Post Office annual report and accounts just dropped - this is the delayed 2019/2020 accounts which is when the Post Office were throwing the kitchen sink at the High Court litigation - the numbers and comments should be interesting:
"we recorded a statutory loss of £307 million, largely because of the cost of settling the Postmaster litigation in December 2019 and the related legal costs; £153 million we have allocated towards the Historical Shortfall Scheme settlements...
… Chief Executive Officer Nick Read said: “Maximising the potential of Postmasters should be the priority and we should behave accordingly. Sadly, this has not always been the case...
"The Post Office does not have a business without those working hard in branches every day, serving communities across the United Kingdom. Genuine value, for a business such as the Post Office, and one with an overarching social and public purpose, should not solely...
… be represented by its ability to generate profit [lucky!], important though that is. The real test is whether the business model enables our Postmasters to thrive – on that metric, we have more to do...
… . To be successful, we must see this as a partnership above all else – one in which we are preoccupied only by what helps our Postmasters thrive.”
This from Tim Parker, Chairman, who signed off on the Post Office’s disastrous strategy of trying to dismiss and crush the claimants case, using staff who tried to mislead the courts:
"As a Board, we accept that this period has also been an extraordinarily painful one...
… as we have had to face up to the shortcomings of the business in its dealings with some Postmasters in preceding years. On behalf of the Post Office, I would again like to express my sincere apology to those affected….
… We will, of course, honour the commitments we have made in settling the litigation [not sure why he feels the need to make a virtue of this - might the PO have tried to get round them?]....
… We have established an Historical Matter Business Unit to focus on ensuring that the affected Postmasters receive redress. We understand the need for the Post Office to go much further in addressing the underlying flaws...
… and imbalances, and to make sure that our systems are fit for purpose."
Back to the CEO:
"I am pleased to be the new Chief Executive of a business with the customer trust, social relevance, and commercial promise which the Post Office has in abundance. However, this sense of excitement is tempered by the group litigation...
…. between some Postmasters and Post Office Limited which was still continuing as I joined. The litigation needed addressing, and with the support of our shareholder, in December 2019, we were pleased to be able to reach a joint settlement...
… with the Justice For Subpostmasters Alliance. Apologising publicly to the Postmasters affected and to enable the redress they deserve is as important as the settlement."
This is interesting - still Nick Read:
"there is a cultural dissonance within Post Office. There is, and has been, a divide in the way the business operates, borne of a misunderstanding of the relationship between Post Office Limited and Postmasters...
… Maximising the potential of Postmasters should be the priority and we should behave accordingly. Sadly, this has not always been the case.
For historical reasons, safeguarding and promoting the interests of our Postmasters...
… was not given enough priority. The urgent task is to emerge from this scandal with clarity that Postmasters are at the heart of this business.”
He’s got a lot to do. Anecdotally most Post Office folk still think the SPMs are guilty. That’s how they prosecuted so...
… many and tried to cover it up. They were led to believe untill 11 Dec 2019 that they were either thieves or potential thieves and treated them accordingly.
"To be successful, we must see this as a partnership above all else one in which we are preoccupied only by what helps our Postmasters thrive. Our understanding and interpretation of the business model needs to be turned on its head.”
Wow...
… at least he recognises what his board, ministers, civil servants and his predecessor failed to notice.
The PO’s business model is fucked.
"I began my career in the army where I learned that ‘to serve is to lead’. We owe our Subpostmasters the same commitment and I thank them..
… and the colleagues that support them, for all they do for their communities each and every day.
Our purpose now, and for the years to come, is to serve.”
This is a really strong message to the staff of the Post Office. I doubt they’ll listen...
… I come from a military family and I’m a big fan of the values military service instils. Nick Read ought to talk to former RAF man @CastletonLee and former RAF man Richard Roll who were instrumental in exposing the Post Office’s appalling behaviour.
He also probably...
@CastletonLee …ought to think about the number of lives cut short by the actions of Post Office staff.
But not too hard, obviously. He’s got a business to run...
Good morning and welcome to Day of R v Hamilton and others at the Court of Appeal. Today we will hear argument for and against the three appellants referred by the CCRC to the court. The Post Office is opposing their appeals. Live-tweet thread to follow.
Yesterday’s court report and all three previous days transcripts can be found here: postofficetrial.com
All my work this week is crowdfunded. If you find any of the stuff of the website useful there is an option to contribute here:
… rewards include a forthcoming book on the scandal and access to the “secret” email - sent on an irregular basis when there are interesting things happening as the story moves through the courts, inquiry and parliament.
NEW: Johnny Depp has FAILED in his application to appeal the libel judgment which found The Sun newspaper’s allegation he engaged in domestic violence against Amber Heard was “substantially true”.
Mr Depp will not be able to take his legal case further on this issue and the High Court judgment of Mr Justice Nicol stands.
Today’s ruling will be posted shortly (if it’s not already) on the judiciary website here:
I am on my way to court 71 of the Royal Courts of Justice to hopefully pick up the Depp v NGN ruling on Mr Depp’s application to appeal the High Court libel judgment against him. Then it will be a question of legging it to court 4 for the resumption of the CoA Subpostmasters...
… hearing.
If Johnny Depp’s application fails, that is the end of the legal road for him in this country on whether or not The Sun’s article, which called him a “wife-beater” is substantially true.
Still meditating on this quote from the CEO of the Post Office today:
"Our understanding and interpretation of the business model needs to be turned on its head.”
This is because the Post Office always saw the government as its client - not its Subpostmasters.
The government gives the PO money and the PO oversees AND POLICES its distribution.
Subpostmasters were its risk.
But the government wanted profitability from the Post Office. So the Post Office sweated its only asset - its Subpostmasters - thinking of them more as slaves to be controlled rather than potential revenue drivers for the business.
Good morning and welcome to Day 3 of the Court of Appeal hearing into whether 42 former Subpostmasters should have their convictions quashed after being criminalised by the Post Office. This will be a tweet thread of proceedings, which start at 10.30am. Some housekeeping...
… Everything I tweet from court is a summary and/or paraphrase of what is being said. Nothing is a direct quote unless it is in “direct quotes”.
We have had two explosive days in court so far. On Monday we found out that the Post Office had ordered documents...
… pertaining to discussions about the reliability of Horizon (the Post Office IT system, evidence from which was used to prosecute Subpostmasters) should be shredded:
Welcome to Day 2 of R v Hamilton et al at the Court of Appeal. 42 former Subpostmasters hope to have their criminal convictions overturned. Here is Ms Hamilton arriving at the RCJ this morning flanked by her barrister Tim Moloney QC (l) and her solicitor, Neil Hudgell.
(thread)
Proceedings are due to start at 10.30am. Brian Altman QC will be speaking for the Post Office.
The clerk has informed us we will be observing the minute silence at noon in memory of the victims of COVID-19.
Seema Misra is in court today, as is Declan Salter, the new(ish) Post Office Director specifically charged with dealing with the fallout from this scandal. Neil Hudgell has taken his place in the gallery. Sam Tobin from the Press Association has to deal...