I'm tired of reading perspectives implying that #Myanmar people don't know what they are risking.
It doesn't matter how politically/economically savvy the take:
It's rubbish if it isn't centered on a high regard for the agency, self-determination, and wisdom of Myanmar ppl, especially ethnic minorities.
They know they are fighting a lion--they know this better than we do.
**I write this as someone who is constantly trying to weed out this paternalistic orientation in myself. I've listened to the wrong voices at times; I've definitely retweeted the wrong things at times. I regret that, and I'm thankful for all the voices teaching me to do better.
Some reflections on #myanmar op-eds by Myanmar outsiders these days. A thread:
I understand why Myanmar folks, some of whom are in exile, might write op-eds that sound resigned in regard to the viability of the #myanmar protest movement. They have their reasons.
But I really wish non-Myanmar outsiders would stop writing this sort of stuff. Pieces that say “protest movements alone never succeed” sound neo-colonial, for one thing.
But for another, these pieces are players in the movement in a real way, and in a detrimental way.
In protest and civil disobedience movements, people are fighting with words to create the world they want to see, a world they believe is possible.
Their faith and hope, and holding onto it despite the odds, is necessary in order for the movement to succeed.
1) go to a place where you don't speak the language. 2) make sure that the only people who come to you for healing have an invisible disability. 3) make sure you have a translator who has prepped the community for your visit.
Here's the thing: trying to confirm something like this is rather complicated.
And if it were confirmed and subsequently broadcasted as true, it would only serves to encourage more people to do phony faith healing activities.
Chan's initiative here is partnered with YWAM and Antioch church. They have a five year plan for flooding Myanmar with their brand of good news. I have yet to hear anything about it that sounds healthy or even well-thought out.
So, Francis Chan is planning to move to Hong Kong in order to carry out ministry in Myanmar, and he introduced these plans by saying, “There’s no one fishing over there.”
Years ago, my husband was talking to a friend about western church leaders and their habits of going to places where they don’t know people, working through translators, conducting serial baptisms, and marketing their “grand work” back to the West.
“I don’t know, can you love someone without knowing them?” @moungkp mused.
His friend replied, “Yes you can. It’s call rape.”