Senior Coroner for Worcestershire David Reid found that Rachel Johnston died as a result of complications of necessary surgery, to which neglect contributed

Full info here georgejulian.co.uk/2021/02/11/rac…

TLDR Lowlights (I can't bring myself to call them highlights) below

1/21
Coroner described Rachel as 'a lively and happy woman who loved music, theatre and the company of other people. She was blessed with a close family who would visit her regularly and bring her back home when there were family gatherings'

2/
The Coroner accepted that Rachel’s extensive dental surgery was necessary.

He ruled on a factual dispute, and found that on discharge Staff Nurse Kate Griffiths failed to provide a leaflet about dental surgery to the support worker who returned Rachel to her care home.

3/
The Coroner was satisfied that Rachel was fit to be discharged on the Friday evening after her surgery and that it was reasonable that she was.

Surgery was at 2pm and she was discharged at 7pm. She was awake, alert and singing before she left for home.

4/
The Coroner described unchallenged evidence that Rachel’s breathing was rattling or chesty on the Friday night and that she continued to bleed.

By 10:30am on Saturday Rachel was described as gurgling, with watery blood coming out of her mouth.

5/
The qualified nursing staff working at Pirton Grange on the Friday night, Saturday day, Saturday night and Sunday morning failed to take more than one partial set of observations of Rachel

6/
When they called 111 on Saturday evening they failed to provide adequate information to the out of hours nurse, who failed to sufficiently question when she return the call to them.

7/
On the balance of probabilities she [OOH Nurse] should have asked direct questions about Rachel’s bleeding, what her chest sounded like, and what most her recent physiological observations had been. These were questions a trained health care professional should have asked.

8/
The Coroner did not find Nurse Sheeba George to be a reliable witness.

As a matter of fact, on the balance of probabilities, I find Ms George did not take any physiological observations that evening, and that’s the reason she did not mention them in that phone call.

9/
The Coroner summarised the evidence relating to Rachel’s gradual decline, culminating in a 999 call and the arrival of paramedics shortly after 2pm on Sunday. Rachel had suffered an unsurvivable brain injury, as a result of her brain being starved of oxygen.

10/
She received intensive care treatment in hospital before the decision was made to move her to end of life palliative care, when she was returned to her home at Pirton Grange, where she died on the 13 November 2018.

11/
On the balance of probabilities, by Sunday, Rachel had already suffered some brain injury.

She should have been admitted to hospital on Saturday evening, and if she had been she probably would have survived.

12/
No doubt if Pirton Grange had in place a more robust system with policies, procedures, training and auditing, both those nurses would have carried out regular observations on Rachel over those two days, but that does not excuse their own failings.

13/
Basic nursing checks should have carried out and recorded, their failure to do so meant anyone, including themselves trying to build a picture of how Rachel was faring in the hours after her surgery were being denied key pieces of information.

14/
Coroner found the failure of the two nurses to carry out and document observations, and failure to seek emergency assistance from Saturday evening, amounted to a failure to provide basic medical attention to a person in a dependent position unable to provide it to herself.

15/
He found each of those incidents so total and complete, so patently not a simple error, they cld only be described as a gross error.

16/
He found the fact the Out of Hours Nurse did not ask sufficient questions was a failure ‘perhaps even a serious one, but not so serious as to amount to a gross failure’.

17/
Coroner was satisfied if regular observations had been recorded, by Saturday evening they would have indicated the need for emergency assistance.

Had it been sought Rachel would have been relayed to hospital earlier, and the Coroner was satisfied she would have survived.

18/
Therefore the two failures did contribute to Rachels’ death.

Short form narrative: Rachel died as a result of complications of necessary surgery, to which neglect contributed.

19/
Coroner concluded: Mrs Johnston if I can address you directly, can I start by offering you and the rest of your family my sincere condolences for your loss. The description you’ve given of your daughter, one can only attempt to imagine the hole left in your life as a result.

20/
Inquest is adjourned. Will resume on 23 February 2021 to hear the remainder of the Registered Manager of Pirton Grange’s evidence and to discuss Prevention of Future Deaths reports

/END

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with GeorgeJulian

GeorgeJulian Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @GeorgeJulian

1 Feb
Twitter, indulge me in a quick trip back down memory lane would you please. I'd like to talk a little about two beloved young men who died in the care of @Southern_NHSFT and the wider response to their deaths by our beloved #NHS, Connor and Edward

1/
Connor was a comedian, unofficially anyway, you can read his mum @sarasiobhan's blog for some highlights, start at the beginning, back before all the shite mydaftlife.wordpress.com/2011/05/26/the….

