。神龍之始,逃歸於蜀。

Li Bai is 9th gen descendant of King of Xi Liang..
“At some point, Li ancestor because of unspecified transgression had to move to Central Asia, change their original surname Li, living as commoner for 5 generations and only fled back to Sichuan in 705AD.”

條支: an old Chinese name for Persia and is generic term for Central Asia
李陽冰 is Li Bai’s Clan Uncle to whom Li Bai relied on for financial assistance in the last days of his life. His writing is also oldest source on Li Bai family other than Li Bai’s own writing. It established exact time when Li Bai family moved frm Central Asia to Sichuan
Li Bai tomb inscription 贈左拾遺翰林學士李公新墓碑 by old family friend added more detail: 凉武昭王九代孫也。隋末多難,一房被竄於碎葉,流離散落,隱易姓名。
9th gen descendant of Xi Liang King. Family took refuge in Suyab (Central Asia). Changed surnames from Li to something else
故自國朝已來,漏於屬籍。神龍初,潛還廣漢。因僑爲郡人。父客,以逋其邑,遂以客爲名
Further adds Li Bai family went to Central Asia to escape chaos of fall of Sui Dynasty. 100 yr later returned and re-adopt Li surname. Li Bai’s Dad name himself 客because he is a guest in Sichuan.
In other words, Li Bai’s Dad didn’t have a Chinese name before they migrated from Central Asia to Sichuan. Nor did they use the surname Li while living in Central Asia
Li Bai himself asserted his descent from Royal Li Clan of Xi Liang (400-421AD purple below ) in his own writings: 本家隴西人,先爲漢邊將 and 白本家金陵,世為右姓。遭沮渠蒙遜之難,奔流鹹秦,因官寓家。少長江漢

If we take this claim at face value, then Li Bai related to Tang rulers
But Tang Dynasty rulers nvr acknowledged kinship w Li Bai family. We also know Tang founder claim to descend frm Royal Li Clan of Longxi is in fact bogus because main branch of Longxi Li Clan nvr acknowledged kinship w Tang ancestors before they made it big.
It was fashionable to claim kinship w Imperial Li Clan of Tang. As Kyrgyz destroyed Uighur Khaganate in Mongolia in 840 AD, Kyrgyz Khagan claim to descend from General Li Ling captured by Xiongnu in 1st cen BC, thereby related to Imperial Li Clan of Tang. Tang Emperor accepted!
There are some potential problem with Li Bai family claim. When their family fled to Suyab, it was still the heartland of Western Turkic Khaganate. Why would Li Bai family flee frm civil war of Sui dynasty collapse all the way to Imperial court of Western Turks?!!!
What we do know from 唐左拾遺翰林學士李公新墓碑並序 Li Bai’s tomb inscription is that when Li Bai met Tang Emperor, his talent included read/write foreign language 草答蕃書,辯如懸河,筆不停綴. Li Bai grew up in Sichuan but prbly picked up from his Central Asian immigrant family
Li Bai also named 1 of his son 李頗黎, 頗黎 is obviously Chinese transcription of Old Turkic name Bori (Wolf).

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Carl Zha

Carl Zha Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @CarlZha

23 Dec
True even for Mandarin dialects. Mandarin 官话 is a whole language family. What people usually refers to Mandarin in English is actually Standard Mandarin Putonghua 普通话

I grew up speaking Chongqing dialect 成渝话 of SW Mandarin 西南官话, lots Beijingers can’t understand it
For thousands of years, Chinese writing is in Classical Chinese which is based on 雅语 Classical Chinese spoken around time of Confucius (551–479 BC).

But anti-traditionalist May 4th movement in 1919 as response to Western predation on China prompted switch to use of colloquial
The vernacular language 白话文 advocated to replace Classical Chinese文言文 in writing is based on Standard Mandarin 國語/普通话 which was created frm Beijing dialect of Mandarin 北京官话.
Read 5 tweets
16 Dec
US politician and Western MSM started new round of campaign accusing China using millions of #Uyghur slaves to work on #Xinjiang cotton "plantations". Reports source none other than Adrian Zenz, originator of million Uyghurs in concentration camp story. A thread debunking Zenz
Adrian Zenz, @VoCommunism “researcher” came out w new report purportedly w evidence of #Uyghur slave labor used to produce cotton in #Xinjiang.

‘Evidence’ 1: because Uyghur majority region in Southern Xinjiang employ local labor!!!
Zenz claims China replacing Han migrant labor in #Xinjiang with local #Uyghur in order to meet its local poverty alleviation program MUST mean Uyghurs are slaves!!!
Read 8 tweets
15 Dec
Trying to name my kid, I looked up Zha family generation names. Chinese families traditionally use a character from a poem to denote each generation. Poem for 查 Zha Clan: 秉志允大继嗣克昌,奕世有人济美忠良,传家孝友华国文章,宗英绍起祖德载光
Great-Grandpa is 查济眉. 济is his generation name. 4 generation frm him is covered by phrase 济美忠良. I am 良generation 良字辈, same generation as martial arts novelist Jin Yong 金庸, full name 查良镛, who is my 族兄 Clan brother.
What I realized that Grandpa didn’t strictly follow the generation naming rule. His children are 忠generation 忠字辈. But he swapped char 忠 (loyalty) to homophone 中 (China) and put it last, so Dad and Uncles would’ve patriotic name like 建中(build China) etc
Read 5 tweets
13 Dec
As someone who actually grew up in China in 1980s, I can actually talked abt how commemoration of Nanjing Massacre changed inside China. I will make a thread
I was born in Oct 1976. 1 month after Mao died. I went to elementary school in China in 1982. my 1st to 4th grade was during honeymoon period btw Japan and China. We learn abt horrors of Hiroshima bombing and how Japan was a victim of US Imperialism
1985 was a pivotal year in Sino-Japanese relations. On the 40the year of Japanese surrender, Japanese PM Yasuhiro Nakasone visited Yasukuni shrine for the 1st time after WW2 Japanese war criminals had been enshrined there in 1978.
Read 13 tweets
13 Dec
Reminder that @ggreenwald wants a nuclear war with China👇🏼
People wants me to seriously respond to @ggreenwald’s ridiculous take. Of course US weapon manufacturers don’t really want a war w China! Their grift is to hype a China threat to justify spending on their weapons not actually destroying US Empire in 15 min in a real war
Read 6 tweets
12 Dec
We just came back from hospital w heavy heart. Shitake passed away last night. Susu (left) Big Mac (right front) and Mochi (right back) all have seizures and couldn’t stand or move. They’re now on sedatives and IV
*correction OP pictures was that of Mochi (left) and Big Mac (w Mochi in background). Susu not pictured
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!