NEW: “Catching Up With ‘Coddling’”! @AdGo & I theorize how ideological litmus tests in education schools may have contributed to the changing ideas about #socialjustice we saw arriving on campus around 2013. 1/10

thefire.org/catching-up-wi…
This is the FOURTEENTH part in the series where we revisit the topics in @JonHaidt & my 2018 book, “The Coddling of the American Mind,” with new data, developments, & caveats. 2/10

amzn.to/39w0DLr
By “changing ideas about social justice,” we mean things like definitions of “equity” that are focused on equality of outcomes, at the expense of things like procedural or substantive fairness. 3/10
By 2002, an accreditor of over 600 education schools adopted a requirement that students be evaluated for their commitments to “social justice” and “diversity.” 4/10

thefire.org/fire-statement…
Member institutions, like @TeachersCollege, followed suit. As @kcjohnson9 documented, the inclusion of these requirements by the accreditor was quickly reflected in the policies of the schools. 5/10

academic.brooklyn.cuny.edu/history/johnso…
ZERO TWEET: Stay after this intermission to see how the NY Times made me a HuffPost blogger, or switch reels to see the trouble with the expansion of Title IX into speech policing. 0/10

WAAAY back, just a few months before we saw the trainwreck known as Spider-Man 3, I wrote an OpEd critical of the imposition of an ideological litmus test: 6/10

chronicle.com/article/social…
That piece had originally been submitted to & accepted by the #nytimes. But a junior editor had accepted it. When the senior editor returned, I was told it *might* run… sometime in the next nine months. I licked my wounds, gave up & instead submitted it to the @chronicle. 7/10
BUT the junior editor remembered what had happened & at his very next position at @HuffPost, invited me to blog there. Ever wonder how I ended up a HuffPo writer for a decade? That’s the secret story of how that I have never told before. 8/10

huffpost.com/author/greg-lu…
To its credit, the accreditor (now part of @caepupdates) did reform its requirements to clarify that embracing its ideology was not a requirement of entering the profession. But the schools went the other direction, as we’ll see ... 9/10
Next in CUWC, we go deeper into what education schools look like today, & what that means for K-12 education going forward. See the whole series: 10/10

thefire.org/tag/eri-catchi…
BONUS TWEET: Don’t let the ideological litmus test at education schools fool you — the “big middle” of collegiate censorship is apolitical. 11/10

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Greg Lukianoff

Greg Lukianoff Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @glukianoff

28 Jun
Wondering about the controversy surrounding "anti-CRT” bills popping up all over the country? You’re not alone. It’s taken me several weeks & 3 co-authors to write this 5000+ word piece (1/34)

thefire.org/13-important-p…
.@AdGo @RynoWeiss & Bonnie Snyder have put together 13 points you should know about the “anti-CRT” law debate. (2/34)
(1) There are dozens of these bills, w/ hundreds of amendments. (This is also why it’s absurd when activists on either side accuse opponents of hypocrisy for not instantly condemning every new bill.) (3/34)
Read 37 tweets
27 May
After tabulating the votes, the winner of my first EXCESSIVELY Prestigious Award for book of the year is @jon_rauch’s Kindly Inquisitors, what I've called the most important on #freespeech of the last 50 years! 1/6
thefire.org/jonathan-rauch…
For the honor, I had @TheFIREorg’s @aaron_reese make this dope gif, explaining Rauch’s Commandments — two core tenets of liberal science! 2/6
With Rauch’s book The Constitution of Knowledge coming out in June, the timing might seem TOO convenient, but I swear on Spider-Man’s aunt May that’s just how the vote worked out! (BTW The Constitution of Knowledge is the most important book of 2021!) 2/6

amzn.to/2RyyxtS
Read 9 tweets
26 May
THREAD: The great @IonaItalia asked me to participate in @AreoMagazine’s #FreeSpeechFortnite, so I wrote a listicle of 12 answers to common, bad arguments against #freespeech. Here’s the short attention span version! 1/14

areomagazine.com/2021/05/25/ans…
First there’s that XKCD comic that people trot out to justify just about any censorship. It wrongly conflates the First Amendment, which is the legal framework for free speech in the US, & free speech generally. It also doesn’t even get the 1A right! 2/14
“Free speech was invented under the false notion that speech & violence are distinct. Now we know some speech is violence.” Speech = violence is one of the oldest ideas in the world. Free speech was invented so people could sort things out without resorting to violence. 3/14
Read 16 tweets
30 Apr
NEW Prestigious Awards: My book of the month goes to @juliagalef’s The Scout Mindset: Why Some People See Clearly & Others Don’t, a book with powerful tools for fighting self-deception! 1/9

thefire.org/the-scout-mind…
The book helps rein in the toughest self-deception: motivated reasoning, i.e. realizing when we’re weighting evidence based on what we WANT to be true.

It’s also everything popular nonfiction should be: clear, well-written, thoughtful, funny, & full of stories. 2/9
The author dispels some common misconceptions, like the fact that Abraham Lincoln’s “Team of Rivals” was effective, & that one can effectively get out of their bubble just by turning on left-wing or right-wing radio. 3/9
Read 11 tweets
27 Apr
NEW: Catching Up With Coddling Pt 17. Hearing disturbing reports of K-12 programming with no respect for the individuality of students or the diverse points of view of students, I created a beta version of 10 principles for a healthier K-12 system. 1/12

thefire.org/the-empowering…
1. No compelled speech, thought, or belief. It is usually bad to tell someone what they cannot say. It is usually far worse to tell someone what they must say, & it is always wrong to tell people what they must think or believe. 2/12
2. Respect for individuality, dissent, and the sanctity of conscience. American First Amendment law is replete with powerful statements about individual uniqueness, and respect for such uniqueness. 3/12
Read 14 tweets
3 Mar
A new “Catching Up With ‘Coddling’”! We’re looking at the effects of bureaucratization on campus. In other words, as colleges evolve into megacorporations, what does that mean for inquiry, education, & #freespeech? 1/21

thefire.org/catching-up-wi…
This is the TENTH part in the series where we revisit the topics in @JonHaidt & my 2018 book, “The Coddling of the American Mind,” with new data, developments, & caveats. 2/21

amzn.to/39w0DLr
In describing the relationship between bureaucratization & the decisions campuses make, we consider three basic frameworks: the narrow corporatism theory, the broader corporatism theory, & the strong corporatism theory. 3/21
Read 23 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(