Some of you will probably know I'm currently grieving. It's a month since my fantastic sister died. I've been thinking a lot about loss, progress and reckoning and coming to terms, both personally and as a society. And I've been wondering: how will we remember the pandemic dead?
The UK is filled with memorials to the dead of wars, of disasters, of lifeboat crews and atrocities. We are a landscape haunted by attempts to remember the brave and the innocent. Villages, towns, businesses, communities: all grouped together to pay for plaques, statues, gardens
I have a terror that in our desire to get 'back to normal' we will forget those lost and things lost during the current pandemic. There's not an enemy they were overcome by; not a single flashpoint of tragedy. Those lost to the pandemic are an uncomfortable reminder of failure
Rebecca Solnit talks about hope only coming from knowing history. People may be optimistic about the future post-covid-19, but that's just desire and dream. For us to build a hopeful future we need to acknowledge and feel what has been lost; to repair and grow, not just erase
The thing is, I don't know if our communities know how to remember what is lost, not in ways that are meaningful to all of that community. Religion is a great enabler of remembrance, but that's not something everyone has. I'm wondering how we fully inhabit our collective sorrow
I feel like the seeds of something better are there in the soil of that sorrow; but that our every instinct will be to turn away from them, to salt the ground so that uncomfortable weeds of what has been lost cannot grow up through the shining 'building back better'
You might argue that we shouldn't politicise sorrow and loss, that blame is not appropriate at a time where unprecedented circumstances led to decisions that are obviously wrong in retrospect. I think this is a trap to avoid the possibility of sorrow turning to hope of better
I feel like there should be a cadre of people helping communities to find a better world in midst of sorrow. Grief doulas if you like. People who for next couple of years come forward to work with expression of collective grief. Not to put it to bed, but to help it become fertile
Imagine every place in the UK set itself the task of finding someway of understanding and living within what has been lost, then creating a new something: a new vision, a new togetherness, a place or a thing that allows the anger, loss, isolation to find a place in the new world
Without a way of carrying the reality of those people lost and those things lost into the new landscape, our collective response will exclude, will devalue. The rush for a national narrative will just be rhetoric and avoidance and the change we need will not happen
WIthout a shared common space in which grief and loss and sorrow can exist, both for lives lost and ways of life lost, we'll just end up with a world that tries to be the same as it was before, and with nowhere but dreams and disaffection for those who have lived through but lost
I don't really know who these grief workers should be; but they need a space to exist and to draw people together. To know what a better world will be takes going to where and when the last one was at its worst. I fear instead we will create a taboo against pandemic loss
We need something that bridges individual and collective loss. We don't have it now. Covid-19 isn't to blame for the pandemic. How our world was organised and how we responded is. We need to remember how loss of people and things happened to avoid it happening again
But my sense is that we don't need a national 'story' of loss. What we need to do is take the licence and space to make our own smaller collective remembrances, to seize back the story in whatever shape that takes. And we don't know how to do that yet: to transmute loss to hope
I do know that the people who lost least and have the greatest resources will define the 'national story'. I also know that this is wrong. The pandemic year isn't just the story of those who made it out relatively unscathed. And loss isn't just a problem to be managed
We don't really know how to build a culture of remembrance and of living through sorrow for thousands of individuals who died because they were in wrong place at the wrong time. We don't know how to make that individual plural. If the risk is hollow theatre, the answer is meaning
I dunno, I picture a vast quilt of different responses, different reckonings, different communities and different conclusions. And to get that quilt started we need to begin the process of sowing and stitching and gather yarn. It;s not too early. It's exactly the right time
And what do we need to overcome? Those who feel the fear they will be tainted by touching the loss of others; people who fear what that loss may tell us about the world that was and the world to come. They'll want to avoid the inconvenience of the need to remember
Many people have lost their lives, and many more have lost the lives they thought they would have. And that isn't inconvenient to 'bouncing back'. It's what bouncing back is bouncing back from. It's not an alternate discussion about the future. It's what the discussion should be
I'm just a sad person missing their dead sister. I've not got any answers tonight. My story is important and so is everyone else's. But forgetting will be a violence against those already hurt.
