The support of women's equality on the basis of their sex-class isn't bigotry. Women have been discriminated against for all of history based upon it, why shouldn't there be true equality be based upon it as well?
Instead we get acquiescence demanded as kindness, biological reality equated with bigotry & critical thinking abandoned for subterfuge or outright rage. But the support of women's equality on the basis of their sex-class isn't bigotry.
The immutable claim that a yearning equals a completely different material reality regardless of & in spite of its detriment to women? That is bigotry. The command to cede not only space but essence is bigotry.
The next big push was meant to make equal pay & equal representation a reality for our daughters, to ensure women were safe in the workplace/the street/their homes-to put an end to a cycle of male violence-
not a struggle to maintain the very definition & meaning of "woman" or "female;" not a struggle against charges of hate crimes to say that there shouldn't be a blanket allowance for entry into vulnerable spaces.
The facts of biological reality & sexual dimorphism aren't unkind; diminishing the female experience is unkind. True inclusion can only ever be really successful when there's consensus. It has to be done together in a way that's right & respectful for all.
The acceptance, tolerance & support for a sustained, malicious effort to debase & intimidate women who don't agree with the negation & dismissal of their shared female experience & the removal of sex based rights will always be incendiary & fought against. As it should be.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
i've been so moved by the poetry i've read lately. this is a thread of the few poems that have come across my timeline so far. i'd love to read more. if you've seen any others, i'd love to read them.
While the historical disdain & hatred for women isn't a surprise, the severity of suffering & the unrevealed stories are frightening & devastating. I balk at what we don't know. This report covers 18/41 of these dark mills & only a fraction of the 231 years of their existence. 1/
I'm overwhelmed by the threads & accounts I've been reading over the last few days. I don't want to do it anymore, but at the same time I feel like we all need to bear witness to this atrocity. 2/
We rightly quiver at the though of the innocent babies. those pure beings so effectively eliminated in a fashion the worst of 20th century humanity could have provided; so callously offered up to strangers, given away by those who had no right to rend. 3/
Today is the international day for the elimination of violence against women. The violence, harassment & inequity perpetrated & fostered by men against women must stop & it‘s up to men to stop it.
An est 6% of males are rapists, that's approx. 234mil worldwide. This stat comes from two different studies cited below on the veracity of the Enliven Project re: the legal issues around rape, prosecutions & concerns about false accusations.
In the UK, the number of prosecutions & convictions for rape is down to the lowest level since annual recording began. In Ireland, 50% of women experience some form of sexual violence in their lifetime, compared to a fifth of men.
the facts of biological reality & sexual dimorphism aren't unkind. just as the support of women's equality on the basis of their sex-class isn't bigotry. who is acting the bigot here? those calling for reflection & discussion or those calling for the removal of democratic rights?
you slandered every person who's spoken up for all the women who feel like they are being erased & for children to be able to lead the healthiest lives possible, both physically & mentally. you've lied about your intentions & cowardly turned off replies. it's unconscionable.
critical thinking is needed for a functioning society. this is an extremely complex issue with so many variations & side roads. but to lay baseless accusations & defame anyone asking for deliberation shows how flimsy your stance is.
this industry does not need ring-fenced millions from our taxes & mine, incl €2.5m next yearto bring its annual subsidy to + €20m. @HollyCairnsTD & @SocDems are right to challenge this; it's a righteous cause.
but i wonder if @HollyCairnsTD & @SocDems can please respond to the extraordinary measures taken by @AmnestyIreland & @NWCI to effectively lobby the gov, & them as representatives, to deny political representation to a large swath of their constituents?
are Women's & Children's Rights also a noble cause worthy of discussion & respect? are they worthy of a response in the face of the most extraordinary call for direct disenfranchisement of Irish citizens?
i'm not an expert, obvs, but IMO referring to the possibility of male violence as "fantasy" multiple x in an argument seems a bit blind & demeaning. an est 6% of males are rapists, that's approx. 234mil worldwide. that's a lot of fantasies, & that's not including DV or common
assault or indeed the persistent occurrences of violent, degrading & sometimes life-threatening messages that women who don't conform to an ideology/dogma receive daily. & since rapists, abusers & misogynists usually don't have a note on their forehead claiming as such, it's
one of the female burdens to be wary of all male bodied people. if Judith Butler wants to term this fantasy, then surely it's a fantasy borne from reality & one that does its best to keep women alive & safe. to condescend that is not constructive or empathetic.