Sara documented family life, her disastrous travel adventures and LB's brilliance

2/
LB I hear you ask, it was an anonymous blog, LB was Laughing Boy, Connor, hence @JusticeforLB

If you'd like to know more check out Sara's first book uk.bookshop.org/books/justice-… or you can watch this brilliant 15min video from @mylifemychoice1 vimeo.com/130521001

I'll precis
3/
Read 40 tweets
1 Nov 20
Thinking of Paula Rawnsley and all of Thomas's family and friends today. Thomas died in February 2015, coming up to 6yrs ago.

Last September I was in Sheffield Coroner's Court with Paula on Day 2 of his inquest when it was adjourned for more expert evidence.

1/LONG THREAD 25+
I just want to talk a little bit about Paula and her search for answers about what happened to Thomas. Paula told me that she had already been labelled as difficult way before Thomas died.

Thomas was a much loved youngest brother and enjoyed a happy childhood at home

2/
As a teenager Thomas became more anxious and Paula asked for support to keep him at home.

She thought maybe they could get some respite help, or some advice. Thomas used Makaton to communicate and was able to make most of his needs known to those he knew well

3/
Read 37 tweets
9 Oct 20
Gather round twitter, I've not done a post like this for a while, but I'd like to introduce you to Jared.

Last week I spoke to Jared's mum, Vicky, and wanted to share some of what she told me, and let you know how you can help #JusticeforJaredB 1/29 A boy wearing a pink tie and waistcoat and a white shirt smi
Jared was Vicky's first born, arriving on 20 February 1994. Vicky was a young mum, only 19, but very excited for the future.

Jared was a perfect baby, he didn’t cry a lot, he slept and fed well, but at his 6mth check-up there was concern he wasn’t putting weight on. 2/
From that point on Jared received support. They had input from physiotherapists, occupational therapists and a speech therapist at their home, along with a brilliant community paediatric nurse. 3/
Read 29 tweets
3 Sep 20
Spent day reading PFDs (Prevention of Future Death) reports and associated stuff. So disheartening to see same issues crop up repeatedly. Am gonna share one lowlight, whilst recognising these are only written due to ongoing concerns after someone has died..
so really they're all lowlights. In my experience NHS Trusts and care providers will do *anything* to avoid being issued a PFD, it's like reputation is all that matters.

I'd like to share about John Gregory, he was 93 when he died in October 2019 judiciary.uk/publications/j…
'Mr Gregory died because he had not been drinking enough, though his Alzheimer’s was not end stage, and before he was admitted to hospital he had been mobile; able to wash, dress and feed himself; and enjoy a good quality of life'
Read 43 tweets
29 Jul 20
Just connected to court for the #CovidSEND judicial review case [It's very echoey, legal teams are in court, a number of people attending remotely through Skype]

Background thread here

I believe those in court are listed in attachment.
@polly_sweeney of @scottmoncrief, @SteveBroach of @39publiclaw and @AliceLIrving for claimants Amber and @1985Deanne Shaw and anonymous claimant ABC thru XYZ

@sarahhannett and Nathan Roberts of @matrixchambers and Mark Davies of @6PumpCourt for defendant SOS for @educationgovuk
As far as possible I will tweet word for word what is said, if not possible due to speed I'll paraphrase. I'll offer no analytical commentary, I'm simply trying to facilitate #OpenJustice thru live tweeting to a wider audience #CovidSEND
Read 629 tweets
29 Jul 20
I'll be live tweeting #CovidSEND judicial review for the next two days from the High Court of Justice, Queen's Bench Division Administrative Court sitting in front of The Hon Mr Justice Kerr.

Case is brought by @1985Deanne and Amber Shaw (pictured) and an anonymous claimant

1/
Claimants challenge SOS @educationgovuk @GavinWilliamson's decision to modify legal duty under S42 Children and Families Act 2014 #CovidSEND

This places a duty on local authorities to secure provision to meet special educational needs and health needs as set out in an EHCP

2/
EHCP = Education, Health and Care Plan.

According @educationgovuk 354k children and young people had an EHCP in 2019 assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/upl…

Thousands of families affected by the SOS decision to replace the duty with requirements to use 'reasonable endeavours' #CovidSEND

3/
Read 26 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!