2/ Seroprevalence studies also indicate that we are under-detecting cases based on discordance b/w rtPCR and antibody studies; these numbers have varied at different time points in the year- all the way up to 10x by some measures at some time points #covid19
3/ One of the big questions is to what extent we have underlying immunity from un-detected cases, & to what extent that contributed to rapid declines in case numbers in January/Feb. Even so, that wouldn't be the whole story; physical distancing & other control measures matter.
4/ As we have seen many times, once you start to see reversal in trends, you likely have many more cases that are happening & going undetected still ('tip of the iceberg'); the infections you detect now likely happened a week or so ago depending on sx onset-->test interval
5/ Further delays between case detection --> hospitalization, given the clinical course of the disease.
In Michigan, we have seen now a reversal in cases AND hospitalizations; Connecticut, Massachusetts, NJ & others w/ similar reversals as well. #covid19
6/ While we are vaccinating fast, some states much faster/more efficiently than others, at this point- vaccinating alone without any other preventative measures will likely not prevent another surge in my opinion. Weather getting better in many places- we should take advantage
7/ Let this conversation not digress into lockdowns v no lockdowns; there is a lot in between. Avoid large indoor crowded poorly ventilated spaces if you/your loved ones are not vaccinated, esp if you have high risk people in your circles who are not vaccinated yet. #covid19
8/ Keep up masking esp in indoor crowded spaces in public; this is a very low hanging fruit; this won't be forever, but we need to bolster our vaccination efforts with all of our other prevention measures. Cloth+ surgical; or high filtration if you have it nytimes.com/2021/03/03/opi…
9/ In short, many of us are concerned.
I am also optimistic; we have vaccinated many of those who are highest risk of death (65+)-- although even here long way to go (see CDC data at link below broken down demographically)
10/ We have evidence in the real world that vaccines work extremely well; in medical centers, nursing homes, in countries like Israel that are far ahead of the pack.
Vaccines excellent at preventing severe disease/death; also reduce asymptomatic infections #covid19
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
2/ While proposed plans to simply isolate the elderly are largely unachievable/ not how societies fundamentally function-- what many of us do agree on is that vaccinating the elderly as a priority group is critical; and we are doing it well.
3/ With real world data from @CDCMMWR today showing significant protection even 2 weeks after just the 1st dose of mRNA vaccines, I am optimistic that we should see a further notable reduction in mortality even w/ subsequent #covid19 surges
Under real-world conditions, vaccine effectiveness of mRNA (Moderna, Pfizer) vaccines:
-90% after 2 doses
-80% after one dose (both measured 14 days after dose) #covid19
2/ "Prospective cohorts of 3,950 health care personnel, first responders, and other essential and frontline workers completed weekly SARS-CoV-2 testing for 13 consecutive weeks."
Data collected from eight U.S. locations during December 14, 2020–March 13, 2021 #covid19
3/ "CDC routinely tested for SARS-CoV-2 infections every week regardless of symptom status and at the onset of symptoms consistent with COVID-19–associated illness."
Gets at one of the biggest questions since the vaccines came out: extent of reduction in asymptomatic cases
1/ As I reflect on the arguments people have put forward regarding individual rights...
Those opposed to masks likely would *not be opposed* (before #covid9) to a restriction of someone coughing/sneezing in your face if they were sick
Yet, we know the logic here is the same
2/ With asymptomatic spread, it doesn’t take coughing/sneezing; it just takes talking/breathing in a public space near others to infect them
So- the rules of the game haven’t changed here
Your right to do certain things is still limited by how they harm other people
3/ Yet their seems to be a perception/misperception that having people wear a mask in public spaces during a respiratory pandemic is somehow a restriction on freedoms
Was interviewed for this @NPRGoatsandSoda piece on how pandemics exacerbate racism & xenophobia; these are not new forces- they constantly are brewing underneath & within our day to day lives. They were amplified during a global crisis. #covid19
2/ Also gets into forces within the global health sector that are both remnants and repackagings of our history of colonial exploitation— we need to more deeply reckon with this as US/European based “global health doctors”; during Covid19, many of us paused overseas work.
3/ This is not a criticism against individuals; it is a call to more deeply reconsider what outcomes academic global health systems are designed to create; and whether they are doing enough to promote global health equity. #covid19
Only when you hear actual stories of the struggles people are going through does it make it clear how problematic it is when we blame those who got sick because of what externally seems like “irresponsible” behavior.
2/ Caregivers of disabled family members who did not have the luxury to stay home; those working in factories where outbreaks are prevalent; we are still seeing these cases and treating them. This isn’t about lockdowns or no lockdowns- this is about creating better public health.
3/ This is about creating systems that can protect us during crises.
The false choice of lockdowns v no lockdowns has been birthed from politics, not public health.
Why is the idea of an actual public health strategy not being brought up in these debates? #covid19
Assessed #covid19 test positivity rates after 90 days in patients who tested positive previously— much less likely to have a positive result compared to those who tested negative previously.
2/ “Protection offered by prior infection was calculated as one minus the ratio of infection rate for positive patients divided by the infection rate for negative patients.”
3/ “Protection offered from prior infection was 81.8% (95% CI 76.6 to 85.8), and against symptomatic infection was 84.5% (95% CI 77.9 to 89.1). This protection increased over time.” #covid19