DiAngelo does work in "whiteness studies" which run parallel to CRT amd makes use of CRT. The difference is focus. One focuses on *race* the other on whitness specifically...but they have massive overlap in terms of the underlying assumptions and worldview
This is why we get papers like this one which link the two.
Saying whitness studies and CRT are seperate is is like saying northern baptists and southern baptsits are seperate. In a sense they are, but they have nearly identical views.
Its the narcisim of small differences
Compered to each other they are a little different. But put them both in a room amd they have way more in common with each others theology then they have with, say, Hindus.
CRT and whitness studies both make use of postmodernism, and both make use of Critical Theory
To pretend that these things are totally unrelated is not fair or honest.
It's like when someone says they don't believe in God and you try to discredit them by showing they don't know about some obscure and subtle point that a theologian msde in the 16th century.
If the major point about the central thing of Christianity *GOD* is rejected, some subtle point about how to interpret a geneology isn't going to matter because that person rejects God to begin with.
They can reject Christianity without having memorize your particular catechism
Showing atheists you know more about the bible proves nothing.
Showing me that you also know whiteness studies has technical differences with CRT but maintains many of the same outlooks and assumptions also proves nothing.
If you want to bring in Postmodern scholarship abd Critical Theory you should say that, and then lets have that debate.
But dont play the game where you try to argue that I'm not finely parsing you constellation of disciplines. I reject your worldview.
Lets have that discussion
Also typos abound in this thread
I wrote fast, on a phone.
Sorry🤷♂️
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ Manifesting is postmodern spirituality. The metaphysics of discourse creates the world, but it is in the postmodern mind a force that can be harnassed through language and thought.
"Manifesting" fits perfectly into that understanding of the world...
2/ Remember the postmoderns think *everything* is entirely socially constructed and if the world is created by society using language, which means the world is built using words that exlress ideas, thoughts, ideologids, dreams, goals, and so on.
Well....
3/ That means the "world" as it's understood to be constructed is not an unintentional brute reality, but it's filled with and interwoven with thoughts, ideas, beliefs, and dreams
If you graft our natural human propensity for spirituality on to that understanding of the world...
This is transparent bad faith. He takes his own reading of the politics of America amd then just says "translation" to insinuate something was said that was not said.
I hope he doesn't take the same approach to scripture
If this was an even vaguely plausible reading of what was being said I would leave it. But it isn't. Ot's a deliberate attempt to paint something in the worst light and pretend it says something it does not.
1/ It says use a dictionary to define communism, but as @realchrisrufo showed in *the next tweet* kids had to simulate a Free Angela Davis rally. She's a communist. It's easy to infer the kids were primed to give a favorable definition of communism...
2/ Greg also ignores that, these *5TH GRADERS* are being taught about *checks notes* Black Communism in a unit where Angela Davis, who once said people in Soviet Gilags deserved it, is painted as nothing more then an academic and activist.
Again, these kids can barely even read.
3/ And we are supposed to pretend there's nothing to see here.
Scott attacks Denny's character. He says there is no evidence of Denny's "work ethic and ability" then says that Denny is not just wrong, but also that Denny cares more about his own power then he does about truth.
Any way you slice it those are character attacks.
note that Scott uses the term "raw ability." That means the natural intelligence to do the work. He isn't going after Denny for not being trained, or properly educated for the task. Scott is attacking Denny's intelligence.
I'm not being a jerk, I'm making my point with a sledgehammer.
Pretending differences between men and women don't exist is utterly absurd, and people keep saying it. This ACLU lawyer quite literally says "Women and girls who are trans are biological women and girls."
1/ Yesterday we found out @ginacarano was fired from Star Wars over Social Media posts
Lots of people talk about cancel culture, but so far no one has given a serious account of exactly what cancel culture is, where it comes from, and how it works
So, Cancel Culture
A Thread🧵
2/ There's a lot of confusion around cancel culture both because cancel culture is a new phenomenon, and because some people have dishonestly and cynically misused the term in order to score political points. So let's try to get clear about EXACTLY what's cancel culture is.
3/ To begin, I need to say something about "free speech."
Free Speech is not *only* a legal principle. It is that, but it isn't *just* that. Free speech is also an enlightenment liberal **VALUE**
Read that last sentence again because it's the beating heart of my thinking here.