On my new post. This is a massive ~7k words piece!
I write abt the 'Indus Valley' playbook. Indus Valley is tour desi startup ecosystem, and the Indus Valley playbook is the hacks, biz models & approaches needed to win in this unique ecosystem.
Indus Valley is guided + constrained by 5 forcing functions
- a small consuming class
- emergence of a 2-track consumer startup ecosystem
- presence of high-quality English-speaking tech workforce
- an underformalized enterprise space
- an over-indexed venture/startup ecosystem.
1+2) Much of spending thus far led by premium India1 consumers (~110m). India2 has another ~100m consumers but need distinct solutions given lower purchasing power.
Increasingly we are seeing the need for differentiated startup products to cater to these two markets.
If all of India's fluent english speakers were a country, it would be 4th largest english speaking country in the world, and would be rich enough to be an OECD member.
12/25
4) India has a (relatively) undersized formal economy.
Manish Sabharwal of Teamlease: Only 19.5k companies with paid up capital > 10crs. 63m enterprises (vs US 32m but US is 9x our GDP). Only 5% of non-ag establishments > 5 people.
Hinders venture-scale enterprise businesses.
5) Oversized venture funding ecosystem. We are higher than UK and Germany in funds deployed! At per capita incomes of $2k!
3 reasons.
14/25
What these forcing functions have done is to guide the development of distinct Indus Valley playbooks...let us go over some of them.
We will look at Indus Valley playbooks for etailing, edtech, short video apps, Bharat SaaS etc. There is more in the post though!
15/25
Etailing hasnt grown in India as we saw in China and U.S. (and they are at a base of $1200bn and $600bn respectively)
We saw etailing bump up from $27b in CY19 to $38b in CY20.
Why? Because we havent seen an expansion in online shoppers as this chart fm @RedSeer tells us.
16/25
How is Indus Valley coping with the lack of new user growth generally?
We are beginning to see waves of innovation in etailing to get India2 customers on board - from social commerce (@meeshoapp) to group buying (@DealShareIndia) to video commerce (@official_bulbul) and so on.
Meanwhile we are seeing curation + discovery led shopping to get India1 to buy D2C brands. Innovators here include @CRED_club@FromLBB etc.
18/25
Similar India1 v India2 or rather India1A v India1/2 distinct models emerging in edtech.
If B2B SAAS led the wave of build in India for the world, we will see consumertech plays pick up that mantle soon - led by edtech. We will see a wave of edtech players launching + scaling abroad.
20/25
And what about consumer brand plays then? How Indian avocado startups can leverage Indiranagar and Bandra market fit to expand to East Coast / West Coast.
Interesting to visualize India as the 51st state of the US for B2C much like Israel was the 51st state of US for B2B.
22/25
A speculation.
India1 audiences: monetized by ads
India2 audiences: in-app purchases, ecommerce and ads.
23/25
SaaSTra - SaaS + Transaction as a model for domestic SaaS plays.
24/25
Phew! Time to wrap here!
I have given you a smattering of the content + playbooks in my essay. Do read!
Would love for you to think aloud and debate with me. What are the playbooks I have missed? What does your Indus Valley Playbook look like!?
Psychological moonshots (as opposed to regular engineering-led moonshots).
Great Q fm Rory - are we in startupland predisposed to more expensive engineering moonshots?
How reframing a negative as a feature, basis our understanding of human psychology, helps. A faster ship would have been harder to pull off & would have still meant slower speed vs an airplane. Instead they focused on slowness and the romance of sea travel.
Worth noting that when Softbank acquired ARM in ‘16, both NVidia and ARM had similar market cap - in the early $30bns. Now Nvidia is at $300b and ARM is being acquired for $40b!
Nvidia has perhaps been amongst the biggest beneficiaries of rise of ML, self-driving cars, gaming where their GPUs have come in handy. As the need for compute power grew Nvidia found itself on the right side of ML tailwinds.
Whereas ARM, a virtual monopoly has languished.
2/7
Sure, there have been perhaps management issues at ARM etc. And the comparison isn't exactly like to like. But if there is a takeaway here, it is that riding tailwinds is perhaps far more important than having moats.
3/7
2/17
It is common to use IIT/IIM as a shorthand to refer to elite colleges in India. Sometimes IIT/IIM/BITS or IIT/NIT/IIMs and so on.
We lack a moniker like the U.S.'s Ivy or France's Grande Ecoles.
So I created one.
3/17
We can look at any top tier college in India, from the IITs to Xaviers / Ashoka, and you will see that they tick these 4 boxes – selectivity in intake, all India (national) intake, presence in a metro or residential nature, and English-fluency.