Thanks for listening. I'm off to make the dinner. Hope you're all as OK as it's possible to be right now.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Mark Brown

Mark Brown Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MarkOneinFour

12 Feb
Just doing a bit of reading, the talk of NHS reorganisation having whetted my appetite for a bit of health geekery. I'm mainly trying to get my head around the purchaser provider split in NHS and what that means. Here's @mellojonny from 2011 (Pre Lansley) abetternhs.net/2011/01/18/com…
This by Mick Timmins is great "choice and competition in health seem to work best when there is a growing rather than a shrinking market – and, despite its relative protection, health has been a shrinking market since 2010" kingsfund.org.uk/blog/2017/06/c…
*Nick, not Mick
Read 5 tweets
12 Feb
Thinking about health and social care integration. Some people think you need reorganisation to remove silos. But, thing is, people like silos. And things not working in partnership often result from one partner not wanting to, or being in a position to do, what the other wants
I think reorganisation of health and social care always tilts toward 'reorganisation of social care so the NHS works better' and very seldom 'reorganisation of NHS so social care works better'. Social care isn't just an element of local authority work that enables the NHS
I kepp thinking of the grand utopian dream of end-to-end health and social care, all together under one notional organisational roof like Toys R Us and thinking: it is a utopian dream and it's also one that people didn't really like the closer it was to reality
Read 6 tweets
8 Feb
Actually, one thing I have been doing during lockdown is really indulging in 'this looks like that' & 'that sounds like this'. What I mean is kind of grazing and burrowing into visual or auditory things. Exploring without going anywhere by jumping from book to book, song to song
Really, consciously tickling my visual and auditory palate by finding things that feel new or which belong with each other by theme, production, sound or, I dunno, shared feeling of jouissance. An example: old pre-internet photobooks on niche subjects with that kodachrome hue
It's like really spending enough time in a landscape that you can see the history of the topography, uncover the old paths, see what links things that otherwise seem unconnected. Seeing the contour lines of culture and human ideas between previously singular seeming things
Read 4 tweets
8 Feb
Things I've done for my #mentalhealth during lockdown include: having a cup of tea; making space to do things just for me; getting on with some stuff that means a lot to me; looking out of the window; not kicking my own arse for things I've not done during a national crisis
I've not written a book. Or found a new hobby. Or learned a language. I've mostly been concentrating on just having a day to day life with small pleasures and tiny doses of awe and wonder. I feel like too many people think of activity as medicine against being mental
I can't give you any tips. Why should I be able to? I don't know you. I don't know what helps you to feel like your life is going OK. Having people to talk to is important to me. It mightn't be to you. Having something interesting to think about is important to me. You may differ
Read 13 tweets
4 Feb
Another year, another time to #TimetoTalk day. This year I'd like to talk about mess and discomfort. One element of stigma is feeling like you carry a story and history that will never be understood and never be possible to integrate with the lives and stories of everyone else
If there's a #TimetoTalk day, there should also be a #timetolisten day. And listening means learning to live with stories that discomfort, stories that trail off, stories that ask questions you can't answer. Mental ill-health is a fucking mess to live with.
The experiences people share around mental ill-health will not conform to your wider narrative expectations. The job of making our stories make sense that we have who live through them is not the same job that a person listening has. #timetotalk isn't about you
Read 8 tweets
3 Feb
Worth looking at trending topic 'CAMHS' (Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services) right now. We aren't providing good service to everyone who needs it. We're often providing a weird service to people who do because CAMHS gets blown about by cultural ideas about mental health
Yes, I know people don't really share much about healthcare experiences that went well, but people's experiences of CAMHS that are being shared present CAMHS as contextless set of unexplained events where things happen for no reasons instead of a place of help and support.
With CAMHS wider cultural winds are like "We need to give children/ young people every support they need for their mental health unless we don't. We don't medicalise distress, unless we do, but we might not again, keep you on yr toes. If you don't want service, you can have it."
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!