With all the debate and angst within @UKLabour and the calls from Corbynite MPs for shift back to the left, it's worth taking a little magical history tour. Let's go back exactly 40 years - to the Labour victory in the Greater London Council elections of 7 May 1981... 1/18
2/18 While many will recall that this was the start of Ken Livingstone's notorious leftist administration at County Hall, what is less well remembered is that the campaign was fought by a moderate leader - Andrew McIntosh. He was toppled the next day by the hard left.
3/18 The 'palace coup' in the GLC Labour Group ensured that Livingstone became leader and a coterie of other left-wingers (John McDonnell, Paul Boateng, Valerie Wise, Dave Wetzel and others) were set to become influential committee chairs.
4/18 It was an era where the GLC had immensely more power than the GLA today and its leader was arguably more powerful than today's Mayor. The authority not only ran public transport and the fire brigade but managed major housing stock, controlled parks and historic buildings.
5/18 Strangely, it didn't have responsibility for the police, at at time when the Home Office retained direct control over the Met. But of course that didn't stop it having its own Police Committee and intervening regularly - particularly with its opposition to the 1984 PACE Act.
6/18 The history of this period is now enshrined in folklore. Livingstone ran extensive campaigns against the Thatcher government, funded by ratepayers. Like other so-called 'loony left' authorities of the era, the GLC also campaigned on foreign policy issues and supported CND.
7/18 Eventually, the Thatcher government decided the GLC needed to be abolished and there was a lengthy campaign to save the authority. In Parliament, this involved co-opting the Lords to try to obstruct the will of the right-wing majority in the Commons.
8/18 In 1986, I joined many thousands on the South Bank as we bid goodbye to the GLC and Ken Livingstone led us in a rendition of 'We'll Meet Again'. Because yes, dear thread reader, I had been a fan. In my teens, I was attracted to Red Ken's brand of politics.
9/18 What was it that lured me in? I liked the radicalism, the lack of compromise, the early emphasis on what would now be called identity politics. I was strongly opposed to Thatcher and Reagan and what they stood for. But I also liked the administration's style and chutzpah.
10/18 Livingstone did not stand on ceremony. He really did travel on the tube. He opened up County Hall and let the public in. He'd even be happy to chat to people like me - geeky political teenagers.
11/18 Dave Wetzel, the GLC Transport Chief, hand wrote his letters in red pen and signed them 'Yours for socialism, Dave'. There was a whiff of the Paris Commune about it all, although probably with a fair amount of trainspotters' convention layered on top.
12/18 As the 80s wore on, I became increasingly disillusioned with this weird strand of urban leftism. Partly because I was encountering the hardline Trotskyist entryists in @UKLabour, CND, NUS and other environments. And I could see the disruptive negativity of the extremists.
13/18 My own politics started to shift. I went on a journey, which would take me to the Labour centre ground by the end of the decade and make me a full-scale convert to proto-Blairism after the unimaginably disastrous election of 1992.
14/18 It was around this time I became the controversial young Chair of what is now @Keir_Starmer's Constituency Labour Party in Holborn & St Pancras. I'd later stand as a parliamentary candidate in the 1997 and 2001 general elections.
15/18 The moral of this story? The lesson from this history? Well, the world changed. I changed. But the hard left never changed. They are the same in 2021 as they were in 1981. They were losers then - over the GLC, the miners' strike, Wapping - and they are losers now.
16/18 They were factionalist and self-obsessed back then. They are just the same today. They claimed their politics were a winning formula in the 1980s. And they claim exactly the same politics are a winning formula in the 2020s.
17/18 @UKLabour has a lot of soul-searching to do. There are no easy fixes to the predicament the party finds itself in. But one thing is absolutely clear. There can be no turning back to the agenda Corbyn, Abbott and GLC veteran McDonnell.
