Here’s @Twitter’s new #COVID19 misleading info @Policy, which includes details of “strikes” for repeated offenders: help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-p… Of note? Twitter will not add a feature for consumers to flag misinformation or disinformation about masks, vaccines.
This may put journalists reporting on PPE shortages or other governmental failures into conflict with the new @Policy. What if authorities misled about prevalence or death?
Much depends on health authorities @Twitter relies on being right. (Cf. @WHO@CDCgov on masks a year ago.)
What is NOT in violation of Twitter’s new #covid19 misinformation @Policy?
“Strong commentary, opinions, and/or satire” if they don’t contain false or misleading statements of facts, & “counterspeech.”
(TBD how @WSJopinion fares. Watch how FDRLST is handled.)
Dear @Twitter: please disclose 1) who your trusted partners are for enforcing your new #COVID19 misinformation @Policy, so we know whose judgement & knowledge you’re relying on for labels, suspensions, & bans 2) data on this category of moderation, including why accounts banned
These 4 screenshots outline @Twitter’s new “strike system” @Policy for violating #COVID19 rules. Consequences depend on context (severity & type of violation, account history) & include deletion, labels, freezing, locks, & permanent suspension.
Of note: @Twitter says it will “prioritize producing @TwitterMoments in cases where misleading content is gaining significant attention & has caused public confusion.”
Moments = a new PSA system to push trustworthy media info out when mis/disinfo hits a tipping point (trending?)
Anyone who claims content moderation is easy is in error :)
Mitigating spread of viral medical misinfo will be HARD, but crucial in a pandemic.
@Twitter is late on this @Policy, but I applaud @TwitterSafety for rolling it out, given need to vamoose vaccine lies & debunk rumors.
If @Twitter is both willing & able to proactively address lies about masks & vaccines & other medical misinfo on its platform, not giving us the ability to report violations might be ok, but I am not convinced that’s the case. People flag for “self harm” now, which isn’t optimal.
Doubling down on labels embraces a strategy that obviously failed to mitigate Trump’s “Big Lie” about a “stolen election” & “widespread voter fraud.”
This “strike” system may be progress, but I’d suggest putting “superspreaders” in epistemic quarantine: cnn.com/2020/12/08/tec…
The @stanfordio report found the primary repeat spreaders of lies & misinformatin online were the @verified accounts of far-right media outlets, social media 'influencers,' & politicians, including @POTUS45 & his family. stacks.stanford.edu/file/druid:tr1… Labels didn't address that, at all.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The @opengovpart put the United Kingdom “under review” for failing to involve its public in co-creating an #opengov plan & submitting 2 late.
I remember when OGP restored the US after we released a weak “action plan” opengovpartnership.org/wp-content/upl…
Wait until OGP learns what @POTUS45 did
When @opengovpart put the US “under review,” who noticed?
Watchdogs had decried corruption & illiberalism; most didn’t participate in the forums.
No far-right media reported “censure.” (Sure wasn’t on Fox.)
After 4th NAP submitted, OGP acted as if US was healthy, & lifted review.
“social media companies have to be responsible for verifying what are real news sources and what are not —and tagging things as disinformation. And being transparent around ‘Who are these pages, who’s funding them, what’s their budget’?”-@MichaelDTubbscjr.org/special_report…
As @ybenkler reminded me, lying about politicians is protected by the First Amendment, &, unlike a Facebook or Twitter moderating an account or Page, governments removing a site of literal fake news would raise speech issues: defusingdis.info/2019/01/17/how…
Defamation law is an option.
When a Senator asked me how to deal with a fake news website in his state, I didn’t suggest taking it down, & suggested he do many of things that Tubbs did: sunlightfoundation.com/2017/12/19/win…
Politicians have limited options.
Search & social media companies need to ID “pink slime” sites.
If you’re not following this closely, the vision of Christian nationalism is incompatible with a pluralistic, multiracial democracy.
It’s the direct descendant of the Confederacy & white supremacy.
It’s key to understanding Trumpism & the 1/6 insurrection: nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/…
A minority of Republicans have now repudiated the Big Lie & Trumpism, as “far-right populism,” not “conservatism,” noting the deification of Trump & his immorality, but @MJGerson doesn’t name Christian nationalism (or White nationalism) for what they are washingtonpost.com/opinions/there…
Republicans are misleading Americans into blaming the Texas blackouts on renewable energy sources, like wind.
Reality: icy conditions knocked plants offline & froze coal stores. Grid wasn’t designed for cold. washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/…
It’s Australia redux:
“Most of the shortfall in electric power generation during the current cold snap is the result of natural gas & coal powered plants going offline.” reason.com/2021/02/16/ren…
By falsely asserting otherwise, @WSJopinion is misleading subscribers, & further damaging @WSJ’s reputation.
This headline by @VICENews is fair, factual, & accurate: vice.com/en/article/88a… If you see the cause of the Texas blackouts falsely associated with renewable energy or wind turbines by a politician, follow the money to their conflicts of interest in the oil & gas industry.
"after a failed coup attempt aimed at overthrowing the results of free & fair elections certified by all 50 states, [this] administration must come to grips with the stark reality that democracy…is in its worst crisis since the Civil War"-@piccone_tedbrookings.edu/blog/order-fro…
"Our political process and electoral systems, while having endured a massive stress test, still need major work to comply with basic standards of free and fair elections with universal suffrage for all U.S. citizens"-@piccone_ted