A friend works for @HHSGov (agency that houses @CDCgov, #NIH , etc): they got an email from new HHS leadership within minutes after inauguration and CDC all-hands meeting scheduled ASAP.
2/ I realized yesterday that the public genuinely don’t realize how badly the Trump administration has botched the #COVID19 response. Here’s an example re: their vaccine distribution planning cnn.com/2021/01/21/pol…
3/ I’ve seen lots of pundits criticize public health people & our response to #COVID19. And I thought it was partially trolling/partially willful ignorance...
4/...but then I talked to a community leader yesterday that I know well & who’s helping older folks in our ‘hood access vaccination. He was like, “When this is over, I’d love to talk to you about how lucking health works cause I don’t get why things are this way...”
5/ As he talked, I realized that he thought the #COVID19 response was planned, that this was within the realm of a normal public health response. Something clicked into place for me.
6/ For people who are not in this world (especially younger folks), the US #COVID19 response is their first exposure to a big publicized real-time public health effort
6/ I reassured him, Oh, this is NOT normal. The Trump administration’s response is literally a playbook of what *not* to in the face of a threat like this (with exception of vaccine development, which went surprisingly well, bc they were hands off maybe?)...
7/ It’s really hard for me to emphasize strongly enough the depth and extremity of how bad their response was. For people who work in this world, people who know the right things to do, it is staggering and heart-breaking to watch a leadership make such bad decisions
8/ I’m not on the front lines of medical or applied public health, but I am trained enough in public health to see how bad it’s been. That is a big part of what has the past year so awful:
9/ all the preventable suffering and death. When people say, “It didn’t have to be this way,” it sounds like trite second-guessing. But really and truly, it didn’t not have to be this bad. It should not have gotten this bad. It’s almost incomprehensible.
10/ The biggest lesson I’ve learned the past year is how much leadership matters. In any organization or scheme. A well-functioning system can muddle through subpar leadership for a while (but not forever). But the wring leadership at the wrong time is an existential crisis
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
@Justfirenews Not quite. I’m arguing that they did the best that they legally could when constrained by bad policy. These are hard ethical calls. Do you continue working for an org that you think is heading in the wrong direction, or do you try to do your best from inside?
@Justfirenews I think about this a lot. For instance, my university brought back uni students for in-person learning last fall w no surveillance testing or modified housing. I thought that was a reckless decision. But I didn’t quit my job...
@Justfirenews Partially bc the balance of the work my colleagues were doing locally, nationally, & globally was so important and I could support that in a small way. Also income and longterm professional goals that I think will help public health beyond covid.
“Coretta Scott King returned to the city where her husband had been assassinated three days after claiming his body. This was truly extraordinary. On a national level, she’s demonstrating that the civil-rights movement would not be deterred by...
If she could, in the most nascent days of her widowhood, with small children at home mourning the loss of their father, show up to fight, so should everyone else.”
HT @Tiffany_L_Green
3/ This @AlexisCoe interview also reminds us what Dr. King and his family were advocating for in those harrowing days: labor rights - safe, fair working conditions and humane, equitable wages
Confession: I’m usually bad at celebrating #MLKDay
Unlike some friends, I don’t volunteer
I don’t re-read key essays or listen to speeches - unless a friend texts me the link right into our group chat (I have good, high-quality friends)
2/ Mostly I just use it as a vacation day and mildly joke with @lriversiii about the bougie lives we have constructed for ourselves and our children (“Was this Dr. King’s dream?” 🤔😏🤷🏾♀️)
3/ But I kind of need it this year. I need the model of people like #MLK to show me how to keep hope in the midst of malevolence and violent disregard for the well-being of others.
Y’all are great. Tl;dr - Big pharmacies get vaccine free & responsible for equipment, scheduling, administering & tracking. Paid mostly via insurance just like standard vaccination PLUS $14 extra for dose 1, $28 extra for dose 2. Sounds like no incentives or penalties for speed
But contract details not fully disclosed, it seems. In MS, state considering pulling out bc companies so slow: *1st* doses won’t be finished until MID FEBRUARY! Because they just didn’t hire enough people. Will CVS et al still get paid a minimum if states ends contract early?
1/ As an epidemiologist, I’m immensely grateful for anyone systematically documenting those refusing #COVID19 vaccination in health care and #LTC...and asking & recording their reasons why...
2/ Vaccine hesitancy is a major barrier to US achieving enough immunization to avoid rolling waves of #COVID19 outbreaks for years. It is *so* important to take it seriously and craft effective responses & strategies (feds should have started months ago, but that’s past)...
3/ It’s critical to watch this closely in this first round of vaccinations in #LTC longterm care/nursing homes and healthcare bc we have the benefit of a denominator in these settings...
1. Great question from @drjenndowd: Let’s say one is open to idea that some exposure & infection differentials in the population (left & right circles) are as great as age-susceptibility differentials (bottom circle):
How can I calculate this all out?