Just tuned in to @LinaMKhan's confirmation hearing. Of course, Wicker focuses on whether social media can be treated as common carriers, citing Justice Thomas
Apples & oranges: Lina's paper was about *economic* regulation of Amazon, not content moderation, protected by the 1A
Unfortunately, she didn't make that distinction clear, just saying that we need to be "a bit market specific"
And I explain the line between regulating economic conduct (what Dems are focused on) and regulating editorial judgments (what Republicans are focused on here: gaidigitalreport.com/2020/10/04/sec…
Sen Thune (R) & former Sen Nelson (D) have now moved on to the bipartisan "Show & Tell" portion of today's Senate Commerce Committee confirmation hearing
If it helps drain the venom from our politics, great 👏
Fun with confirmation hearings!: every time someone says "Packers & Stockyards Act," take drink!
Moran: social media sites should be punished for deceiving consumers by not delivering on their promises to provide an open, fair platform
Um, they also promise to block hate speech, misinformation, etc, etc
The FTC doesn't police drawing lines in such non-commercial speech
See Section IV of this paper, explaining why the FTC will no more sue websites for not being "fair" or "neutral" than it would sue Fox News for not being "fair & balanced" gaidigitalreport.com/2020/10/04/sec…
Apparently, the one thing that Senators find more interesting than bashing "Big Tech" is....
talking to a Senator-ASTRONAUT about SPACE
Cruz: the FTC should be doing more to rein in the censorship of big tech companies and the imposition of their views on the free marketplace of ideas
No, there is literally nothing the FTC can do about speech. It polices *economic conduct,* not editorial judgments.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Klobuchar emphasizes that Apple won't allow sideloading of apps onto iOS photos (as Google does)
But Apple has, since 2018, allowed progressive web apps (PWAs) to run in the Safari mobile browser
And PWAs are increasingly able to duplicate the functionality of "native" apps
PWAs have some significant advantages over native apps (found in app stores): notably, you can build the same app to run on all major web browsers (except Firefox), so you don't have to build separate Android and iOS versions
Republicans have relentlessly attacked "Big Tech" companies for "censoring" conservatives
Under pressure, Apple has caved, reinstating the #Parler app even though, for example, openly Nazi content is still readily available on the site. And that's just the tip of the iceberg...
It's hard to know what's really on Parler because the site doesn't allow full text search: unlike on Facebook or Twitter, you can only search for user names and hashtags
Even before the January 6 insurrection, Parler censored certain hashtags, like the N-Word
This was the bare minimum of what it took to create the veneer of respectability required to pretend that the site wasn't the cesspool of hate speech that it actually is
Parler seems to have expanded the list of banned hashtags to include other code words (eg "skittles"=Muslims)
Hawley isn't subtle about the motive for the bill: he's trying to use #antitrust law to retaliate against a private company for exercising editorial judgment in a way that Hawley doesn't like
The bill's text isn't out yet, but "online hosting services" may well cover other Internet infrastructure, including hosting domain names & "hosting" apps in the Play store
At noon, Prof. Hamburger will repeat his nonsense claims that the First Amendment is a sword by which government can force private websites to host speech they find reprehensible.
Websites have the same First Amendment rights as parade organizers, newspapers or other media to exclude speech they find objectionable, however "unfair" their decisions may be
It's just not the government's job to second-guess those content moderation decisions
Republicans used to understand this. They spent 80 years attacking Fairness Doctrine mandates for broadcasting, yet are now demanding a Fairness Doctrine of their own
Here's Rep @CathyMcMorris Rodgers firmly rejecting such nonsense in late 2019