A fourth thread in my series calling out #Holyrood2021 election half truths, misleading nonsense & lies.

I'm focusing on a misleading claim by @theSNP about 'ending period poverty' for women. Also questioning just how 'committed' they are to improving the lives of women.
[1/12]
I want to focus specifically on the highlighted claim, where the SNP are claiming credit for 'ending period poverty' for women.

This features as part of a wider claim about 'improving the life chances of women' more generally.
Date of their tweet was April 2nd 2021.
[2/12]
➡️On ending period poverty for women

The heart of this boast by the SNP is the 'Period Products (Free Provision) (Scotland) Bill'; which was unanimously passed into law in November 2020.

Unanimous! Great, so the SNP deserve the credit you might think...but wait...
[3/12]
The 'Products (Free Provision) (Scotland) Bill' was originally introduced not by the SNP, but by Labour's @MonicaLennon7. She has been campaigning to end period poverty since 2016.

And there is more...
[4/12]
The initial reaction of the SNP was to oppose her bill. So they're seeking credit now for a bill their initial reaction was to oppose.

It would never have happened without Ms Lennon in the first place.
[5/12]
Indeed the SNP only later came round to backing the bill after proposing several of their own amendments.

Ms Lennon's bill was already gathering cross-party support, compelling the SNP to finally back it. That is how the bill gained unanimous support.
[6/12]
So, if anyone deserves the credit for aiding the battle of 'ending period poverty' I'd say it is Scottish Labour's Monica Lennon.
[7/12]
➡️On the wider point about 'improving the life chances for women'

How can the SNP seriously claim to be committed to improving women's life chances when they excluded women from the protections of the Hate Crime & Public Order bill?'
[8/12]
Even SNP MSPs have been making this same criticism:

SNP MSP Joan McAlpine: "It will seem bizarre to many people that men who enjoy cross-dressing are protected from hate crime, but women are not."

Why were women excluded from protections of Hate Crime legislation?
[9/12]
Briefly, why does it matter that women are excluded from the legislation?

Women are victims of male crimes of aggression. Only a fool or someone malicious would dispute this.

Also, women are statistically more likely to be victims of crime than its perpetrators.
[10/12]
As a gay, I experience the constant low-level cultural background white-noise of casual homophobia which can occasionally be threatening, so I empathise with a female reality of constant low-level harassment, sexism & aggression (often not rising to levels of criminality)
[11/12
Sources:

'Period poverty: Scotland first in world to make period products free'
bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotla…

'Alex Massie: A bad week to pass law that ignores women'
thetimes.co.uk/article/alex-m…
[12/12]
➡️You can find part three of my series on the SNP's dodgy affordable housing claims here:

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dean M Thomson

Dean M Thomson Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DeanMThomson

4 Apr
A recent poll has made a big splash about the potential of this #Supermajority. But if we take a moment to just look at the polling trend lines, it's far too early to be making any sort of prognostication about any such thing.

Plus SNP majority? What SNP majority?

[1/11]
➡️Trend line since January 2021 - early April

Even to a layman's eyes, the downward trajectory of SNP support in regional polling is obvious.

If anyone is interested, the trendlines are local regressions (LOESS)
[2/11] Image
Here the same downward trajectory can also still be seen with SNP constituency polling; albeit their support on the constituency has a higher upper level it's declining from.
[3/11] Image
Read 11 tweets
2 Apr
So, what on earth is going on in Angus?

So far we've seen the SNP being told to repay £20,000 in #Covid19 support grants. Money originally intended to support small businesses, instead used to support nationalist politicking.
[1/6] Image
It's clear that Tim Rideout was teaching SNP supporters ways to 'game' the Covid business support grants.

But not just that, proceeding to also encourage a diversion of funds to his own group.
[2/6] Image
And his facebook boast "I have made over £50k for the indy cause today" stands ingloriously out there for all to see.
[3/6] Image
Read 8 tweets
1 Apr
Interesting in lots of ways.

Most obvious is Alba has further eroded SNP support on the list, but at only 3% unlikely to get anyone elected.

They might take enough support from the SNP to stop them getting list MSPs, while not getting enough switchers to get any Alba elected.
Also: constituency vote indicates that the SNP have not managed to turn the Hamilton Report moment into a strategic reset. Instead this poll, much like the general trend since October last year, suggests a continued slow unravelling of SNP support in the constituency numbers.
Only question is, will SNP support unravel fast enough to have an impact in the election in five weeks time? That I don't know.
Read 4 tweets
30 Mar
FM spoke of the importance of equality of opportunity in her 2016 priorities for Gov speech: “It will help to create not just a fairer nation, but one that is wealthier, healthier and happier”

Let’s look at food insecurity & childhood health to see if she delivered.
(1/11)
📈 Food Insecurity Rising 📈

The 2019 Scottish Health Survey showed that 9% of adults experienced food insecurity in the preceding 12 months.

While this is bad, it’s actually worse than you think.
(2/11)
The percentage food insecurity was 8% in 2017. It actually increased to 9% in 2018 and has stayed there through 2019. So food insecurity got worse under the SNP 2017-2019.
(3/11)
Read 12 tweets
29 Mar
Here is one for the polling lovers.

Let's try explain why the SNP are being so personal in their attacks on defectors to Alba; and what is worrying them.
[1/7]
1. Even before Alba launched their party, it was touch and go if the SNP would even secure the necessary extra list MSPs they craved to land a majority.

You can see, even before Alba launched, the SNP list support had been dropping significantly since August last year.
[2/7]
2. Constituency polling numbers over roughly the same time period have also been dropping.

SNP's fear that Alba dog-&-pony show could further erode SNP support on constituency. Divided parties lose elections, Alba stripping SNP of strategic control of media narrative.
[3/7]
Read 8 tweets
28 Mar
Nicola Sturgeon, correctly, praises her constituency. Glasgow southside is populated by good, honest people.

But what has the First Minister actually achieved for her constituency? Well, reviewing the evidence, I say #VoteAnas in Glasgow Southside
[1/12]
The Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) reveals Govanhill is ranked in the 10% ‘most deprived areas’ in income, education, housing and crime. Second most deprived in employment & health. (as of 2020)
[2/12]
If we flip to the 2016 SIMD map, we also see huge amounts of 'most deprived 10%' deprivation, around Govanhill. Some progress has been made, but not much. Not enough for those suffering severe deprivation.
[3/12]
Read 18 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!