I think the thing people need to understand about anti-Asian racism (with its roots in the ‘Yellow Peril’) is that it is and always has been closely linked to xenophobia. This was the case in the 19th century, during the rise of Japan in the 70s & 80s, and today. 1/
That makes it related to other forms of racism but also different - just as leukemia and colon cancer are both cancers and bad things that should be rooted out but also very distinct from one another. 2/
And the link between anti-Asian racism and xenophobia is why it probably isn’t going away any time soon - and may even get with worse in the near term. The emergence of China is something deeply threatening to the American psyche, just as the rise of Japan was. 3/
Indeed, for many evangelicals, US hegemony is part of God’s plan. But even for people who don’t have such a religious view of the country, there is a deep attachment to the idea that the US is the “richest country in the world,” “the leader of the world,” etc. 4/
And, yes, there are many things about China today that are rightly criticized. But as much as many people will say that their negative reactions to China are based on those things, many of the tropes that get used are the same ones once used about democratic, capitalist Japan. 5/
And it bears repeating that because anti-Asian racism is based on seeing Asians as this foreign & unassimilatable “other,” views about China (and Japan in its day) readily get projected onto Asian Americans. 6/
You readily see that in the attacks this past year - the go back to China taunts, the Twitter replies like the one below to me which are, alas, just par for the course for Asian Americans. 7/
In short, it would be good for people to understand what Asian Americans mean when we say we experience racism. So many people try to compare it to racism experienced by other groups, when it is at once related but different. It’s important for people to understand that. 8/
And every politician who casually engages in and uses Asian tropes because they get a rise (and Democrats do their fair share of this) should know that they are feeding into the xenophobia that leads to violence against Asian Americans. 9/
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Re-upping this thread 🧵on the *long* history of discrimination and violence toward Asian Americans in the United States based on the sense that we are too foreign, too ‘other,’ too perpetually alien. It is important that people know this history.
And related to all of this is the notion of the ‘Yellow Peril’ - the idea that Asians and Chinese in particular are conniving threats to the America - an idea which plays out in things like this
And lest you say, that kind of anti-Asianness is about people who are foreign nationals, not about American citizens, I’m here to tell you that a great many Americans have a very hard time telling the difference. To wit below, a very common variant of a Twitter response I get.
A thread 🧵 on the redistricting provisions of H.R. 1 - which many people shorthand describe as banning partisan gerrymandering and/or requiring independent commissions for drawing congressional districts - but which really are a *lot* more. #ForThePeople#HR1#fairmaps 1/
First, let’s talk about the partisan gerrymandering ban. Unlike the partisan gerrymandering cases litigated in state and federal court, H.R. 1’s partisan gerrymandering covers not just intent but also *effects.* #ForThePeople#HR1#fairmaps 2/
This is crucial because, as we saw last decade, maps can be wildly skewed (think the 12-4 in OH or 13-5 in PA) but evidence of intent is often carefully hidden & lawmakers offer any number of pretexts, requiring complex, time consuming litigation. #ForThePeople#HR1#fairmaps 3/
It goes without saying that the 1776 Commission doesn’t deal honestly or in depth about the causes of the American Revolution (see below).
But my view is most liberals don’t either. The genesis of the Revolution is mostly glossed over by both left and right.
Maybe at most you get something about taxes or the lack of representation in Parliament, but then you swiftly move on to ‘we’re now independent and drafting a constitution.’ But the Revolution’s roots bear looking at - because they can be pretty dark.
And for that darkness, you need look no further than the litany of complaints in the Declaration of Independence itself. To wit:
Worth noting that Manchin is talking here about $4 trillion over *ten* years. By contrast, we’ve spent over $6.4 trillion on wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
To compare, China *did* spend on infrastructure, in particular as part of its response to the Great Recession. Below (left) the Beijing subway in 2003 and (right) what it looks like today (with 2021 extension).
China also has spent massively on high-speed rail since 2008 - and is still doing so (the size of China's high-speed rail network will double again in the this decade).
In our modern celebrations of Dr. King, it can become easy to conflate Dr. King with the civil rights movement writ large. But it’s important to remember how messy & sometimes fraught movement politics were - w/ often sharp disagreements based on policy, tactics & personalities.
And it wasn’t just MLK vs. Malcolm X or later the Black Panthers. Even things like the the sit-ins and the Selma march were very controversial in some quarters at the time.
And some people who did key work didn’t get credit at the time (women in particular). Some still haven’t been fully recognized.