18/18 These people helped write off the 80s for Labour. They were resurrected from the political crypt to plunge the party into a nightmare between 2015 and 2019. Never again. The party has to learn. It must move on. For good.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with philwoodford

philwoodford Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @philwoodford

9 May
In political life, there is inevitably a difference between what people are able to say publicly and think privately. As I haven’t been involved in frontline @UKLabour politics for many years, I am happy to say publicly what many moderates will be thinking to themselves. 1/16
2/16 Starmer is a decent enough guy. Bright, well meaning, broadly on the right side of most major political debates. But we know in our water we’re probably not looking at a Prime Minister. Something is missing. Perhaps an intangible quality.
3/16 Miliband and Kinnock were decent, intelligent men who lacked a certain something too. There’s a pattern here that @UKLabour probably needs to address.
Read 16 tweets
16 Dec 20
Ok, I know I'm going to stir up some controversy here and probably should live the quite life, but here goes. I think that when we come to write the history of the Covid pandemic, many of the trite assumptions of the first six, eight, ten months may prove to be myths. 1/15
2/15 We heard a lot about Germany and South Korea, for instance. If only we'd followed their example, we'd have done so much better. Today, ICU beds in Seoul are near capacity. Lockdown looms for the first time. edition.cnn.com/2020/12/16/asi…
3/15 The German response has been hampered by the country's federal political structure - laissez-faire Länder resisting more stringent lockdown measures proposed by Merkel's government. Now, hundreds of deaths a day. theguardian.com/world/2020/dec…
Read 16 tweets
15 Dec 20
Some thoughts on the debate over the UK Xmas rona regulations. First of all, public opinion is ostensibly against relaxation, which gives the government some wriggle room. 57% say the tier system should remain in place over the festive period. Interesting. 1/8
2/8 I suspect this is the politically correct answer to pollsters and that a proportion of people who oppose the non-disty Christy *would* meet up with people outside their bubble if the government continues to say that it is ok. But they kind of hope they'll be *told* it's not.
3/8 Here's the thing. These decisions are actually very difficult. My father is 84, has advanced Parkinson's. My father-in-law is 88, profoundly deaf, and on his own. I don't want them put at risk, but I don't want them isolated at Christmas.
Read 8 tweets
17 Sep 20
It's important to keep watching the Trump presidential campaign and the deranged incumbent's pronouncements. In his Twitter feed, there is an ever-increasing emphasis on the fact that any election result cannot be trusted and that the result may never be clear. 1/7
2/7 I think the calculation in the Trump camp is that the election is already lost because of Covid and the economic slump. They must have a lot of private polling from the swing states suggesting that scraping a win in the electoral college is now a real long shot.
3/7 They'll throw all they can at Biden. He's Sleepy Joe, who's never let out of the basement. He's in the grip of the hard left. Harris is the real power behind the throne. And a vote for the Democrats is a vote for Antifa and anarchy. But they know it won't be enough.
Read 7 tweets
26 Jul 20
I think the decision to abruptly reverse the air corridor to Spain will be another turning point for trust in the government. It seems strange to draw a parallel with Dominic Cummings, but at a psychological level, these issues are related. 1/10
2/10 Behavioural scientists talked about the issue of equity at the time of the Barnard Castle affair. We obey the rules because we believe - perhaps naively - that they apply equally to everyone. When it's clear they don't, we feel anger and resentment. Trust has broken down.
3/10 A slightly different thing is happening with the quarantine rules, but it's clearly connected. People flew out to Spain having been told they *wouldn't* have to self-isolate on return. They are now being told that the goalposts have shifted and will resent it.
Read 10 tweets
29 Jun 20
Parallels with the 1980s are always front of mind with @UKLabour's predicament. When Kinnock took over in 1983, he had broad support from sections of the left, but he soon ran into conflict with the hardliners. The media labelled them as the 'loony left'. 1/20
2/20 This notorious faction had a strong foothold in local government - particularly in London (Ken Livingstone's GLC, Ted Knight's Lambeth etc) - and pursued policies that would be instantly familiar to young Corbynistas now.
3/20 The formula was opposition to all cuts (the word for austerity in the 80s) to the point of defying the law; opposition to nuclear weapons; support for liberation struggles; for leftist regimes around the world; an obsession with Ireland, Palestine and socialist Nicaragua.
Read 20 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(