Market PE at 40 and yet the market is not falling, why? Getting asked this question multiple times. Here's a thread covering ‘very basic’ premier on valuation for my retail investor friends.

Do hit the ‘re-tweet’ and help us educate more investors (1/n)
For us to be able to comprehend the situation, we need to understand 4 very basic valuation matrixes
(1) Trailing EPS
(2) Forward EPS
(3) Trailing PE
(4) Forward PE


EPS = Profit After Tax / Number of outstanding Shares
PE = Market Price / EPS (2/n)
So what's a trailing EPS?

So in March 2020, RIL generated a Profit after tax (PAT) of 39,354 cr. The number of outstanding shares of RIL is some 676.21 cr. which means the 39,354 cr of PAT belongs to the 676.21 cr. shareholders, right? (3/n)
That also means that per share, RIL earned Rs. 58.20 (39,354/676.21). This 58.20 is called the trailing (TTM) EPS. Trailing means past, already done. (4/n)
So RIL earns 58.20 rupees per share but you pay 58.20 * 33.16 = 1930, 33.16 times more to buy 1 share from the market, that 33.16 is called the Price/Earnings (PE) ratio. This is again trailing as 58.20 EPS is trailing. (5/n)
33.16 PE may be looked at as taking 33.16 years to receive your investment back assuming the company keeps earning 58.20 each year (58.20 * 33.16 = 1930). But what if the company earns more than 58.20? (6/n)
So let's say, next year the company is expected to earn 20% more say 70 rupees (58.20 + 20%) per share as earning (EPS), then automatically, you start thinking that from next year's perspective the PE is cheaper. How? (7/n)
How? If next year's EPS (expected) is 70 per share and you are paying 1930 to buy the share, next year if 70 is actually the EPS (because earnings grew at 20%), the PE will become 1930/70 = 27.58 from the 33.16 you feel today. (8/n)
Which means in a company, which is expected to increase the earnings (EPS), will automatically have a lower PE the next year. This 70 projected EPS is called forward EPS and 27.58 is called forward PE. Generally good companies, increase their earnings year on year (9/n)
So you are buying RIL at 33.16 PE today, assuming the EPS will move from 58 to 70 and hence from the next year perspective, the PE (forward PE) you are paying is only 27.58. (10/n)
Now, like a stock has a PE and EPS (trailing & forward) Index also has it. Nifty trailing PE is 40 and trailing EPS is 365 (14600/40) (11/n)
How is Nifty’s PE & EPS calculated?

Nifty’s PE & EPS (trailing or forward) will be the weighted average PE & EPS of the 50 stocks the index is made up of. So if one stocks PE exponentially increases it has an increased impact on the nifty PE and vice versa (even for EPS) (12/n)
Nifty’s forward EPS is expected to be 461.9 for FY 21 and hence next year's PE is expected to be 31.61 (14600/461.9) vs the current 40 we see today. This is said as “Nifty is currently trading at 31.61 times 1-year forward EPS” (13/n)
Nifty’s FY22 expected EPS is 616 and hence FY22 PE is expected to be 23.70 (14600/616) and Nifty’s FY23 expected EPS is 723.8 and hence FY23 PE is expected to be 20.17 (14600/723.8) (14/n)
10 years average PE of Nifty is 19.9 and hence when FY23 PE is expected to be 20.17, analysts say Nifty is discounting FY23 earnings. Important here to also note is that Nifty is trading at 59% premium to FY21 EPS (31.61-19.9/19.9) (15/n)
The current PE is high at 40 because the earnings (EPS) has fallen drastically in the last 2 quarters due to COVID but prices have not and can look cheaper tomorrow ONLY if earnings pick up, like I have explained above (16/n)
But imagine if the forward expected EPS (earnings) does not come through? Today RILs PE is 33.16 because of 58.20 as EPS, you were expecting 70 as EPS and hence forward PE as 27.58 and hence buying it but the EPS next year comes at 60? (17/n)
Which means PE then would be 32.2 (1930/60) vs your expectations of 27.58 and hence it will suddenly start looking expensive again and might see selling pressure. (18/n)
Which is y it is said that stocks adjust back 2 the earnings. Today stocks r going ⬆️ bcoz of lower $ fuelling liquidity, lower % globally but @ some point earnings will have 2 support the valuations, if it does nt, PE will start looking expensive & that can trigger 🔽 in stock
So, keep an eye on the earning season over the next 2-3 quarters as it's the single most important factor to monitor which can move stock prices once the easily liquidity slows down. (20/21)
Hope the thread added value :) Hit the 're-tweet' and help us reach more investors. We have written multiple similar educative threads on personal finance. You can find them as a pinned tweet on my profile or click the link below (**END**)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh

Keep Current with Kirtan A Shah

Kirtan A Shah Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!


Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @kirtan0810

8 Jan
In such a low interest rate scenario, what if I tell you, there is a product, which pays 8.5%, tax free, default risk free & also gives you deduction under 80C, would you invest?

Follow this thread on EPF v/s VPF

Hit the ‘re-tweet’ and help us educate more investors (1/n)
In the western world, 1s u retire, ur medical, pension etc. is borne by the government. This is 1 lagging bit in India 4 various reasons where we don’t have social security schemes. To counter this, government runs schemes like NPS, EPF etc. (2/n)
We have written about NPS before & hence will not talk about it here; u can read our thread on the same. In this thread, we will focus on educating u on Employee Provident Fund & Voluntary Provident Fund & y u can allocate some investments here (3/n)

Read 27 tweets
26 Dec 20
In this #IPO frenzy market, lets talk (Thread) about some basics around
-Allotment process
-IPO Funding
-Grey Market

Hit the ‘re-tweet’ & help us educated more investors (1/n)
Why do companies come out with an IPO?

(a) Funding needs
- Business expansion plans
- Debt payoff

(b) Non-Funding requirement
- Enhancing corporate stature
- Exit options to large investors like the VCs & PEs (2/n)
While most of us believe IPOs are for funding requirements, you deep dive and understand it’s more of an exit channel for large investors (VC/PE). Let me explain the same concept from a start-up's perspective (3/n)
Read 25 tweets
18 Dec 20
Liquidity is fueling the stock market rally says everyone. What is this liquidity? How does it get created? How does it fuel stocks, commodities? (Thread)

Hit the ‘re-tweet’ and help us educate more investors’ (1/n)
Lets start with basic, y does inflation increase?
Most feel bcoz of higher demand & lower supply but that’s nt the only factor. Imagine there is a shortage of laptops wrt the demand, but there is no liquidity in the market (people don’t have monies) will the price of laptop⬆️? No
So, Inflation takes place because the demand supply situation is accompanied by liquidity, people have the monies to spend and hence the price goes up. Inflation does not take place only because of the demand supply gap (3/n)
Read 27 tweets
13 Dec 20
Here’s a compilation of Personal Finance threads I have written so far. Thank you for motivating me to do it.

Hit the 're-tweet' and help us educated more investors
Yes Bank’s additional Tier 1 bonds, written off. Lakshmi Villas Banks Tier 2 bonds, written off. Understand what & why of ATI and Tier 2 bonds in this thread.

'Floating Rate Funds' - A case for debt investing in the current interest rate situation (2/n)

Read 17 tweets
12 Dec 20
(Thread) With Kotak launching its International REIT Fund of Fund NFO, it is worth revisiting our old thread on Real Estate Investment Trust (#REIT). The Idea is to educate readers on REIT & share our view on the Kotak #NFO

Do ‘re-tweet’ & help us educate more investors (1/n)
What’s a REIT?

Lets say I am a RE developer, K Raheja. I like a land in Mumbai & Hyderabad 4 some commercial development. I decide to buy it. Where will I get the monies 2 buy & construct it?
1. Self
2. Bank, NBFC, MF - Debt
3. Partner – someone else investing as Equity (2/n)
So I invest some monies, got some 4m banks & MF’s & I also got Blackrock to invest 2 buy the land & make the business park called 'Mindspace'. I constructed around 23-mn sq ft with multiple building & I started leasing them out to companies who wanted rented office premises (3/n)
Read 31 tweets
4 Dec 20
Yes Bank’s additional Tier 1 bonds, written off. Lakshmi Villas Banks Tier 2 bonds, written off. Understand what & why of ATI and Tier 2 bonds in this thread.

Do ‘re-tweet’ and help us benefit more investors (1/n)
As a bank, you are in the business of borrowing & lending where the difference in the rate is the banks profit. So if the bank borrows under savings account, current account, FD etc at an average of 6% & lends at 8%, the difference of 2% is the banks profit. (2/n)
But there is a problem here,

If 100 is borrowed by the bank & 100 is lent & assuming there is a 10% NPA, the deposit holders will lose 10% of their deposits which is not a good sign and RBI surely does not like it (3/n)
Read 18 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!

This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!