LISTEN as highly influential Prof John Conly (upper left) of UCalgary, AHS CV19 sci advisory grp, Public Health Agency Canada, Chair WHO Infection Prevention & Control R&D Expert Grp. opposes N95 wearing citing acne harm vs @DFisman & @kprather88 precautionary principle. /1
"there's been decreased O2 concentrations in pregnant women" yeah, well here's the reference from one of his publications, dissected in fine form by @caruzycki /2
What's the risk of COVID in apartment buildings? This review covers much of the basics but I believe the prevalence is much higher ... (THREAD) /1 ncceh.ca/documents/evid…
We've long known air flows throughout a building despite walls and floors because there's strong driving forces and little attention to air sealing, both on the building envelope, and between units. /2
Figure: Ueno, Lstiburek, Bergey 2012 buildingscience.com/documents/bare…
The three driving pressure forces are: Wind, Stack (chimney) effect, and Mechanical (both negative and positive). /3
Figure: Air Leakage Control for Multi-Unit Residential Buildings, CMHC 2017 agency.coop/media/747/down…
#COVIDCO2 readings in an Ottawa classroom. Never reached a steady state. At 3152 ppm every breath contains 7.2% of other people's breath‼️‼️ 🤮. #DontShareYourAir#Onted
Classroom has below 0.4 air changes per hour.
For COVID, air changes from HEPA filtration are equivalent to outdoor air. Typical classroom portable HEPA air cleaner:
400 CFM on max at 65 dB adds 2.7 ACH
200 CFM on med at 55 dB adds 1.3 ACH.
Two on med would be 58 dB.
BUT there's still the cognitive impact of 3000ppm!
/2
Here's the back-calculation assumptions used to reach 0.4 ACH in a classroom. I'm assuming 12 foot ceilings for an older naturally ventilated school. Other values are typical as well. The calculator throws an exception in red at 19 students, but not at 18.
/3
CBC Marketplace and UofT's Dr Jeffrey Siegel tested 3 samples of 5 models of air purifier, including the DIY box fan with MERV-11 filter, which was better than the Dyson #filtrationcbc.ca/news/business/…
The Marketplace/UofT tests did not consider how loud the air purifier is on its highest setting, which can be a limiting factor for practical use. cbc.ca/news/business/…
Also consider the Clean Air Delivery Rate per Watt of power. ENERGY STAR air purifiers are tested for both.
Stick to the basics of filtration. Beware of some technologies used by portable air cleaners: Ionizers, UV-PCO and other names may claim to remove or destroy contaminants but may convert them to other compounds that may be harmful
Link (PDF): ashrae.org/file%20library…
/2
Good example of sizing a portable air cleaner for a classroom with a MERV-8 filter already present in the HVAC system to achieve 6 air changes per hour equivalent.
Link (PDF): ashrae.org/file%20library…
/3
HRAI has also reached out to school boards and Education Ministries Canada-wide to ensure decisions concerning #ventilation and #IAQ in schools are informed by the best available information.