1/ In the 1920's, Germany experienced hyperinflation because it had a large amount of public debt from World War 1, which its central bank covered by printing money. The central bank governor sought to "buy time" for the politicians.

I see so much of Lebanon in there. 👇
** The excerpts below are from the book "Lords of Finance" by Liaquat Ahamed about the role of central bankers in the period between World War 1 and World War 2.

The passages are not that long. I really recommend reading them.
2/ The central bank governor allowed the Reichsbank to keep printing money to fund the public sector (for Leb, this could include the Govt + BDL debts, as is happening now). People wondered why he never "stopped the printers".

Intentional or ignorance?
3/ The real reason is subtler, as it always is:
4/ He sought to "buy time" for the politicians. It failed. Eventually, Germany hit a trigger point and the currency totally fell apart.

Sound familiar?
5/ He never admitted to his mistakes and, eventually, the currency became worthless, and commerce became impossible.
6/ He refused to take responsibility for his role in the crisis and change course. Instead, he dug in, blamed others, and "hid the losses" by giving the illusion of solvency.

This is the consequence of pretending there are no losses that need to sorted out.
7/ Outside observers noted that it would be impossible to hope for a recovery "unless power is taken entirely from the lunatics presently in charge."
8/ How was this affecting the average German citizens?

"Fresh Dollar" concept, whereby people earning foreign income live luxuriously because of the currency devaluation, while locals suffer.
9/ Destruction of the middle class: doctors, civil servants, teachers, etc. become destitute.
10/ A strange mental illness emerged because of the hyperinflation: Cypher Stroke.

Even your average housewife began to closely track the hourly exchange rate (addeh el dollar?).

Eventually, people dropped the German Mark and turned to barter or foreign currencies.
11/ Beneficiaries of the crisis: "Speculators" and "Profiteers from Imported Commodities".

Dollar mad3oom? Politicians and others with money abroad buying up assets (and people) in Lebanon at fire sale prices? Someone always benefits.
12/ The "Rise of Extremism" and "Destruction of Social Values".

You all know what happened soon after this episode in Germany.
13/ Keynes made the following observations at the time: The End of Civilization.

In the longer text, he's referring to the war, but fundamentally he's referring to the "incompetent" & "wicked" politicians' refusal to do anything to stop the accumulation of losses.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Mike Azar

Mike Azar Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @AzarsTweets

12 Apr
1/ The first nuclear power plant in the Arab world began commercial operations in UAE last week. Our firm acted as financial advisor to the lenders for this groundbreaking $25+bn project. What does it take to develop & finance a complex nuclear project?

reuters.com/article/us-emi…
2/ We faced multiple challenges in structuring this and other (very rare) new nuclear project financings over the last 15 years. I'll describe a few general challenges related to nuclear financings, from a bank's perspective.
3/ Construction risk (delays and cost overruns). Nuclear projects are notorious for experiencing large cost overruns and delays.

A nuclear project in Georgia, USA has nearly doubled in cost ($14 bn to $24bn+) and is more than 5 years delayed. It's still not complete.
Read 24 tweets
10 Apr
1/ Head of Budget and Finance Committee @IbrahimKanaan accuses unnamed Govt advisors/others of having purchased Credit Default Swaps (CDS) on Leb Eurobonds and then pushed for default to make a profit. Any trader could've explained to him why this is far-fetched had he only asked
2/ I suggest the MP hire advisers as these are technical topics and we can't keep wasting time on this nonsense over and over again.

While not my job, I did the research for anyone who's interested.
3/ As most of you know, CDS is like an insurance product. The CDS Buyer gets paid out by the CDS Seller if there is a default on the bonds. To keep it simple, the Buyer pays the Seller a fee or premium to buy this insurance.
Read 16 tweets
5 Feb
1/ BDL appears to be proposing that all official intl humanitarian aid (~$1.5bn in 2021) be channeled through BDL and given to recipients in LBP at a rate of 6,200 LBP. BDL says this will allow it to sustain the 1500/3900 subsidy longer. It's a gross misuse of humanitarian aid.
2/ Firstly, as we've said before, the issue is HOW the $ are being used. If the $ are used to sustain the peg, a large portion of which benefits monopolies, smugglers, money launderers, &the wealthy, then the value of the aid is NOT going to the people it's meant to help. For ex:
3/ It doesn't matter if the Govt/BDL gives recipients the aid at a rate of 9,000 LBP! If the actual real $ are squandered, then the country is losing regardless of the rate it gets because the impact will be further inflation.
Read 18 tweets
3 Feb
1/ The Leb financial crisis in one chart. We tend to focus on the blue bar (how the $ were spent to maintain the peg), but that misses half the story. It's not only about why the blue bar decreased, but why the red bar increased (why deposits are so high)? The ratio is the story
2/ The problem is that the ratio of dollars remaining in the system is low *relative to* the amount of deposits that those dollars are needed to cover. It's not that dollars are low in some absolute sense, it's the ratio of the two.
3/ Why are deposits (red bar) so high? Mainly the gov't fiscal deficit financed by BDL and BDL losses due to excessive interest it paid banks on their deposits. BDL had to create new LBP to cover these expenses and this caused the amount of deposits to explode.
Read 10 tweets
20 Jan
The 2020 estimate for remittance inflows to Lebanon aren't that surprising (remittances tend to be stable). But, they are down over the last 5-yrs, worse than comparable countries. And, in 2020 vs. 2019, they are down around the average for the top remittance recipient countries.
So Lebanon performed around the average in terms of remittance inflows in 2020v2019 at a time when the country is in deep trouble with the figure possibly inflated, as @lebfinance mentioned, by many sending money to close out loans (plus after the explosion, etc.).
It is striking that BDL reserves continue to fall despite this level of remittances and the absolutely severe reduction in imports we've seen. It would seem that these $ are not making their way into the financial system (b/c we haven't even started the restructuring process).
Read 8 tweets
4 Jan
I rarely talk about my day job, but a project I've been working on for 5 yrs just won "Global Deal of the Year" for 2020. It's a $20+ bn gas project in Mozambique, the largest investment ever in Africa, all during a pandemic & only 3 yrs after Moz defaulted on its Eurobonds. 1/
Mozambique, a country with limited means, defaulted on its debt, hired intl advisors, restructured its debt, did a forensic audit, negotiated an IMF program, all while setting up the legal/regulatory framework for an incredibly complex multi-billion $ new industry. 2/
This was possible b/c Moz has a Gov't which hires the right advisors for the job & listens to them. They didn't drown the population in misinformation, they didn't put ego & personal interest ahead of the national interest, they didn't use clientelism to destroy the economy. 3/
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!