There have been many comments wondering if Appraisals won't support some of the high RE prices we have been seeing
As I have posted before its not a big issue on a 45 or 60 day closing because there will be new sales supporting those prices
2/
The trouble starts when markets plateau or worst of all a market dip
In the late Spring of 2017 we had many Appraisal Disasters
RE prices in the GTA abruptly stop rising in April of 2017 after a 16 month run
House closings in May onward often had appraisal issues
3/
Problems continued throughout 2017 as new construction purchases bought in 2016 in York and Peel all had appraised values under purchase price
What will happen if this RE market cools off?
This time the run up has been in so many regions it will be a bigger issue
4/
If I bought new construction in Durham in the last 6 months closing late this year or 2022 I might start thinking about having more down payment than the minimum 20%
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
And this ain't prediction, because prediction is a crap business and BTW I am not suggesting a crash or the bursting of a bubble, I am saying when do these batshit crazy prices increases end?
Because the wild increases will end
2/
And that's analysis not prediction
Either the government stops it with mortgage rule changes, or inflation pushes bond yields and in turn fixed rates to a point consumers step back or the market burns out on its own accord, enough people just quit looking
Do I know when?
3/
No I don't, maybe some time this year
Will prices reverse? Maybe, I simply know the ridiculous appreciation will stop
So what does that mean? Well what it historically means is some sort of price dip occurs even if only because people who bought have to sell
Canadian Real Estate Prices Leading Some to Craziness
I posted the other day about Buyer exhaustion at the stressful RE bidding wars that caused some folks to quit looking which conceptually could level off RE price trends
Many interesting responses but a few were wild
2/
Some thought house prices could go much higher
And a couple thought Toronto house prices were LOW and needed to catch up with Vancouver house prices
People are entitled to think whatever they want, that's the beauty of Canada
Here's a thought though:
3/
There is a fault line in RE in many regions
When you want to get into the market you hate the high prices
The day your offer is accepted you pray the prices keep running up
And it not like Equities, RE is an illiquid product, unlike stocks your kids sleep in the RE
4/
The massive downturn in the Toronto condo market is documented everyday
The facts are just easy, Airbnb collapse, foreign University student collapse, downtown restaurant and hospitality worker renter exodus, flight from small living spaces
2/
It's a long list that radically reduces the number of renters and drives condo owners to seek freehold housing
Heck, we even have relentless addition of new condos from completing construction projects
The simple supply / demand math destroys value with no end in sight
3/
Well maybe a 2022 end in sight but 12 - 18 months of mayhem
Likely 25% - 35% down from peak condo pricing VERY dependent on product with the sub 500 sq ft product in real trouble
But will the contagion spread to Freehold: Towns, Semis and Detached?
Hey, I am not in the prediction business but I am in the observation business
Simple facts: downtown Toronto rents are falling steadily and if they continue to fall prices will errode
That's facts and math not prediction
And rents will fall
2/
This is simple stuff all Covid related
1) No foreign students, turns out this was big, rarely talked about and looks like they're gone till Fall 2021 2) No Airbnb, not just no tourists, no sporting events, weddings, proms huge list, Fall 2021 for return but slow even then
3/
3) Too many renters in Hospitality lost their jobs and moved back with parents or doubled with friends: Fall 2021 or never 4) For people with ongoing jobs, downtown offices empty, WFH but HATED cooped up experience, bought Towns or Detached likely NEVER back
4/